🔧 Introduction: Furnace Location Isn’t Convenience — It’s System Design

Most homeowners want their furnace “out of the way.”
Most installers want it “where it’s easiest to put.”
Tony thinks both approaches are wrong.

After 35+ years in the field, Tony says:

“A furnace is the heart of the house. Where you put the heart decides how well the body works.”

The location determines:

• Airflow quality

• Static pressure

• Heat distribution

• Noise level

• Service accessibility

• Energy efficiency

• Longevity of equipment

• Safety (carbon monoxide, freeze risk, drainage, combustion air)

Choosing the wrong location can take a 96% furnace and make it perform like an 80% — or worse.

3 Ton 15.2 SEER2 80,000 BTU 96% AFUE Goodman Upflow Air Conditioner System

This article walks through Tony’s full decision-making logic for choosing between attic, crawlspace, basement, or closet, with real-world rules he uses on Goodman and similar systems.

---

🧭 1. The Four Furnace Locations & What They Mean in the Real World

Tony doesn’t start with the homeowner’s preference — he starts with the house’s physics.

The typical installation options:

• Attic

• Crawlspace

• Basement

• Closet / Mechanical room

Each one has major performance implications.
Tony’s golden rule:

“Put the furnace where it can breathe, drain, vent, and stay safe — not where it ‘fits.’”

---

🌡️ 2. Furnace in the Attic — The Good, The Bad & Tony’s Warnings

Attics are the most common modern furnace location — especially in the South.

Tony installs furnaces in attics only when the home design demands it.

🟩 Attic — The Pros

✔️ Frees up interior space

Great for small homes without basements.

✔️ Easy duct routing

Open attic layout = easier trunk lines and branches.

✔️ Quiet operation

Noise is far from living areas.

---

🟥 Attic — The Cons (Tony Hates These)

Tony says attics are “the most dangerous place to put a high-efficiency system” due to:

❌ Extreme temperatures

Attics reach 130–160°F in summer and 20–30°F in winter.

This affects:

• Blower performance

• Motor lifespan

• Circuit boards

• Limit switches

• Condensate and vents (freeze risk)

❌ Condensate drain freeze

A 96% furnace drains gallons of water.
In an attic? That water freezes.

❌ Hard to service

Techs tripping over joists = future problems.

❌ High heat loss from ducts

Insulation only minimizes loss — it doesn't eliminate it.

Tony’s rule:

“If the attic isn’t climate-controlled, your furnace is fighting the house 24/7.”

✔️ Furnace attic installation risks (DOE):
https://www.energy.gov/energysaver/furnaces-and-boilers

---

🟨 Tony Installs in Attics ONLY IF:

• The attic is insulated to R-38 or higher

• The furnace has a freeze-safe drain route

• There’s a proper platform & walkway

• There’s space for a full-service clearance area

• All ductwork is sealed and insulated

• Combustion air is correctly routed

• Vent run stays within manufacturer specs

• A secondary drain pan with float switch is installed

Tony says:

“Attic installs aren’t bad — sloppy attic installs are.”

---

🕳️ 3. Furnace in the Crawlspace — The Most Misunderstood Location

Crawlspaces are common in older homes, especially in humid southern states.

Tony says crawlspaces are the trickiest.

🟩 Crawlspace — The Pros

✔️ Shorter duct runs

Direct access to floor registers = better airflow.

✔️ Hidden from view

No indoor footprint.

✔️ Easier to route returns below floor

---

🟥 Crawlspace — The Cons

❌ Moisture

Humidity + condensation = rust, mold, motor failure.

❌ Flooding risk

Furnaces submerged during heavy rain = catastrophic.

❌ Pest access

Rodents and insects love warm equipment.

❌ Hard service conditions

Mud, cramped access, low clearance = rushed work.

❌ Freezing risk

Pipes freeze easily — especially condensate drains.

Tony’s take:

“A crawlspace furnace needs environmental protection or it won’t live past 7–10 years.”

✔️ Crawlspace moisture control reference (EPA):
https://www.epa.gov/mold/mold-cleanup-your-home

---

🟨 Tony Installs in Crawlspaces ONLY IF:

• Crawlspace is encapsulated

• Dehumidifier or vapor barrier is present

• Drain line doesn’t travel through unconditioned space

• Furnace is elevated 6–12 inches

• Service access door is wide enough

• Rodent-proofing is done

• Gas line & electrical line protected from moisture

Tony avoids crawlspaces in cold climates entirely.

---

🧱 4. Furnace in the Basement — Tony’s Favorite

Basements are Tony’s #1 choice for furnace location — when available.

🟩 Basement — The Pros

✔️ Stable temperatures

Cool in summer, warm in winter = ideal furnace environment.

✔️ Easiest service & longest equipment life

Techs can do full maintenance without contortion.

✔️ Best duct performance

Shorter runs + vertical trunk lines = better static pressure.

✔️ Best drainage

Gravity helps everything flow downhill.

✔️ Quietest installation

Basement walls absorb noise.

✔️ Space for zoning, humidifiers, filters

Upgrades become simple.

Tony says:

“A basement is the furnace’s natural habitat.”

✔️ Basement mechanical room standards: https://www.energystar.gov

---

🟥 Basement — The Cons

❌ Not available in slab homes

No workaround if the house simply doesn’t have one.

❌ Humidity / mold risk in wet basements

Needs waterproofing or dehumidification.

❌ Combustion air must be correctly routed

Especially for sealed-combustion 96% systems.

But these are fixable.

Tony will choose a basement location 100% of the time when possible.

---

🚪 5. Furnace in a Closet or Mechanical Room — The Most Common Modern Setup

Many new homes place furnaces in:

• Laundry room closets

• Hall closets

• Garage mechanical rooms

• Utility closets indoors

Tony says closets are fine if they follow the rules.

🟩 Closet — The Pros

✔️ Easy access

Service is simple.

✔️ Protected environment

Temperature-stable.

✔️ Short duct runs

Particularly in single-story homes.

✔️ Quiet when insulated properly

---

🟥 Closet — The Cons

❌ Combustion air often done wrong

Closet furnaces need:

• Louvered doors

• Upper & lower vents

• Direct-vent kits

Tony sees dozens of installs where the closet suffocates the furnace.

❌ Drain problems

Small closets = poor access for drain traps.

❌ Clearance issues

Installers violate manufacturer service clearances because of cramped spaces.

Tony says:

“Closet installs fail because of poor airflow, not because of the closet.”

✔️ Combustion air requirements: https://www.nfpa.org

---

🧮 6. Tony’s 4-Category Furnace Location Scoring System

Tony scores a possible location from 1–10 in four categories:

---

🔥 1. Airflow Score

• Is the return path easy?

• Can duct sizing be optimized?

• Can blower hit rated CFM?

Attics: 6/10
Crawlspaces: 5/10
Basements: 10/10
Closets: 8/10

---

💧 2. Drainage Score

• Does gravity work in your favor?

• Can the trap be serviced?

• Can the drain freeze?

Attics: 4/10
Crawlspaces: 3/10
Basements: 10/10
Closets: 8/10

---

❄️ 3. Environment Score

• Will the furnace see extreme temps?

• Moisture? Rodents? Dust? Attic heat?

Attics: 3/10
Crawlspaces: 4/10
Basements: 10/10
Closets: 9/10

---

🛠️ 4. Serviceability Score

• Can techs actually reach components?

• Is there working room?

• Will maintenance be done correctly?

Attics: 5/10
Crawlspaces: 2/10
Basements: 10/10
Closets: 7/10

---

⭐ Total Score (Tony’s Preference)

---

🔍 7. Real-World Case: The “Complaints for 7 Years” Furnace

A homeowner calls Tony:

“Every winter a tech comes out and says our furnace is fine — but the house is never warm.”

Tony inspects:

• Furnace in an uninsulated attic

• Return duct drooping

• Drain trap frozen

• Filter slot incorrect

• Blower at max speed due to high static

• Coil sweating into insulation

He moves the furnace to a hallway mechanical room.

Results:

• Static pressure drops from 0.9 → 0.45

• Supply heat increases

• ΔT stabilizes

• Humidity control improves

• Noise disappears

• Energy bill drops 25%

Homeowner says:

“It’s like a whole new house.”

Tony’s comment:

“It wasn’t the furnace — it was the location.”

---

🏁 Conclusion: Location Is a Design Decision, Not an Afterthought

Whether the furnace sits in an attic, crawlspace, basement, or closet changes:

• Efficiency

• Airflow

• Drainage

• Noise

• Longevity

• Safety

• Comfort

Tony’s final rule:

“Put the furnace where it can live — not where it can fit.”

When in doubt:

• Pick basement first

• Pick indoor closets next

• Use attics only with full prep

• Pick crawlspaces only when absolutely necessary

Buy this on Amazon at: https://amzn.to/4hyDyKH

In the next topic we will know more about: Why You Must Treat a 3-Ton Coil Like a Dehumidifier — Tony’s Rules for CFM-per-Ton Tweaks