Howdy Folks!
Mike here 👋—your down-to-earth, plain-talking guide to everything HVAC and home comfort. Today we’re going to dig into a problem that’s got more people steaming than their actual water: running out of hot water too fast from a 50–60 gallon electric water heater.
You bought that big tank because it’s supposed to last, right? But lately, it’s been tapping out halfway through your morning shower—or worse, quitting on you before the shampoo’s even rinsed. Don’t worry. I’ve got your back. Let’s troubleshoot it together. 🛠️
1. You’re Using More Hot Water Than You Think
Let’s start with the obvious: how much hot water are you actually using?
A standard 50-gallon water heater provides about 33–40 gallons of hot water before it starts refilling and reheating. So if your teenager takes 20-minute showers and you’re running the dishwasher and laundry at the same time—yeah, you’re gonna drain it.
Check your household usage against the Department of Energy's guide to hot water use to see if your tank capacity matches your needs.
Quick Fix:
Spread out hot water use—shower early, run the laundry later. Or go big and install a mixing valve to stretch that hot water farther by blending in more cold.
2. Sediment Buildup Is Stealing Your Heat 💨
Over time, minerals in your water (especially hard water) settle at the bottom of your tank. That creates an insulating layer of gunk that keeps the heating element from doing its job.
Too much sediment can reduce available hot water, make your heater work overtime, and even cause it to overheat and shut off early.
How to Check:
Open the drain valve and flush the tank.
If it hasn’t been flushed in over a year, chances are it’s working harder than a rookie plumber on Monday morning.
External Tip:
For a deep dive into water heater maintenance, Bob Vila’s guide is solid and easy to follow.
3. Faulty Dip Tube = Lukewarm Showers
Your water heater has a part called a dip tube—a plastic pipe that carries cold water to the bottom of the tank, so it can get heated properly.
If that dip tube cracks or falls apart (common in older models), cold water gets dumped near the top where the hot water outlet is… and guess what? You’re mixing cold water with the hot stuff before it’s ready.
How to Diagnose It:
If you’re getting bursts of hot water followed by lukewarm streams, the dip tube might be toast. It’s cheap to replace but can be a pain to access if you’re not familiar with plumbing.
For visual learners, check out Pros DIY’s repair video on diagnosing and replacing a dip tube. 📺
4. Heating Elements Are Worn Out or Broken 🔥
Most electric water heaters use two heating elements—one near the top and one at the bottom.
If one of them goes out, the heater may only be warming half a tank… which is fine until you try to fill the tub.
Signs You’ve Got a Bad Element:
-
Water gets warm, but not hot.
-
You get a short blast of hot water, then nada.
-
The water takes forever to reheat between uses.
DIY Check:
Turn off power at the breaker, remove the panel covers, and use a multimeter to test resistance on the elements. (If you’re not confident here, it’s okay to call a pro or reference this step-by-step from AO Smith).
5. Thermostat Is Set Too Low (Or Gone Bad)
Most 50–60 gallon electric heaters have dual thermostats—one for each heating element. If the thermostat’s miscalibrated or failing, it might not be heating the tank high enough.
Pro Tip:
Aim for 120°F. That’s hot enough for comfort and sanitation, but not so hot that you risk scalding or burning out your heater early.
You can safely adjust the thermostat with a flathead screwdriver. But if the temp stays low despite the setting, the thermostat itself may need replacing.
Not sure where to start?
Energy Vanguard has a helpful explanation of how water heater thermostats work and how to optimize them for performance and safety.
6. You’ve Got the Wrong Size Tank for Your Needs
A 50-gallon water heater is a good match for a 2–3 person household with average hot water use.
If you’ve got:
-
A big tub to fill 🛁
-
Multiple teens who shower daily 🚿
-
Laundry and dishes going constantly
…you may need to go bigger, or consider a hybrid or tankless backup system.
Before you go shopping, try the TLC plumbing sizing calculator to double-check your home’s hot water demand.
Bonus Tip: Insulate and Upgrade to Stretch Your Hot Water
Want to get the most out of your tank without replacing it? Try this:
-
Add an insulation blanket to the tank
-
Insulate hot water pipes for faster delivery
-
Install low-flow showerheads to use less hot water
-
Consider a point-of-use water heater in the kitchen or bathroom for hot water on demand
It won’t fix a broken dip tube or burnt-out element, but it can help you go farther between refills.
Final Thoughts from Mike
Look, I get it—running out of hot water is just plain frustrating, especially when you paid good money for a big ol’ 50–60 gallon tank. But the good news is, most of these issues are fixable without a plumber and without breaking the bank.
Keep your heater flushed, check those thermostats and elements, and don’t be afraid to do a little detective work. And if all else fails, it might be time to upgrade.
If you're in the market for a reliable new system, check out the 50–60 gallon electric water heaters available over at The Furnace Outlet. They've got top brands and great prices—no fluff, just the good stuff.
Worried about making installation mistakes? Visit: Installing a 50–60 Gallon Electric Water Heater.
Until next time, keep those pipes warm and your showers hot. 🔧
– Mike Sanders
The guy who still tests hot water with his hand like Grandma taught him
