If you’re shopping for a full HVAC setup and comparing Goodman vs. Carrier, you’re in good company. They’re two of the biggest names in residential heating and cooling—and while they serve the same purpose, their approach (and price) can be pretty different.
Here’s how Tony breaks it down for homeowners considering the Goodman 2 Ton Northeast System vs. a comparable Carrier system.
📊 1. Efficiency & Performance
Goodman GLXS3BN2410:
-
14.3 SEER2
-
Single-stage scroll compressor
-
96% AFUE gas furnace
-
AHRI-matched for balanced airflow
Carrier Comfort 15 24SCA5 (2 Ton):
-
~13.8 SEER2
-
Single-stage compressor
-
80% or 96% AFUE furnace options
-
Slightly quieter operation (lower dB rating)
👉 Carrier Residential Product Guide
Verdict: Both offer comparable cooling performance. Carrier may have a slight edge on quiet operation, but Goodman wins on efficiency at the same tonnage in this specific match-up.
💵 2. Price & Value
Goodman is known for lower equipment cost and DIY accessibility.
-
Goodman system (parts only): ~$2,500–$3,000
-
Carrier system (dealer only): ~$3,800–$4,500
Carrier typically requires professional installation through certified dealers, which adds to cost. Goodman parts can be sold direct or via trusted online resellers.
👉 Cost breakdown for HVAC systems – Forbes
Verdict: Goodman wins on affordability, especially for DIYers or homeowners working with independent contractors.
🛡️ 3. Warranty Coverage
Goodman:
-
10-year parts (with registration)
-
Lifetime heat exchanger on furnace
-
20-year unit replacement on select models
Carrier:
-
10-year parts
-
20-year or lifetime heat exchanger (model-dependent)
-
Limited replacement warranty on some models
👉 Goodman Warranty Info
👉 Carrier HVAC Warranty Policy
Verdict: Both brands offer strong coverage, but Goodman’s lifetime exchanger warranty is standard, not model-specific.
🧰 4. Installation & Maintenance
Goodman:
-
Easier DIY or contractor-friendly installs
-
Available through online retailers
-
Broad documentation support
Carrier:
-
Dealer-exclusive installs
-
More restrictive on parts sourcing
-
Higher installation cost due to dealer markup
👉 HVAC.com
Verdict: If you want more flexibility or lower install cost, Goodman is better suited. Carrier prioritizes dealer oversight and premium installs.
🛠️ Tony’s Take
“Carrier’s great if you want to ‘set it and forget it’ and pay more for a quieter ride. But Goodman gives you options, power, and value without fluff. Just match the components, register the warranty, and you’re golden.”
In the next topic you will know about: Rebates & Tax Credits for High-Efficiency HVAC in 2025
