Is a 50-Gallon Water Heater Enough for Your Family? Sizing Tips from M

0 comments

Hey, Mike Sanders here. If you're shopping for a new water heater, chances are you’ve run into the classic question: “Is 50 gallons enough for my home?”

The 50-gallon size is the most popular tank sold in America—and for good reason. But whether it’s the right size for your household depends on more than just how many people live under your roof. In this guide, I’ll walk you through everything you need to know.

🏠 1. What Determines the Right Water Heater Size?

It’s not just about how big the tank is. You need to factor in:

🔁 A. First Hour Rating (FHR)

How much hot water your unit can deliver during the busiest 60 minutes of the day. It includes:

Stored hot water
Recovery rate (how fast it reheats new water)

👨👩👧👦 B. Household Size & Usage

Each person typically uses:

10–20 gallons for a shower
6–10 gallons for laundry
4–6 gallons for a dishwasher cycle

So the number of people and how they use hot water really matters.

📚 Source: Energy.gov Water Heating Guide

🔎 2. Why 50 Gallons Is the “Sweet Spot” for Many Homes

Here’s why 50 gallons hits the bullseye for millions of homes:

Balances storage and cost: not too big, not too small
Offers moderate FHR (62–67 gallons for State ProLine)
Works for families of 3–5 in most climates
Easy to install in standard closets or utility rooms
Often avoids upgrade costs for breakers or wiring

🧰 It’s the “Goldilocks” of water heaters—just right for most.

📊 3. What the Experts Recommend

Family Size	Suggested FHR	Suggested Tank Size
1–2 people	38–49 gallons	30–40 gal
2–3 people	49–62 gallons	40–50 gal
3–4 people	62–74 gallons	50 gal
5+ people	74+ gallons	66–80 gal

📚 Source: DOE Water Heater Guide (PDF)

🚿 4. Real-Life Scenarios (Mike's Field Examples)

👪 A. Family of 3

2 morning showers = ~35 gallons
Light laundry + dishes = ~12 gallons
FHR needed: 45–50 gallons

✅ A 50-gallon tank like the State ProLine is more than enough.

👨👩👧👧 B. Family of 4

3 morning showers + one evening
Dishwasher run + laundry in evening
Total = ~65–70 gallons/day, with 45–60 gallons in the morning hour

🟢 50-gallon tank works well if you stagger usage slightly.

👨👩👧👦👦 C. Family of 5+

Multiple back-to-back showers
Simultaneous dishwasher, laundry, and morning prep
Morning peak demand: 70–80+ gallons

🟡 50-gallon tank can fall short unless hot water is scheduled or spread out.

Mike’s Tip: Add a low-flow showerhead or delay laundry to avoid running dry.

⚖️ 5. Comparing 40 vs. 50 vs. 66 Gallon Tanks

Feature	40 Gallon	50 Gallon	66 Gallon
Tank Size	Smaller	Mid-size	Larger
FHR	50–58 gal	62–67 gal	75–85 gal
Footprint	Small	Standard	May require extra clearance
Cost	$500–$750	$650–$950	$900–$1,200+
Ideal Use	1–3 people	3–5 people	5+ people

🔗 Source: Home Depot Water Heater Guide

🔥 6. What About Recovery Rate?

If your water heater can reheat water faster, you may get away with a smaller tank.

The State ProLine 50-Gallon Electric Water Heater has:

4.5 kW dual heating elements
Recovery rate: ~21 GPH (gallons per hour)

This means:

You get 60+ gallons of hot water in the first hour
Full recovery within ~2–2.5 hours after heavy use

📄 Verified source: State Product Literature

🧯 7. What Can Cause You to Run Out of Hot Water?

All showers at the same time
Filling a tub right after laundry
Sediment buildup reducing tank efficiency
Thermostat set too low
Incoming cold water in winter

Mike’s Tip: Flush your tank once a year to maintain capacity. Here's how:
🔗 Family Handyman Water Heater Flush Guide

🔍 8. Is a 50-Gallon Tank Enough for You?

Ask yourself:

Do you shower back-to-back as a family?
Do you often run laundry and dishwasher at the same time?
Do you have guests often?
Do you have multiple bathrooms used simultaneously?

If the answer to 2+ of those is yes, you might benefit from a larger tank or a hybrid system.

✅ 9. Mike’s Quick Recommendations

Household	Recommendation
Single or Couple	30–40 gal
2–3 People	40–50 gal
3–5 People	50 gal (stagger use)
5+ People	66–80 gal or heat pump
Frequent Guests	50 gal minimum or hybrid
Limited Space	50 gal tall model fits in closets

📚 10. External Verified Links

🏁 Final Thoughts From Mike

The 50-gallon tank is a workhorse—and for most families, it’s exactly what you need. That’s why I install the State ProLine 50-Gallon Electric Water Heater more than any other model.

It’s reliable, compact, and delivers plenty of hot water when sized properly. Just remember: