Jake’s Rule for Declaring a Furnace “Commissioned”
Most furnaces are declared “done” after one successful run.
Jake doesn’t trust that.
Because one cycle proves the furnace can start.
It does not prove the furnace is stable, repeatable, or ready to live in a real house with real power, real airflow, and real occupants.
That’s why Jake has a hard rule:
If it hasn’t completed three clean cycles, it isn’t commissioned.
Not “basically done.”
Not “working fine.”
Not “we’ll see how it goes.”
Not started.
This article explains why three cycles matter, what changes between each one, and how Jake uses repeatability—not luck—to decide when a furnace like the Goodman GR9S800803BN is actually ready to be handed off.
80,000 BTU 80% AFUE Upflow/Horizontal Single Stage Goodman Gas Furnace - GR9S800803BN
🧠 Why One Good Cycle Is the Most Dangerous Lie in HVAC
The first cycle is optimistic.
Everything is cold.
Nothing is stressed.
No component has been asked to repeat itself yet.
On cycle one:
-
Voltage is fresh
-
Draft hasn’t been challenged
-
Heat exchanger hasn’t expanded
-
Blower hasn’t heat-soaked
-
Control board hasn’t compared behavior yet
A furnace can pass cycle one and still be wrong in six different ways.
“Cycle one tells you it can run.
Cycles two and three tell you if it should.”
🔄 What Actually Changes Between Cycles
Furnaces don’t repeat cycles identically — even when nothing is wrong.
Jake knows this, and he watches how they change.
Across multiple cycles:
-
Metal expands and contracts
-
Voltage stabilizes (or doesn’t)
-
Draft improves (or falls apart)
-
Gas pressure drifts
-
Control logic adapts
The system reveals itself in patterns, not moments.
① Cycle One: Baseline Establishment
The first cycle answers one question:
Can the furnace complete a full ignition sequence safely?
Jake watches for:
-
Clean ignition
-
Stable flame
-
Proper inducer operation
-
Acceptable startup voltage
-
Normal blower ramp
But he does not relax.
Because this cycle is forgiving.
Problems often hide here.
② Cycle Two: Consistency Test
The second cycle is where most installers get uncomfortable.
Why?
Because this is where:
-
Voltage dips repeat
-
Draft timing shows variance
-
Flame sense changes slightly
-
Noise patterns emerge
-
Gas pressure behavior shifts
Jake compares cycle two directly against cycle one.
If anything changes noticeably, he stops and investigates.
“A furnace that can’t repeat itself isn’t reliable — it’s lucky.”
③ Cycle Three: Stress & Memory Lock-In
The third cycle is the decider.
By now:
-
The cabinet is warm
-
The heat exchanger has expanded
-
Components are closer to real operating conditions
-
The control board is establishing “normal”
This is when:
-
Borderline voltage causes lockouts
-
Weak flame sensing shows up
-
Pressure switch timing becomes critical
-
Blower delay hides or reveals airflow problems
If cycle three matches the first two, Jake is satisfied.
If it doesn’t — the system is not commissioned.
🧠 Control Boards Judge Patterns, Not Intentions
Modern control boards don’t care how confident the installer feels.
They observe:
-
Ignition timing
-
Flame proving speed
-
Voltage behavior
-
Pressure switch response
And they remember patterns.
Early instability teaches the board to tolerate bad behavior — until it can’t anymore.
This behavior is well documented in furnace control diagnostics
(ACHR News – Understanding Furnace Controls).
Jake makes sure the board learns good habits from day one.
⚡ Why Electrical Problems Love Cycle Two and Three
Voltage problems almost never appear on cycle one.
They show up when:
-
Igniters are hot
-
Motors are warm
-
Circuits are under repeated load
Jake measures voltage across all cycles because:
-
Shared circuits sag unpredictably
-
Loose neutrals worsen when warm
-
Grounds reveal themselves under repetition
This aligns with standard voltage-drop diagnostics used in HVAC electrical commissioning
(HVAC School – Voltage Drop Basics).
🌬️ Airflow Problems Don’t Announce Themselves Immediately
Airflow issues often behave like this:
-
Cycle one: seems fine
-
Cycle two: noise appears
-
Cycle three: temperature rise shifts
Why?
-
Ducts warm and flex
-
Filters load slightly
-
Static pressure changes with heat soak
Jake wants to see airflow behave consistently across cycles, not just once.
ACCA airflow guidance emphasizes repeatable measurements over single readings
(ACCA Manual D Overview).
🔥 Gas Pressure Drift Shows Up Late — Not Early
Gas pressure almost never lies on cycle one.
It lies later.
After:
-
Regulators warm
-
Valves stabilize
-
Demand repeats
Jake rechecks manifold pressure across cycles because:
-
Drift often appears after sustained firing
-
Flame shape changes subtly
-
Noise increases gradually
Skipping later cycles means skipping the truth.
📝 Jake’s Three-Cycle Commissioning Checklist
Jake doesn’t rely on memory. He writes it down.
Across all three cycles, he records:
-
Ignition timing
-
Flame stability
-
Voltage under load
-
Static pressure behavior
-
Noise changes
-
Any adjustments made
If cycle three doesn’t match the first two, he does not leave.
🚫 The Three Commissioning Lies Jake Refuses to Accept
❌ “It started fine once”
Once doesn’t matter.
❌ “It’ll probably settle in”
Settling in is what causes callbacks.
❌ “The homeowner won’t notice”
The furnace will.
🧠 Why Callbacks Start at Cycle Four — Not Cycle One
Most startup-related callbacks happen weeks later.
That’s because:
-
Early instability becomes normalized
-
Stress accumulates quietly
-
Components wear unevenly
Three clean cycles prevent that chain reaction.
“Callbacks don’t come from bad furnaces.
They come from unfinished startups.”
🏁 What “Commissioned” Actually Means to Jake
To Jake, a commissioned furnace is one that:
-
Starts cleanly
-
Repeats behavior
-
Handles heat soak
-
Operates consistently under real load
Anything less is unfinished work.
🔚 Jake’s Final Word on the Three-Cycle Rule
A furnace doesn’t care how long you’ve been doing this.
It only cares whether:
-
You watched it repeat
-
You respected patterns
-
You waited for the truth
“Three clean cycles isn’t overkill.
It’s the minimum required for honesty.”
If it hasn’t passed three, it hasn’t started.
Buy this on Amazon at: https://amzn.to/3L2nAfF
In the next topic we will know more about: Startup Notes That Save Callbacks: What Jake Writes Down Before He Leaves
