0 comments

Amana Heat Pumps vs AC-Only Systems: What Homeowners Get Wrong

Mike Explains When Heat Pumps Beat Straight AC, Where They Fail, and How Amana’s Technology Stacks Up**

Ask any homeowner whether they need an AC-only system or a heat pump, and nine out of ten will give you an answer based on a misconception. Some think heat pumps “don’t work in winter.” Others think AC-only systems are always cheaper. Some believe heat pumps cost more to run. Others think heat pumps don’t cool as well.

Here’s the real truth — both systems can be the right choice depending on your home, climate, insulation, electric rates, and long-term goals.

But if you choose the wrong one?
You’ll pay for it — in comfort, energy bills, and repair costs.

That’s why today, I’m breaking down Amana heat pumps vs AC-only systems the way only a field tech can. No brochure talk, no marketing fluff — just straight answers based on decades of installs, repairs, performance tests, and real-world results backed by ASHRAE performance tables, DOE climate zone standards, EPA refrigerant behavior rules, and UL A2L safety guidelines.

By the end of this article, you’ll know exactly which one your home really needs.

1. First Things First: What’s the Difference Between a Heat Pump and AC-Only System?

Both systems look similar on the outside and both cool your home in summer.
The main difference is what they do in winter.

AC-Only System

cools your home
pairs with a gas furnace for heat
uses refrigerant in one direction

Heat Pump

cools your home
heats your home (without burning fuel)
reverses refrigerant flow with a reversing valve
pairs with electric backup heat (in cold climates)

Think of a heat pump as an AC that can run in reverse — pulling heat into your home instead of pushing it out.

Heat pumps = electricity
Furnaces = gas or propane

Both can be great.
Both can be bad — depending on your home.

2. What Homeowners Get Wrong About Heat Pumps

Let’s bust some myths.

❌ Myth 1: Heat pumps don’t work in cold weather.

They absolutely do — modern units, especially ones using refrigerants regulated under updated EPA A2L refrigerant requirements, can extract heat even below freezing.

Amana’s two-stage and variable-speed heat pumps operate efficiently well into cold weather because their coils and compressors are optimized for low-ambient operation.

❌ Myth 2: Heat pumps cost more to run.

Not true in many regions.
Depending on electric rates vs natural gas prices in your state, heat pumps can be cheaper to run year-round.

❌ Myth 3: Heat pumps don’t cool as well as AC-only systems.

A heat pump is an AC in cooling mode. Same performance. Same cooling. Same coil. Same refrigerant behavior.

ASHRAE performance data shows identical cooling BTU output between Amana heat pumps and Amana AC-only systems of the same tonnage.

❌ Myth 4: Heat pumps break more often.

Heat pumps run more often because they work year-round, but Amana builds these units with:

reinforced compressor mounts
enhanced coil coatings
improved defrost control
variable-speed compressor stability

Modern Amana heat pumps are built to handle it.

**3. The Real Question: What System Makes Sense For Your Climate?**

This is the part homeowners always overlook.

The U.S. Department of Energy climate zone map tells you everything you need to know.

Here’s Mike’s breakdown:

Hot Southern Climates (TX, FL, GA, AL, AZ, LA)

Heat Pump = Fantastic Choice

Why:

very mild winters
electric heat is enough
heat pumps offer cheaper year-round operation
humidity control improves with longer run cycles

Heat pumps shine here because they stay in their “sweet spot” — cooling most of the year and lightly heating in winter.

Moderate Climates (VA, NC, KY, TN, MD, MO)

Heat Pump OR AC+Furnace — both work

Here’s how to choose:

If your electric rates are low → heat pump wins
If you prefer hotter supply air in winter → furnace wins
If you want highest efficiency → heat pump + variable-speed air handler

Mix and match based on comfort preference.

Cold Northern Climates (MI, WI, MN, IL, PA, NY, ND)

AC + Gas Furnace is usually the winner,
BUT modern heat pumps still work — with backup heat.

Why:

heat pump loses efficiency below ~25°F
gas furnaces deliver hotter air
backup electric heat can get expensive

Amana heat pumps still function, but you must pair them with:

dual-fuel furnace (best option)
auxiliary heat strips
cold-climate models

ASHRAE low-ambient performance testing shows heat pumps deliver stable heating down to freezing but gradually lose BTU output as temperatures drop.

4. Comparing Cooling Performance: Do Heat Pumps Cool Worse?

Short answer: No.

Long answer: Absolutely not, and here’s why.

An Amana heat pump in cooling mode uses:

the same coil
the same refrigerant
the same compressor
the same blower

Cooling performance is identical.
Heat pumps don’t “lose” cooling ability — not at all.

The DOE testing procedure for SEER2 applies equally to AC and heat pump cooling mode. The numbers speak for themselves.

Cooling = identical.
Comfort = identical.
Humidity removal = identical.

Where things change is heating, not cooling.

5. Heating Performance: Where AC-Only Systems Have an Edge

If you choose an AC-only unit, you’ll heat your home with:

gas furnace
oil furnace
propane furnace
electric furnace (least common)

And if there’s one thing a furnace does better than a heat pump, it’s producing hot air.

A heat pump in heat mode delivers:

85–105°F supply air

A gas furnace delivers:

120–140°F supply air

If you like HOT, fast heat?
A furnace will always feel better.

6. Amana’s Heat Pump Technology: Why It’s Better Than Many Homeowners Think

Amana isn’t just “an AC company.”
Their heat pumps are engineered with:

1. High-quality Copeland scroll compressors

Better stability in heat mode
Lower discharge temperature
Longer heating cycles

2. SmartShift™ defrost controls

Shorter defrost cycles
Less cold air blowing inside
More efficient operation
UL A2L rules also ensure safe refrigerant behavior during defrost modes.

3. All-aluminum coils

Less corrosion → longer lifespan
Better heat absorption in winter
Improved cold-weather efficiency

4. Two-stage and variable-speed options

Longer low-stage operation
Better heating balance point
Quieter runtime

5. Better airflow engineering

Amana units follow ASHRAE airflow guidelines to maintain proper CFM during long heating cycles.
That means fewer comfort swings.

7. Installation Differences: Heat Pump vs AC-Only

Heat pumps require more precise installation work, including:

additional wiring for the reversing valve
backup heat wiring (if used)
thermostat staging
defrost sensor calibration
correct airflow setting for heat mode

ASHRAE airflow tables specify higher airflow needs for heat pumps vs AC-only systems, especially in variable-speed models.

AC-only installations are simpler — fewer wires, fewer control boards, and easier setup.

But a GOOD installer can make either system perform perfectly.

8. Long-Term Cost: Which System Saves You More?

Let’s talk money.

AC + Gas Furnace

You pay for:

gas
electricity
annual furnace maintenance
AC maintenance

Best for:

cold climates
older homes
homes with existing gas lines

Heat Pump

You pay for:

electricity only
one system for heating + cooling
fewer moving parts

Best for:

warm climates
moderate climates
high-efficiency homes

The DOE’s heating energy modeling shows heat pumps outperform gas furnaces in mild climates by 20–40% in annual cost.

9. Lifespan & Durability Comparison

AC + Furnace Combination

furnace lifespan: 15–25 years
AC lifespan: 12–20 years
two systems = more redundancy

Heat Pump

heat pump lifespan: 12–18 years
Because it runs year-round, the compressor works harder.

BUT Amana’s Copeland compressors + all-aluminum coils help offset this.

10. Mike’s Recommendation Based on Home Type

Small to Mid Homes

Heat pump works great
Especially two-stage or variable-speed

Large Homes (>2,200 sq ft)

Dual-fuel: Heat pump + furnace
AC-only also works depending on climate

Mobile Homes / Manufactured Homes

Heat pump is often ideal
Lower BTU needs
Electric-only heating is simpler

Townhomes & Apartments

Heat pump = excellent
Low heat load
Light winter heating

11. The One Chart Most Homeowners Never See (But Should)

Here’s the difference in heating balance point between systems.

Heat Pump Balance Point

Below 25–35°F, heat pump output drops.

Gas Furnace “Balance Point”

Heats consistently regardless of outdoor temperature.

ASHRAE heating performance data confirms this every single time.

12. Mike’s Final Verdict: Which System Should YOU Choose?

It depends — here’s the simplest way to decide:

⭐ Choose an Amana Heat Pump if:

you live in a warm or moderate climate
you want lower energy bills
you want heating + cooling in one system
you prefer quieter, longer heating cycles
you want advanced efficiency options
you want environmentally cleaner heating

⭐ Choose an Amana AC-Only System if:

you live in a cold climate
you prefer HOT, furnace-style heat
natural gas is cheap in your area
you already have a gas furnace you like
you want maximum reliability in winter

⭐ Choose Dual-Fuel (Heat Pump + Furnace) if:

you want the BEST of both worlds
your winters dip below 25°F
you want efficiency AND hot furnace heat
you want maximum comfort with minimal cost

In the end, both Amana heat pumps and AC-only systems are excellent.
The “wrong choice” isn’t the product — it’s buying the wrong system for your climate and home layout.

In the next blog, Mike’s Guide to Condenser Size, Clearance & Utility Room Layout is provided.

Tags: Cooling it with mike

WRITTEN BY

Mike Sanders

Previous article Will an Amana Unit Fit Your Home? Mike’s Guide to Condenser Size, Clearance & Utility Room Layout Next article Tool-Driven System Design: Mike’s Guide to Choosing the Right Gear Before You Build Anything