By Tony Marino — a DIY‑minded homeowner who values comfort, energy savings, and smart upgrades.
📘 Introduction
When summer hit last year, Tony faced a familiar problem: his window AC rattled loudly, blocked his favorite view of the backyard, and left his family room muggy despite running all day. Frustrated, he asked himself the question many homeowners eventually face:
“Should I stick with a window unit, or upgrade to a through‑the‑wall AC?”
This guide will help you answer that same question. By comparing performance, cost, installation, and efficiency, we’ll see why Tony ultimately chose a built‑in through‑the‑wall system — and whether it’s the right move for you.
🧾 1. The Basics: Window AC vs. Through‑the‑Wall AC
Before diving into pros and cons, it’s important to understand how these two systems differ:
-
Window AC Units
-
Installed in a window opening.
-
Portable and easy to remove.
-
Commonly used in apartments or rentals.
-
-
Through‑the‑Wall AC Units
-
Installed permanently into an exterior wall via a wall sleeve.
-
Better insulation and weatherproofing.
-
A long‑term solution with higher upfront investment.
-
👉 According to the U.S. Department of Energy, choosing the right type of room air conditioner can save significant energy while improving comfort.
🪟 2. Window Units: Affordable but Temporary
✅ Advantages of Window ACs
-
Lower upfront cost: Prices often start under $200.
-
Quick installation: Plug‑and‑play in less than an hour.
-
Portability: Easy to remove in winter or when moving.
-
Good for renters: Doesn’t require permanent modifications.
❌ Drawbacks of Window ACs
-
Blocks sunlight: One less window for fresh air or a view.
-
Noise issues: Vibration and poor insulation can make them louder.
-
Less secure: Can be removed from outside, compromising safety.
-
Lower efficiency: More air leaks compared to sealed wall units.
-
Shorter lifespan: Typically last 5–7 years under heavy use.
👉 Consumer Reports notes that window AC units are best for short‑term or budget‑friendly cooling, but may not deliver the longevity or comfort many homeowners want.
🏠 3. Through‑the‑Wall Units: Permanent Comfort and Value
✅ Advantages of Through‑the‑Wall ACs
-
Sleeker design: Flush with the wall, doesn’t block a window.
-
Improved insulation: Installed in a sleeve that seals air gaps.
-
Better security: Permanently fixed, not easily removed.
-
Long lifespan: Often 10–15 years with proper maintenance.
-
Noise reduction: Insulated placement reduces indoor noise.
❌ Drawbacks of Through‑the‑Wall ACs
-
Higher upfront cost: Units typically range from $500–$1,200.
-
Installation required: Cutting a wall and installing a sleeve.
-
Less flexibility: Not ideal for renters or frequent movers.
👉 According to HVAC.com, through‑the‑wall ACs are a better investment for homeowners who want permanent solutions with higher efficiency.
📏 4. BTU Sizing: Do Wall Units Perform Better?
Both window and wall units are rated in BTUs (British Thermal Units). A 10,000 BTU system typically cools ~350–450 ft², while a 12,000 BTU system handles ~450–550 ft².
The difference lies in efficiency:
-
Wall units, being better sealed, lose less cooled air.
-
Window units often have air leaks, which reduces effective coverage.
👉 Use the Energy Star Room AC Sizing Guide to calculate the right BTU capacity for your room.
⚙️ 5. Installation: Tony’s Turning Point
For years, Tony wrestled his 60‑pound window unit in and out of the frame every spring and fall. One slip nearly broke his windowpane. That’s when he decided:
“I’m done fighting with window units. I want something permanent.”
Window AC Installation
-
Requires no permanent modification.
-
Risk of improper sealing → drafts and water leaks.
-
Seasonal removal for storage.
Through‑the‑Wall AC Installation
-
Requires cutting an exterior wall and inserting a wall sleeve.
-
Professional install may cost $200–$500, but it’s a one‑time job.
-
Unit remains in place year‑round.
👉 Home Depot’s AC Buying Guide explains that through‑the‑wall units are ideal for long‑term homeowners, while window ACs suit temporary needs.
💰 6. Energy Efficiency & Operating Costs
Tony wanted lower energy bills, so he compared his window AC to a new through‑the‑wall model:
-
Window Unit: SEER ~9, monthly bill ~$75 in summer.
-
Through‑the‑Wall Unit (Energy Star): SEER ~14, monthly bill ~$55.
That’s a 25% savings over the season.
Why Wall Units Save More
-
Sealed installation prevents leaks.
-
Higher SEER/EER ratings available.
-
No seasonal air gaps around window frames.
👉 Energy Star confirms that certified through‑the‑wall ACs save 10–30% more energy than non‑certified window units.
🔇 7. Comfort & Noise: The Big Lifestyle Upgrade
Tony’s wife used to complain they had to turn up the TV every time the window AC clicked on.
Wall units, installed with insulated sleeves, reduce:
-
Vibration noise
-
Outdoor noise leakage
-
Inconsistent temperature swings
🛠️ 8. Maintenance & Longevity
Window ACs
-
Need seasonal removal → risk of dropping or damaging.
-
Filters often harder to access.
-
Exposed to weather when stored improperly.
Through‑the‑Wall ACs
-
Stay in place year‑round.
-
Wall sleeve protects from weather damage.
-
Filters easy to reach and clean.
-
Units often last 10+ years with regular care.
👉 The Furnace Outlet Maintenance Guides provide seasonal care tips for extending AC lifespan.
🧠 9. When a Window Unit Still Makes Sense
Despite Tony’s choice, window ACs remain useful if:
-
You’re a renter and can’t cut into walls.
-
You need short‑term or seasonal cooling.
-
Your budget doesn’t allow for a larger upfront purchase.
-
You plan to move soon.
⭐ 10. Tony’s Verdict: Why He Chose a Through‑the‑Wall AC
After comparing both options, Tony made the switch.
“The extra upfront cost was worth it. My room is cooler, quieter, and my energy bills are finally under control.”
Tony’s Quick Checklist for Homeowners:
-
If you own your home → Choose through‑the‑wall.
-
If you rent → Stick with a window unit.
-
If you want the quietest, most efficient option → Through‑the‑wall wins.
👉 Explore Through‑the‑Wall AC Units – 10,000 to 12,000 BTUs to find Tony’s recommended sizes.
In the next topic we will know more about: Installation Guide: How Tony Prepped His Wall for a 12,000 BTU AC
