Should You Upgrade to a Higher VA Transformer Pros, Cons & When It Makes Sense

If your HVAC system’s transformer keeps blowing fuses or struggling to power your thermostat and accessories, you might be asking:

👉 Should I upgrade to a higher VA transformer?

I’ve faced this question myself. After adding a Wi-Fi thermostat and a whole-home humidifier, my standard 40VA transformer was working overtime. Eventually, I had to make the call: stick with OEM specs or upgrade for more capacity.

Goodman 120V to 24V Transformer 0130M00140S

In this guide, I’ll explain what VA means, why it matters, and when upgrading makes sense (and when it doesn’t).


🧾 Table of Contents

  1. ⚡ What VA Rating Means

  2. 🏠 Typical Loads on a Standard 40VA Transformer

  3. ➕ When to Consider Upgrading to Higher VA

  4. ➖ Downsides of Upgrading

  5. 🔍 How to Calculate If You Need More VA

  6. 📖 Mark’s Real-World Story

  7. 🛡 Safety and Protection Tips

  8. 💲 Cost Breakdown: Standard vs. Higher VA

  9. ❓ FAQs About Higher VA Transformers

  10. 📚 Final Thoughts


⚡ 1. What VA Rating Means

VA (volt-amps) is a measure of the transformer’s power-handling capacity.

  • Volts (V): The electrical potential.

  • Amps (A): The current flowing.

  • VA: Product of volts × amps = capacity.

A 40VA transformer can supply up to 40 volt-amps of power on the secondary side (the 24V output).

👉 If your HVAC control circuit demands more than 40VA, the transformer may overheat, blow fuses, or fail prematurely.

👉 Learn the basics here: Electronics Tutorials – Transformer Fundamentals


🏠 2. Typical Loads on a Standard 40VA Transformer

Most residential Goodman furnaces and air handlers ship with a 40VA transformer. That’s usually plenty for:

  • Thermostat: 3–5VA (varies by model).

  • Contactor coil (outdoor unit): ~5VA.

  • Control board relays & safeties: ~10–15VA.

👉 Total = ~20–25VA under normal use → well within 40VA capacity.

This is why most homeowners never have to think about transformer size—until they add accessories.


➕ 3. When to Consider Upgrading to Higher VA

You should consider a 50VA, 60VA, or even 75VA transformer if:

  • Smart Thermostats: Many Wi-Fi or learning thermostats (like Nest, Ecobee) draw constant power, adding ~5–10VA.

  • Humidifiers / Dehumidifiers: Steam humidifiers can pull 10–20VA.

  • UV Air Purifiers: Some models draw from the 24V circuit.

  • Zoning Systems: Each damper motor can draw 5–10VA, and control boards add even more.

  • Multiple Accessories Combined: A Wi-Fi thermostat + zoning board + humidifier can easily exceed 40VA.

👉 Compatibility notes: Honeywell Transformer Sizing Guide

If you’re at or near the limit, upgrading prevents nuisance fuse blows and ensures stable power.


➖ 4. Downsides of Upgrading

Upgrading isn’t always the answer. Here’s why:

  • Higher Cost: Standard 40VA = $20–$40. Upgraded 50–75VA = $40–$75.

  • Bigger Size: Larger transformers may not fit original mounting brackets.

  • Doesn’t Fix Shorts: If your transformer keeps blowing due to a wiring short, a bigger unit will just burn out faster.

  • Risk of Overkill: Oversizing beyond what your system needs doesn’t improve efficiency—it just wastes money.

👉 Common causes of failure: InspectAPedia – HVAC Transformers


🔍 5. How to Calculate If You Need More VA

Here’s the simple way to calculate transformer load:

  1. Find VA rating of each device (thermostat, contactors, humidifier, zoning board).

  2. Add them up.

  3. Ensure total ≤ 75% of transformer rating.

Example:

  • Smart thermostat = 5VA

  • Zoning board = 20VA

  • 3 dampers @ 5VA each = 15VA

  • Contactor coil = 5VA

  • Control board = 10VA

Total = 55VA

👉 On a 40VA transformer, this setup would be overloaded.
👉 A 75VA transformer would be the right call.

👉 Load calculation resources: HVAC School – Common 24V Problems


📖 6. Mark’s Real-World Story

When I installed a smart thermostat and later added a bypass humidifier, my Goodman furnace started blowing its 3A fuse regularly.

At first, I thought it was a wiring short. But after testing, I realized the accessories were pushing my 40VA transformer too close to its limit.

I upgraded to a 75VA transformer, added an inline fuse for protection, and haven’t had an issue since.

Lesson: Upgrading makes sense if your load has grown—but only after ruling out wiring problems.


🛡 7. Safety and Protection Tips

Even if you upgrade, keep these safety tips in mind:

  • Always add a fuse: Protect the transformer with a 3–5A inline fuse on the secondary side.

  • Fix wiring issues first: Shorts will kill any transformer, regardless of size.

  • Don’t oversize for no reason: Bigger isn’t better unless load demands it.

  • Verify with a multimeter: Measure load before upgrading.

👉 Testing how-to: SFGate – Test a Furnace Transformer


💲 8. Cost Breakdown: Standard vs. Higher VA

Transformer Typical Rating Cost (Part Only) Installed by Pro
Standard 40VA $20–$40 $200–$350
Mid-size 50–60VA $35–$60 $220–$375
High-capacity 75VA $40–$75 $250–$400

👉 Service cost averages: Forbes Home – HVAC Repair Costs


❓ 9. FAQs About Higher VA Transformers

Q: Will a higher VA transformer make my system more efficient?
A: No—it only increases capacity, not efficiency.

Q: Can I install a 75VA transformer if my system only needs 20VA?
A: Yes, but it’s unnecessary. Better to stick with OEM unless upgrading for load.

Q: What happens if I don’t upgrade and overload my transformer?
A: It will overheat, blow fuses, or fail prematurely.

Q: Do smart thermostats always require a bigger transformer?
A: Not always—only if combined with other accessories that push load near 40VA.


📚 10. Final Thoughts

So, should you upgrade to a higher VA transformer?

  • Yes, if you’ve added smart thermostats, zoning boards, humidifiers, or multiple accessories that push load past 40VA.

  • No, if your system is running fine with a standard 40VA and no extra devices.

  • Always fix wiring shorts first—upgrading won’t solve electrical problems.

For me, upgrading to 75VA was the right move after expanding my system. For you, it comes down to load demand and future add-ons.

👉 Key takeaway: match the transformer VA to your actual needs—not just bigger for the sake of bigger.

In the next topic we will know more about: How Mark Fixed His Furnace by Replacing a $20 Transformer

Mark callahan

Leave a comment

All comments are moderated before being published