Electric Heat vs. Heat Pump PTACs: Which One Is Better for Your Space?

If you’ve been exploring Amana PTAC systems (Packaged Terminal Air Conditioners) for your home, apartment, or rental property, you’ve probably noticed two types pop up everywhere: electric heat PTACs and heat pump PTACs.

At first glance, they look identical — same wall sleeve, same controls, same cooling power. But under the hood, the way they heat your room couldn’t be more different. One generates heat using electricity, while the other transfers heat from the air outside.

Choosing between them can affect your comfort, your utility bills, and how well your system performs when temperatures dip. So, let’s break down how each type works, when it shines, and how to pick the right option for your space.

---

⚙️ 1. What’s a PTAC, and Why Heating Type Matters

A PTAC (Packaged Terminal Air Conditioner) is a self-contained, through-the-wall HVAC unit that provides both cooling and heating for a single room or suite — think hotels, apartments, offices, or studio homes.

They’re popular because they’re:

• Ductless — no complicated installation or retrofitting needed.

• Independent — each unit controls its own zone.

• Compact — all components (compressor, fan, coils, and heater) are in one package.

The Amana Distinctions 14,700 BTU PTAC is one example: it provides cooling for medium to large rooms and includes a 3.5 kW electric heat kit for year-round comfort.

But the key difference among PTACs isn’t just BTU size — it’s the type of heating system inside.

You’ll find two main options:

1. Electric resistance heat (like the Amana Distinctions electric model).

2. Heat pump PTACs, which reverse their cooling cycle to provide heat.

Let’s see how each works.

---

🔌 2. How Electric Heat PTACs Work

Electric PTACs are simple and robust. They work by converting electricity directly into heat through resistance coils.

Here’s the process:

1. The PTAC draws room air in.

2. Air passes over electric heating coils (like a giant toaster element).

3. The coils warm the air, and a fan blows it back into the room.

That’s it — no compressors or refrigerant needed for heating. Because of that simplicity, electric PTACs are:

• Easy to maintain

• Reliable in any temperature

• Ideal for cold climates where outside air may be too frigid for a heat pump to function efficiently

⚡ Example: Amana Distinctions 14,700 BTU with 3.5 kW Electric Heat

This model uses an internal resistance heating element that outputs steady warmth even when outdoor temperatures fall below freezing.

Electric heat systems are 100% efficient at converting energy into heat (every watt of power becomes one watt of heat output) — but they can be costlier to operate, especially in regions with high electricity rates or long winters.

📘 Learn more: Energy.gov – Electric Resistance Heating Basics

---

🔄 3. How Heat Pump PTACs Work

Heat pump PTACs use a reversible refrigeration cycle. In cooling mode, they absorb heat from inside your room and release it outdoors. In heating mode, they reverse the process — pulling heat from outside air and transferring it indoors.

Even in chilly weather, there’s still some heat energy in outdoor air. The refrigerant absorbs that energy and releases it inside your space.

🔹 Benefits of Heat Pump PTACs

• Energy efficient: Instead of creating heat from scratch, they move it — making them 2–3x more efficient than electric resistance heating.

• Lower operating cost: You get more heat output per unit of energy consumed.

• Year-round comfort: Smooth transition between heating and cooling modes.

A great example is the Amana Distinctions 15,000 BTU Heat Pump Model, which uses R-32 refrigerant for high efficiency and includes electric backup heat for extreme cold.

📘 Learn more: Energy.gov – Heat Pump Systems

---

⚖️ 4. Generating vs. Transferring Heat — The Core Difference

Think of it like this:

• Electric heat is like turning on a hairdryer — instant warmth, no fuss.

• Heat pump is like using nature’s warmth — extracting heat that already exists in the air.

Both have their place, depending on where you live and how you use your PTAC.

---

🌎 5. Climate Considerations — Where Each One Wins

If you remember just one thing, remember this:
Your climate determines which PTAC heating type makes sense.

Heat pumps thrive where outdoor temps rarely dip below freezing. In northern climates, electric resistance remains king because it never loses output power.

📘 Reference: ASHRAE Climate Zone Map

---

💰 6. Cost Comparison: Purchase vs. Operation

🛒 Upfront Cost

• Electric heat PTAC: Usually $100–$200 less than a heat pump model.

• Heat pump PTAC: Slightly higher initial price due to added components (reversing valve, extra sensors).

⚙️ Operating Cost

• Electric heat: Consumes more electricity during long heating periods — often double the cost of a heat pump in the same conditions.

• Heat pump: Uses roughly ⅓ to ½ the energy for the same heating effect in moderate climates.

🧾 Example Scenario

Heating a 600 ft² apartment for four months:

• Electric PTAC → ~$350 in electricity

• Heat pump PTAC → ~$190–$220

That’s roughly a 30–45% savings during the heating season.

📘 See more: ENERGY STAR – Room AC and Heat Pump Efficiency Ratings

---

🧊 7. What Happens When It’s Freezing Outside?

Heat pumps have one limitation: as outdoor air gets colder, there’s less heat available to extract. Efficiency and capacity drop — often below 40°F.

Most Amana heat pump PTACs solve this with a backup electric resistance heater. When the temperature outside is too low for the heat pump to work efficiently, it automatically switches to electric heating mode.

Electric-only PTACs don’t have this problem — they deliver full heating power regardless of temperature, which makes them ideal for cold climates like the Midwest or Northeast.

📘 Learn more: HVAC.com – PTAC Heat Pump vs. Electric Heat in Winter

---

🧰 8. Maintenance & Longevity

Both PTAC types require basic upkeep — but their complexity differs slightly.

🔧 Electric PTAC Maintenance

• Clean air filters monthly.

• Inspect coils for dust buildup.

• Minimal moving parts — fewer failure points.

🔁 Heat Pump PTAC Maintenance

• Clean filters and coils regularly.

• Keep outdoor intake clear.

• Check reversing valve and thermostat calibration annually.

• Slightly more to maintain but still DIY-friendly.

Amana PTACs, including the Distinctions line, are built for easy access — with slide-out chassis designs and washable filters.

📘 Reference: The Furnace Outlet – PTAC Maintenance Guide

---

📊 9. Side-by-Side Pros and Cons

Both are great — it’s all about matching the system to your climate and comfort goals.

---

🏡 10. Which One Is Right for Your Space?

Here’s Samantha’s quick guide for making your choice simple:

Choose Electric Heat PTAC if:

• You live in a northern or mountain climate.

• You experience long periods below freezing.

• You prioritize simplicity and reliability over maximum efficiency.

• Your PTAC is used occasionally (guest rooms, backup zones).

Choose Heat Pump PTAC if:

• You live in a southern or moderate climate.

• You use your PTAC daily for heating and cooling.

• You want lower long-term energy bills.

• You’re comfortable with slightly more complex technology.

If you’re somewhere in between (like the Midwest), consider Amana heat pump models with electric backup. They offer the best of both worlds — efficient heat most of the time, reliable backup when it’s bitterly cold.

---

🧩 11. The Amana Distinctions Line: Built for Every Climate

Amana’s Distinctions PTAC lineup gives you both options in one family.
Whether you choose electric heat or heat pump, you’ll enjoy:

• Dual fan motors for quieter operation.

• 3-speed fan control (cycle or constant).

• LCDI safety cord included.

• R-32 refrigerant for cleaner, modern efficiency.

• 5-year limited warranty.

Featured Models:

• Amana Distinctions 14,700 BTU (3.5 kW Electric Heat)

• Amana Distinctions 15,000 BTU Heat Pump with Electric Backup

Both share the same 42” wall sleeve, meaning upgrading from electric to heat pump (or vice versa) later is simple.

📘 Visit: Amana PTAC Official Site

---

🧠 12. Real-World Example: Samantha’s Rental Suite

Let me share a real-world story.

When I upgraded the climate control in my rental suite (about 600 ft² in Virginia), I faced the same decision you might be making. Winters are mild, summers are hot — so I compared:

The math made my decision easy — I went with the heat pump.

But when I helped my sister in Colorado, where winter nights drop below 10°F, the electric model made more sense. It provided steady, dependable heat without relying on outside air temperatures.

That’s the beauty of PTAC systems: you can tailor them to your exact needs.

---

🌟 13. Samantha’s Takeaway

Here’s how I sum it up for homeowners, landlords, and renovators:

• Electric Heat PTACs are your go-to for cold climates or when you need bulletproof reliability and simplicity.

• Heat Pump PTACs shine in milder climates, offering lower bills and greener operation.

• Hybrid setups (heat pump + electric backup) deliver the best of both worlds.

“Your perfect PTAC isn’t just about BTUs — it’s about matching heating technology to your climate and comfort style.”

If you’re leaning toward the Amana Distinctions line, you’re already looking in the right direction. Whether electric or heat pump, you’ll get reliable comfort, solid warranty coverage, and straightforward installation.

---