Heating Options for Small Wall ACs: Electric Heat vs. Heat Pump Add-Ons

🌬 Introduction

Jake had a problem. His 8,000 BTU through-the-wall AC worked like a charm during summer, keeping his home office at a comfortable 72°F. But when autumn rolled in and the temperatures dipped into the 50s, he found himself dragging out an old space heater. The result? sky-high electric bills and a room that never felt evenly warm.

That’s when Jake started exploring whether he could make his small wall AC unit do double duty—providing both cooling and heating. He discovered two popular add-on options:

1. Electric Heat Kits — budget-friendly, plug-and-play heating

2. Heat Pump Add-Ons — efficient, long-term comfort solutions

This guide breaks down Jake’s findings so you can decide which heating add-on is best for your 6,000–9,000 BTU wall AC.

---

🌬 Why Add Heating to a Small Wall AC?

For Jake—and many homeowners—the answer came down to convenience, savings, and comfort.

🏡 Dual-Purpose Comfort

• Saves space: one unit instead of separate AC and heater.

• Perfect for small apartments, guest rooms, home offices, or in-law suites.

• Ideal for spaces without central HVAC ductwork.

💵 Energy & Utility Savings

Instead of cranking up the whole-house furnace for one room, a wall AC with heating keeps energy use focused.

• Running central heat for Jake’s 200 sq ft office: ~$90/month.

• Running his wall AC with heat pump add-on: ~$20–25/month.

🌎 Flexibility

• Electric kits are great for occasional heat (like cool autumn mornings).

• Heat pumps are better for daily comfort through fall and spring.

📌 According to Energy Star, supplemental heating is a proven way to reduce seasonal energy costs.

---

⚡ Electric Heat Kits

🔎 How They Work

An electric heat kit uses resistance coils, similar to a toaster or space heater, to generate heat. The wall AC’s fan then blows air over the coils, distributing heat into the room.

✅ Pros of Electric Heat Kits

• Low Upfront Cost: Typically $100–$200.

• Simple Installation: Slides into many existing wall AC sleeves.

• Reliable Heat: Works consistently regardless of outdoor temperature.

• Instant Warmth: Heat is generated immediately when switched on.

Jake’s guest room uses an electric heat kit—perfect for when relatives visit in December.

---

❌ Cons of Electric Heat Kits

• Energy Hungry: 100% efficient at point-of-use, but costly on the electric bill.

• Short-Term Solution: Best for 2–4 hours daily, not for 24/7 heating.

• Hot Spots: Less even heating across the room compared to a heat pump.

📌 This Old House confirms that while electric resistance heating is effective, it’s among the most expensive methods long term.

---

❄ Heat Pump Add-Ons

🔎 How They Work

A heat pump add-on reverses the AC’s cooling cycle. Instead of expelling heat outside, it brings it indoors—even in cool weather.

• In mild climates: Works very efficiently, using 2–3x less electricity than resistance heat.

• In cold climates: Still works, but efficiency drops below ~30°F.

---

✅ Pros of Heat Pump Add-Ons

• High Efficiency: Up to 300% efficient, meaning 1 kWh of electricity delivers 2–3 kWh of heat.

• Lower Bills: Jake’s usage cost him ~$20/month in fall, compared to $45+ with an electric kit.

• Comfortable Heat: Distributes warmth evenly without hot spots.

• Dual Function: Also provides cooling in summer.

---

❌ Cons of Heat Pump Add-Ons

• Higher Upfront Cost: $300–$600.

• Climate Sensitive: Less effective in very cold areas.

• Installation Complexity: May require professional help if refrigerant lines are involved.

📌 The U.S. DOE notes that heat pumps can deliver 2–3x more heat than the energy they consume, making them far more efficient than electric resistance heating.

---

📊 Side-by-Side Comparison

---

🏡 Jake’s Real-World Scenarios

Scenario 1: Home Office in Mild Climate

• Choice: Heat pump add-on.

• Result: Comfortable daily heating, cut his seasonal heating bill by ~60%.

Scenario 2: Guest Room Used Occasionally

• Choice: Electric heat kit.

• Result: Cheap, quick warmth when needed. Only costs ~$10/month when guests stay.

Scenario 3: Basement Apartment in Cold State

• Choice: Combo setup (heat pump + electric kit backup).

• Result: Heat pump handles most days; electric kit supports during freezing nights.

Jake: “The combo approach gave me peace of mind—efficient heat most of the time, with backup when temps plummet.”

---

🔧 Installation & Maintenance Tips

For Electric Heat Kits

• Verify compatibility with your AC sleeve.

• Use the manufacturer’s instructions for wiring and coil placement.

• Check annually for dust and inspect wires for wear.

For Heat Pump Add-Ons

• Ensure sleeve clearance for airflow.

• If refrigerant connections are needed, hire a certified HVAC pro.

• Clean coils and filters every season.

📌 Family Handyman offers detailed guidance on DIY AC and heating add-on installs.

---

💵 Cost & Efficiency Considerations

Jake ran numbers for his 200 sq ft office, used 5 hours daily for 4 months:

Electric Heat Kit

• Draw: ~1,500 watts/hour

• Monthly: 225 kWh

• Cost (@ $0.15/kWh): ~$33.75/month

• Total (4 months): ~$135

Heat Pump Add-On

• Draw: ~600 watts/hour

• Monthly: 90 kWh

• Cost (@ $0.15/kWh): ~$13.50/month

• Total (4 months): ~$54

Savings: ~$81 per season → pays off higher upfront cost in ~2 years.

---

✅ Jake’s Heating Add-On Decision Checklist

• Do you need heating occasionally or daily?

• Is your climate moderate (heat pump works well) or cold (backup may be needed)?

• Can you spend more now to save long term?

• Are you comfortable with DIY, or will you hire a pro?

• Does your AC model support the add-on type you want?

---

🏁 Conclusion

Jake’s final verdict:

• If you only need occasional heat → an electric heat kit is simple and cheap.

• If you need regular, efficient heat → a heat pump add-on is worth the investment.

• In colder climates, combine both for the best of efficiency and reliability.

With the right add-on, your 6,000–9,000 BTU wall AC becomes a true year-round comfort solution.

In the next topic we will know more about: Real Costs of a 6,000–9,000 BTU Wall AC: Unit, Sleeve, and DIY Install