❄️ Cold Climate Performance: The Critical Question
Heat pumps like the Amana PBH092J12AA are increasingly popular for year-round comfort. But homeowners in northern regions often ask:
"Will my through-the-wall heat pump actually work in winter?"
The answer is nuanced — let’s break it down Mike Sanders-style.
🔧 How Heat Pumps Work (Even in Cold Air)
Heat pumps operate by extracting heat energy from outdoor air, even when temperatures are low:
1️⃣ Cooling Mode (Summer): Moves indoor heat outside.
2️⃣ Heating Mode (Winter): Reverses refrigerant flow to absorb outdoor heat and release it indoors.
Even at freezing temperatures, outdoor air contains usable heat — but as temperatures drop, extraction becomes more challenging.
Reference: Energy.gov Heat Pump Basics
🌡 Cold Climate Efficiency Curve
| Outdoor Temp | Heat Pump Efficiency |
|---|---|
| 50°F (10°C) | Excellent (400% COP) |
| 35°F (1.5°C) | Very Good (250-300% COP) |
| 25°F (-4°C) | Good (200-250% COP) |
| 10°F (-12°C) | Reduced (100-150% COP) |
| 0°F (-18°C) | Minimal (near 100% COP or less) |
As outdoor temperatures approach 25°F and below, most through-the-wall models lose heating capacity rapidly.
Reference: HVAC.com Cold Weather Heat Pump Guide
⚠️ Limitations of Through-the-Wall Heat Pumps in Cold Weather
1️⃣ Reduced Heating Output
-
Amana PBH092J12AA heating capacity: ~8,500 BTU at mild temps.
-
Capacity diminishes below 30°F.
2️⃣ Backup Heat Required
-
Electric resistance backup heat often built into units.
-
Less efficient, but ensures emergency heating during very cold snaps.
3️⃣ Defrost Cycles
-
Outdoor coils freeze at low temps.
-
Unit must periodically switch into cooling mode briefly to melt ice.
4️⃣ Electrical Load Increases
-
As heat pump loses efficiency, electric consumption rises.
Reference: Energy.gov Heat Pump Cold Climate Challenges
🏡 Ideal Applications in Cold Climates
While not ideal as primary heating, through-the-wall heat pumps excel as supplemental zone heaters in:
-
Bedrooms
-
Finished basements
-
Sunrooms
-
Home offices
-
In-law suites
-
Enclosed patios
They can significantly reduce the burden on your central heating system.
🌬 When Through-the-Wall Heat Pumps Struggle
❌ Bad Fit For:
-
Entire home heating loads
-
Open floor plans in cold zones
-
Uninsulated rooms or garages
-
Primary heat source below 20°F outdoor temperatures
Mike’s Test:
"If your local winter lows hit single digits regularly, you’ll need backup heat alongside your through-the-wall heat pump."
🏷 Cold Climate Heat Pump Alternatives
| Technology | Key Advantage |
| Ductless Mini-Split Heat Pumps | High cold climate ratings (operate down to -13°F) |
| Dual-Fuel Systems | Combines heat pump + gas furnace |
| Baseboard Electric + Heat Pump | Efficient hybrid approach |
Reference: Energy Star Cold Climate Heat Pumps
🧰 Installation Tips for Cold Climate Performance
✅ Maximize Insulation:
-
Seal wall sleeve perfectly.
-
Insulate gaps with high-density foam.
✅ Avoid Air Leaks:
-
Caulk all exterior joints.
-
Install drip caps and weather-resistant flashing.
✅ Proper Drainage:
-
Ensure proper condensate management to prevent freeze-ups.
✅ Placement Matters:
-
Shield exterior coil from prevailing winter winds.
Reference: The Spruce: Wall AC Installation Best Practices
🔋 Energy Cost Implications in Cold Regions
| Energy Cost Factor | Through-the-Wall Heat Pump | Electric Resistance Heat |
| Moderate Temps (35-50°F) | 50-70% cheaper | N/A |
| Sub-Freezing (0-25°F) | Equal or worse | 100% electric |
| Year-Round Operating Cost | Lower overall | Higher overall |
In many climates, heat pumps still deliver meaningful savings even with cold weather performance drop-offs.
Reference: Department of Energy Efficiency Projections
🌎 Climate Zone Considerations
| Region | Through-the-Wall Heat Pump Role |
| Northeast U.S. | Backup or supplemental only |
| Upper Midwest | Backup only |
| Mid-Atlantic | Primary/supplemental mixed |
| Pacific Northwest | Primary viable |
| Southeast U.S. | Excellent primary solution |
Reference: ASHRAE Climate Zone Map
🏆 Mike Sanders' Cold Climate Rule of Thumb
"If your winters spend most days above 30°F, a through-the-wall heat pump is golden. But if you're consistently freezing for weeks at a time, use it as a smart backup or zone heater — not your whole-home solution."
