Which One’s Right for Your Building?
You’re planning heating and cooling for a hotel, motel, or multifamily apartment building. The two big contenders? PTACs and mini splits.
As someone who’s installed both over the years, I’ll tell you right now—there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. But there is a better option depending on your goals: ease of maintenance, energy efficiency, upfront cost, or aesthetics.
Let’s break it down.
What Is a PTAC?
A Packaged Terminal Air Conditioner (PTAC) is a self-contained unit that goes through a wall. It heats and cools a single room—perfect for hotels or studio apartments.
The Amana Distinctions 14,700 BTU PTAC is a workhorse:
✅ 3.5kW electric heat
✅ Easy to install
✅ Built for high-volume use
It’s the standard in hospitality and assisted living facilities for good reason.
What Is a Mini Split?
A mini split system includes one outdoor condenser and one or more indoor units (called air handlers). Each indoor unit can control its own zone.
It’s ductless and quieter, but typically more complex and expensive to install.
🔗 U.S. Department of Energy – Ductless Mini-Split System Overview
PTAC vs Mini Split: A Quick Comparison
| Feature | PTAC | Mini Split |
|---|---|---|
| Cost (Per Room) | ✅ Lower | ❌ Higher |
| Ease of Installation | ✅ Wall Sleeve, Plug-In | ❌ Requires Refrigerant Lines, Mounting |
| Aesthetics | ❌ Bulkier | ✅ Sleek Wall-Mounts |
| Noise Level | ❌ Louder (Built-In Fan) | ✅ Quieter (Remote Compressor) |
| Maintenance | ✅ Quick Swaps | ❌ Requires HVAC Pro |
| Zoning Capabilities | ✅ One Room = One Unit | ✅ Advanced Zoning Possible |
| Energy Efficiency | Moderate | ✅ Higher SEER Ratings |
When PTAC Wins
-
Budget Projects: Renovating a motel or outfitting a mid-tier hotel? PTACs are cost-effective and easy to install.
-
Frequent Turnover: They’re simple to replace. If a unit fails, swap it without disturbing tenants.
-
Direct Room Access: No need to access indoor plumbing or shared ductwork.
🔧 Read More: ASHRAE’s PTAC Best Practices for Hospitality
When Mini Splits Make Sense
-
Luxury Builds: If you’re upgrading to a boutique hotel or high-end apartment, a mini split is quieter and more discreet.
-
Energy Efficiency Focus: Most mini splits boast SEER ratings over 20—good for green builds and long-term savings.
-
No Wall Space? PTACs require a large wall opening. Mini splits mount high on the wall and run refrigerant lines discreetly.
🔗 Mitsubishi Electric – Commercial Mini Split Systems
The Hybrid Approach
Some property owners use PTACs for standard rooms and mini splits for suites or management offices. This combo keeps costs low while providing premium comfort where needed.
Mike’s Bottom Line
If you’re running a 30-room motel and need fast installs at the lowest cost, go PTAC—specifically something durable like the Amana Distinctions 14,700 BTU model. If you’re developing high-end rentals and want that whisper-quiet experience, a mini split might be worth the upfront investment.
💡 Either way, always think about:
-
Maintenance staff experience
-
Energy usage goals
-
Tenant comfort expectations
Final Tips from Mike
-
PTACs are the go-to for economy and ease.
-
Mini splits deliver premium comfort, but cost more.
-
Make your decision based on scale, staff, and goals.
Need help picking the right PTAC? I’ve got your back—this Amana unit is one of the best values in the business for heating and cooling individual rooms reliably and affordably.
In the next topic you will read: How to Clean and Maintain a PTAC Unit Like a Pro
