Most people think furnace problems start at the equipment.
- Cold rooms? Must be the furnace.
- High bills? Must be the furnace.
- Short cycling? Definitely the furnace.
But after years of working with homeowners, I’ve discovered something surprising:
Most furnace problems don’t start at the furnace. They start with sizing.
If your furnace is too big, it blasts your home with more heat than the ducts or rooms can handle. If it's too small, it runs nonstop, struggling to catch up. In both cases, you lose comfort, efficiency, and money.
80,000 BTU 96% AFUE Upflow/Horizontal Two Stage Goodman Gas Furnace - GR9T960804CN
That’s why I built the 8-Point Energy Waste Calculator—a simple data-based method to diagnose your furnace size before you spend thousands on upgrades, ductwork, or a complete system replacement.
This is the calculator I use when a homeowner calls and says:
-
“My furnace doesn’t feel right.”
-
“The rooms aren’t consistent.”
-
“My gas bill doubled this winter.”
-
“I think my furnace is too big…but I’m not sure.”
-
“It feels like it runs all the time.”
Armed with just this 8-point checklist and a week’s worth of observations, you can determine if your furnace is oversized, undersized, or perfectly matched to your home.
Let’s dive in.
🧊 1. The Real Problem: Improper Furnace Sizing Is Shockingly Common
Most homes suffer from mis-sizing—either too big or too small—because of how HVAC decisions are typically made. A contractor or builder often chooses a furnace using:
-
A rough square footage estimate
-
“Standard” rules of thumb
-
Whatever size they happen to keep in stock
-
“The last house on this street used a 100k, so this one will too”
-
Outdated Manual J assumptions
But here’s the truth:
❗ A furnace that is even 25% off the correct size will waste energy every single day.
It either:
-
Short cycles (oversized)
-
Runs endlessly (undersized)
-
Delivers uneven temperatures
-
Creates hot-cold pockets
-
Stresses ductwork
-
Wastes gas and electricity
Most homeowners blame the equipment.
But 7 out of 10 times, it’s the sizing—not the furnace.
🌡️ 2. Oversized Furnaces: The Silent Energy Hogs
An oversized furnace “heats too fast,” which sounds good—until you understand what fast heating does to a home.
🔥 Signs your furnace is oversized:
-
It shuts off after 3–7 minutes
-
The thermostat overshoots the target temp
-
You hear loud whooshing from vents
-
Rooms heat unevenly (warm downstairs, cool upstairs)
-
The system starts and stops constantly
-
The furnace never runs long enough to even out the house
-
Your home is humid in summer but desert-dry in winter
Why this wastes energy:
Oversizing causes something called short cycling, where the furnace turns on and off constantly. This burns more fuel, stresses components, and makes comfort unpredictable.
Oversized furnaces also:
-
Dump heat before ducts can distribute it
-
Cause temperature swings
-
Increase airflow noise
-
Reduce heat exchanger lifespan
-
Waste gas on ignition cycles
It’s like using a race car for stop-and-go traffic.
❄️ 3. Undersized Furnaces: The Struggling Workhorses
An undersized furnace has the opposite problem: it can’t keep up.
🧊 Signs your furnace is undersized:
-
Runs for 45 minutes or more each cycle
-
Struggles to reach setpoint on cold days
-
Some rooms never get warm
-
Your thermostat stays stuck at 67°F even when set to 72°F
-
It takes hours to recover after a setback
-
You see a huge spike in gas bills during cold snaps
Why this wastes energy:
-
The furnace burns fuel for long stretches without warming the home effectively
-
The system stays in “max effort mode”
-
Return air stays cold, forcing hotter supply temperatures
-
Ductwork expands and contracts excessively
-
The thermostat never stabilizes, so heating never balances
This is like flooring the gas pedal on a car that can’t get above 30 mph.
🧮 4. Introducing Samantha’s 8-Point Energy Waste Calculator
This calculator doesn’t guess.
It measures exactly how your furnace behaves in the real world.
Each category gets a score from 0 to 5 (0 = no problem, 5 = severe problem).
Add them up, and you get your Energy Waste Score (EWS) out of 40.
The higher your score, the more mis-sized your furnace likely is.
Let’s walk through each point.
1️⃣ Point 1 — Runtime Balance (0–5 points)
A correctly sized furnace should run:
-
10–20 minutes per cycle
-
2–3 cycles per hour
This keeps temperatures steady without swings.
Oversized score:
-
Runs 3–8 minutes
-
Cycles 4–6 times per hour
Undersized score:
-
Cycles last 30–60+ minutes
-
Furnace runs nearly nonstop during cold weather
Score it:
-
0–1 → Perfect
-
2–3 → Slight imbalance
-
4–5 → Severe mis-sizing
2️⃣ Point 2 — Temperature Drift Test (0–5 points)
This is the gold-standard test used by energy auditors nationwide.
How to run it:
-
Set your thermostat to 65°F overnight.
-
Note the lowest indoor temperature.
-
Compare it to the outdoor low (e.g., via National Weather Service).
https://www.weather.gov/wrh/climate
Drift scoring:
-
1–3°F drop → Tight envelope
-
4–6°F drop → Mild heat loss
-
7–10°F drop → High heat loss
-
10°F+ drop → Extreme heat loss
Oversized & undersized furnaces both worsen drift—for opposite reasons.
3️⃣ Point 3 — Recovery Curve (0–5 points)
This tests how long your furnace needs to bring your home from 65°F to 70°F.
Normal:
-
10–20 minutes
Oversized:
-
4–8 minutes (too fast → short cycling)
Undersized:
-
30–60+ minutes
-
Sometimes never recovers fully
Score based on how far from normal your home is.
4️⃣ Point 4 — Room-to-Room Delta (0–5 points)
Use simple temperature sensors or a smart system to measure each room.
Ideal:
-
Rooms differ by ≤ 2°F
Problem zones:
-
3–5°F difference → mild imbalance
-
6–9°F difference → airflow or mis-sizing issue
-
10°F+ swing → severe oversizing/undersizing
Oversized furnaces cause hot spots. Undersized furnaces cause cold zones.
This difference scores very high in many homes.
5️⃣ Point 5 — Vent Temperature Rise (0–5 points)
Measured using a cheap IR thermometer.
Typical furnace temp rise: 35–65°F
Oversized furnace symptoms:
-
High rise (65–90°F) → overheating, short cycle
Undersized symptoms:
-
Low rise (20–35°F) → furnace cannot deliver adequate heat
Score based on how far outside the ideal your system falls.
6️⃣ Point 6 — Humidity Behavior (0–5 points)
Humidity reveals infiltration and system sizing interactions.
Use a humidity sensor or smart thermostat.
Ideal winter humidity:
35–45%
Oversized furnace:
-
Drops humidity rapidly (“desert dryness”)
-
Air changes too fast for moisture retention
Undersized furnace:
-
Causes humidity stagnation
-
Cold rooms push moisture out of the air
Score based on severity of humidity swings.
7️⃣ Point 7 — Noise & Airflow Clues (0–5 points)
Noise often reveals furnace mis-sizing.
Oversized furnace noise:
-
Loud vent blast
-
Duct popping
-
High register velocity
-
“Jet engine” effect
Undersized furnace noise:
-
Weak airflow
-
Slow warm-up from vents
-
Whistling returns
Score based on how loud or weak ducts behave.
External reference on duct performance:
https://www.acca.org/hvac/technical/manuals
8️⃣ Point 8 — Energy Bill Pattern (0–5 points)
This is your financial scoreboard.
Compare:
-
December vs January gas usage
-
Year-over-year winter bills
-
Bills during cold snaps vs mild weeks
Oversized furnace:
-
Bills spike even on mild days
-
Trending upward year after year
-
High therms despite low runtime
Undersized furnace:
-
Bills skyrocket during cold snaps
-
System burns fuel nonstop
-
You see 30–60% increases rapidly
Score based on gas/electric bill abnormalities.
🧾 Your Total Energy Waste Score
Add up all eight categories.
0–10: Your furnace is likely sized correctly
You may have minor duct issues, but sizing is not your main problem.
11–20: Mild mis-sizing
Common in older homes. Comfort isn’t perfect, but efficiency isn’t terrible.
21–30: Major mis-sizing
Your home is wasting a noticeable amount of energy. Comfort is probably poor.
31–40: Severe mis-sizing → system likely needs correction
Your furnace is either too big or too small by at least 25–60%.
Time to take action.
🔧 If Your Furnace Is Undersized: Samantha’s Recommended Fixes
Before replacing anything, check these first:
✔ Check the air filter
A clogged filter can mimic undersizing.
✔ Clean return and supply grills
Blocked vents make airflow appear weak.
✔ Check for duct leaks
Up to 30% of heat is lost through leaky ducts.
Reference: U.S. DOE — Energy Saver
https://www.energy.gov/energysaver
✔ Seal attic bypass points
Especially around recessed lighting.
✔ Inspect window & door weatherstripping
Undersized symptoms are often infiltration issues.
✔ Reduce thermostat setbacks
Large drops overnight create big recovery loads.
✔ Consider a two-stage or variable furnace
A properly sized two-stage system solves undersizing by matching output to demand.
🔥 If Your Furnace Is Oversized: Samantha’s Recommended Fixes
Before replacing, try these:
✔ Reduce airflow velocity (blower speed)
Slowing airflow eases short cycling.
✔ Increase setback temperature thresholds
Oversized systems overshoot less when temperature swings are smaller.
✔ Open more vents
Give the furnace more breathing room.
✔ Add return air pathways
Oversizing often exposes return deficiencies.
✔ Use thermostat staging or smart thermostat algorithms
This prevents “slam heating.”
✔ Consider replacing with a modulating furnace
Modulating systems prevent future oversizing issues by adjusting output 1% at a time.
🧠 Why Oversizing and Undersizing Often Mislead Homeowners
If your home has:
-
Poor insulation
-
Drafty windows
-
Leaky ducts
-
Bad thermostat placement
-
Closed interior doors
-
Inconsistent usage patterns
-
Sun-exposed rooms
…your home can look like it has a furnace problem when it’s really a house problem.
Likewise, a perfectly sized furnace can look wrong if:
-
The ducts choke airflow
-
Return air is insufficient
-
Supply ducts are too small
-
A bedroom is isolated
-
The thermostat is near a heat source
This is why the 8-Point Energy Waste Calculator is so important. It untangles what problem you actually have.
🎯 Final Recommendation: Run This Calculator Before You Buy Anything
Before you:
-
Install a new furnace
-
Buy a heat pump
-
Replace ductwork
-
Modify your HVAC system
-
Upgrade to a smart thermostat
Run this 8-point diagnostic. It will tell you:
-
Whether your furnace is the right size
-
Whether your home is bleeding heat
-
Whether duct airflow is the real issue
-
Whether your energy use is normal or excessive
-
Whether you need a two-stage or modulating system
-
Whether replacement is even necessary
Homeowners save thousands using this calculator before making big decisions.
Buy this on Amazon at: https://amzn.to/4hJt23t
In the next topic we will know more about: Samantha’s 3-Zone Strategy: How to Size a Two-Stage Furnace When Your Home Isn’t Built for Even Heating
