Replacing a water heater isn’t cheap. Between the unit itself and installation, you’re easily looking at $1,200–$1,800 for a new system. So, when homeowners hear about rebates and tax credits, the first question is:
👉 “Do gas water heaters qualify?”
When I replaced my old tank last year, I did a deep dive into all the programs. The truth is, not all gas water heaters qualify, but some do—especially if they’re ENERGY STAR certified or tankless.
Let’s walk through everything you need to know in 2025.
🏛️ Federal Tax Credits in 2025
The Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) extended and expanded federal tax credits for homeowners making energy-efficient upgrades. Water heaters are a big part of that program.
🔥 What Qualifies?
-
Standard gas storage water heaters → Most don’t qualify.
-
High-efficiency ENERGY STAR-certified gas storage units → Eligible for up to $600 tax credit.
-
Gas tankless water heaters (condensing models) → Eligible if ENERGY STAR certified.
💡 How It Works
-
You can claim 30% of the project cost, up to $600 for water heaters.
-
Credit applies to purchase + professional installation.
-
You’ll need IRS Form 5695 when filing taxes.
👉 Mike’s Tip: Keep your invoice, installation receipt, and ENERGY STAR certification handy for tax season.
🔗 ENERGY STAR – Tax Credits for Water Heaters
🌱 ENERGY STAR Requirements for Gas Water Heaters
Not every gas heater makes the cut. To qualify for credits or rebates, it must carry the ENERGY STAR label.
✅ Current Requirements (2025)
-
Gas Storage Water Heaters (40-gal models): Must achieve a Uniform Energy Factor (UEF) of at least 0.64–0.68, depending on size.
-
Gas Tankless Water Heaters: Must have UEF ≥ 0.87.
Example:
-
A standard State ProLine 40-Gallon Gas Heater → Reliable but usually not ENERGY STAR.
-
A State ProLine XE High Efficiency Gas Heater → ENERGY STAR certified, eligible for incentives.
🔗 ENERGY STAR – Certified Gas Water Heaters
🏠 State & Local Rebates
On top of federal credits, many states and utilities offer rebates for upgrading to efficient gas heaters.
💵 Typical Rebates
-
$50–$150 → Basic ENERGY STAR gas tank water heater.
-
$200–$400 → High-efficiency condensing tank or tankless unit.
🔎 Examples in 2025
-
California: Rebates up to $400 for ENERGY STAR natural gas water heaters through utility programs.
-
New York (Con Edison): $100–$200 for high-efficiency natural gas storage or tankless models.
-
Midwest Utilities: I personally claimed $150 back from my local gas company for upgrading to ENERGY STAR in 2024, and the program is renewed for 2025.
👉 Mike’s Tip: Always check DSIRE (Database of State Incentives for Renewables & Efficiency)—it’s the most complete source for current programs.
🔗 DSIRE – Search Incentives by State
⚡ Gas vs. Electric: Who Wins the Incentive Game?
Here’s the reality:
-
Electric heat pump water heaters qualify for the biggest rebates (sometimes up to $2,000) because they use way less energy.
-
Gas water heaters get smaller rebates, unless they’re tankless or condensing.
Why the Difference?
Policymakers are pushing electrification for efficiency and emissions. That said, gas is still supported, especially when upgrading from an old, inefficient tank to a modern ENERGY STAR model.
👉 Mike’s Take: “I chose gas because recovery speed matters in my house. The rebate was smaller, but the performance fit our lifestyle better.”
🔗 Energy.gov – Heat Pump vs. Gas Water Heaters
📊 Cost vs. Savings: Real-World Numbers
Let’s compare three scenarios:
1. Standard 40-Gallon Gas Tank (Non-ENERGY STAR)
-
Cost: ~$700 (unit) + $700 (install) = $1,400.
-
Incentives: None.
-
Long-term: Average 6–12 year lifespan, no rebates.
2. ENERGY STAR 40-Gallon Gas Tank
-
Cost: ~$950 + $700 install = $1,650.
-
Incentives: $150 utility rebate + $600 tax credit = $750 saved.
-
Net cost: ~$900.
-
Long-term: ~$100–$200 lower gas bills over 10 years.
3. Gas Tankless (ENERGY STAR)
-
Cost: $1,500 + $1,000 install = $2,500.
-
Incentives: $300 utility rebate + $600 tax credit = $900 saved.
-
Net cost: ~$1,600.
-
Long-term: More efficient, but higher upfront costs.
👉 Mike’s Verdict: The ENERGY STAR 40-gallon tank often hits the sweet spot—good incentives without the complexity or higher install cost of tankless.
🧾 How to Claim Credits & Rebates
✅ Federal Tax Credit Process
-
Buy an eligible ENERGY STAR gas water heater.
-
Keep receipts and certification paperwork.
-
File IRS Form 5695 for the $600 credit.
✅ Utility/State Rebates
-
Visit your utility’s website.
-
Download rebate forms (often online submissions now).
-
Submit proof of purchase + installation photos.
-
Get check or bill credit in 4–8 weeks.
👉 Mike’s Tip: Take photos of the installation tag with model/serial number. Some rebates require it.
🔧 Is It Worth Paying Extra for a Qualifying Gas Heater?
This is the big question. Should you pay more upfront just to get rebates?
-
If you’re staying in your home long-term → Yes. You’ll earn back the difference through rebates + lower bills.
-
If you’re moving soon → Maybe not. A standard tank might be the smarter budget choice.
-
If you use a ton of hot water (big family, multiple showers) → The recovery rate of gas tanks/tankless is worth the investment.
✅ Mike’s Final Recommendation
Here’s how I break it down for 2025:
-
Basic gas tanks → Reliable but rarely qualify. Best if you need the lowest upfront cost.
-
ENERGY STAR-certified gas tanks → The sweet spot. You can stack a $150 rebate with a $600 federal credit and save around $750.
-
Tankless gas water heaters → More expensive, but great for long-term efficiency and still eligible for rebates/credits.
👉 For most families, I recommend upgrading to an ENERGY STAR 40-gallon gas water heater. The rebate and tax credit make it nearly the same price as a basic model, and you’ll save on bills for years.
In the next topic we will know more about: Noise, Space & Venting: Will a 40-Gallon Tall Water Heater Fit in Your Utility Room?
