For many homeowners, replacing a central AC system or a furnace is one of the most expensive home upgrades they’ll face. And when one unit fails, the big question comes up:
“Should I replace both my AC and furnace at the same time?”
The answer isn’t always straightforward. Sometimes it makes sense to replace both systems together, especially when age and efficiency are factors. Other times, staggering replacements saves money without sacrificing performance.
In this guide, we’ll walk through the pros, cons, and key considerations to help you make an informed choice.
Why AC and Furnace Replacements Often Overlap
Central AC and furnaces may look like separate systems, but in most homes they’re interconnected. Here’s why replacing one often involves the other:
-
Shared Components: Both systems rely on the same blower motor, air handler, and thermostat. If one system is brand new but paired with an older counterpart, mismatches can reduce performance.
-
Efficiency Standards: New regulations like SEER2 for AC and AFUE standards for furnaces raise the bar for efficiency. Mixing old and new equipment may prevent your system from performing as advertised.
-
Warranty Concerns: Some manufacturers won’t honor warranties if a new AC unit is paired with an incompatible furnace, or vice versa.
-
Contractor Recommendations: HVAC pros often suggest dual replacement to ensure compatibility and efficiency.
According to Energy.gov, the performance of an HVAC system depends not just on the individual unit but on how all components work together.
Benefits of Replacing AC and Furnace Together
1. Matched System Efficiency
When you upgrade both, your AC and furnace are designed to work together. That means your SEER2-rated AC and AFUE-rated furnace deliver their promised efficiency.
2. Lower Labor Costs
Doing both jobs at once reduces installation time. Contractors often provide package deals since they don’t need to make two separate visits.
3. Improved Comfort and Performance
A mismatched system can lead to uneven cooling and heating. With a matched pair, airflow and thermostat communication are optimized.
4. Warranty Alignment
Replacing both means you start fresh with warranties that run on the same timeline, simplifying future service.
Drawbacks of Dual Replacement
Of course, replacing both isn’t always the best move. Here are the potential downsides:
-
Higher Upfront Cost: Replacing both can cost $8,000–$15,000 depending on system size and efficiency.
-
Unnecessary Replacement: If your furnace is only five years old and running efficiently, replacing it alongside your AC wastes money.
-
Project Disruption: A full system replacement is more involved than replacing just one unit.
Consumer Reports advises weighing the age and condition of each unit before committing to a dual replacement.
When It Makes Sense to Replace Both
You’ll usually benefit from replacing both systems if:
-
Both units are 10–15 years old. Older systems are likely near the end of their useful life.
-
Major repairs are needed. A compressor failure in the AC or a cracked heat exchanger in the furnace may justify full replacement.
-
You want a major efficiency upgrade. ENERGY STAR-certified systems can cut utility bills significantly.
-
You’re planning to sell your home. A brand-new HVAC system is attractive to buyers.
When You Can Replace One System at a Time
Replacing one system alone may make sense if:
-
The other unit is relatively new. If your furnace is under 10 years old with a high AFUE rating, keep it until it’s closer to end-of-life.
-
You’re working within a budget. Staggering replacements can spread costs out.
-
Routine maintenance shows the other unit has life left. A well-maintained system may still run efficiently for several more years.
The American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE) emphasizes that proper maintenance extends system life and reduces the need for premature replacements.
Cost Considerations
Average Replacement Costs
-
AC Only: $4,000–$8,000
-
Furnace Only: $3,000–$7,000
-
Both Together: $8,000–$15,000
Incentives and Rebates
Federal tax credits and utility rebates in 2025 can significantly offset costs:
-
Federal Energy Efficiency Tax Credit: Up to 30% of installation costs, capped at $600–$2,000 for qualifying systems.
-
Utility Rebates: Many utilities offer $200–$1,000 back for ENERGY STAR-certified systems.
-
State Programs: The DSIRE database lists state-specific rebates.
According to Angi, replacing your AC and furnace together can save money in labor costs, reduce future service calls, and ensure both systems run more efficiently over time.
Key Takeaways for Homeowners
-
Dual replacement makes sense when both systems are aging, inefficient, or incompatible.
-
Staggering replacements is fine if one unit is newer, well-maintained, and efficient.
-
Factor in labor savings, warranty alignment, and rebates before deciding.
-
Always consult a licensed contractor for a professional load calculation and system inspection.
For a broader look at system comparisons across major brands, read our full guide: Top 10 Central AC Units Compared.
If you’re leaning toward saving money upfront, our next guide—The Real Cost of Cheap Central AC Units: What You’re Giving Up — explores why bargain units often cost more in the long run.
Final Thoughts from Alex Lane
Replacing your AC and furnace at the same time isn’t always necessary—but in many cases, it’s the smart move. When both systems are aging, efficiency is low, or major repairs are looming, dual replacement saves money in the long run and ensures better comfort.
On the other hand, if one system is still in great shape, you may be better off staggering replacements and using rebates to offset costs.
The key is to look beyond the sticker price. Consider efficiency, warranty coverage, and your home’s long-term comfort. With the right planning—and the right contractor—you’ll get an HVAC setup that saves energy, reduces stress, and keeps your family comfortable for years.
Alex Lane
Your Home Comfort Advocate
