Hey there, savvy shoppers! Samantha Reyes here, ready to help you navigate the sometimes confusing world of PTAC heating options. If you’re looking to upgrade your Packaged Terminal Air Conditioner (PTAC) unit or picking one out for the first time, understanding the heating choices available is key to getting cozy efficiently and saving on your energy bills.
PTACs come with different heating technologies—Electric Heat, Heat Pumps, and Hydronic Coils—and each has its pros and cons depending on your climate, budget, and comfort needs. In this guide, I’ll break down each option in straightforward terms, so you can make the smartest choice for your home or business.
Why Heating Matters in Your PTAC Unit
Before diving into the types, it’s important to understand why the heating component in your PTAC is so crucial. PTACs are popular in hotels, apartments, offices, and other spaces because they combine heating and cooling in a single unit installed through a wall. They’re compact, efficient, and great for zone control, meaning you can heat or cool just the rooms you want without wasting energy.
But not all heat is created equal. How your PTAC produces heat will impact your comfort, energy costs, and even maintenance needs. Let’s get into the details.
Option 1: Electric Heat – Simple, Reliable, But Watch Those Bills
How It Works
Electric heat PTACs use electric resistance heating elements inside the unit—kind of like a giant toaster—to warm up the air. When the thermostat calls for heat, electricity flows through these coils, generating warmth.
Pros
-
Reliable & Fast: Electric heat kicks in quickly and works consistently, no matter how cold it gets outside.
-
Simple Installation: No need for additional plumbing or complex hookups, making it easier and cheaper to install.
-
Low Maintenance: With fewer moving parts and no refrigerant involved, electric heating systems tend to need less upkeep.
Cons
-
Energy Costs: Electric heat is usually the most expensive heating option to operate, especially in areas with high electricity rates.
-
Environmental Impact: Depending on your electricity source, electric heat can have a larger carbon footprint compared to other heating methods.
Best For
-
Mild to moderate climates where heat is needed only occasionally.
-
Spaces where quick, reliable heat is a priority without the need for complex installation.
-
Renters or property managers seeking low-maintenance heating solutions.
Option 2: Heat Pump – Efficient, Eco-Friendly, and Versatile
How It Works
Heat pump PTACs work by transferring heat rather than generating it. During the winter, the heat pump extracts heat from the outside air—even when it’s cold—and moves it inside. In the summer, it reverses the process to cool your space.
Pros
-
Energy Efficiency: Because they move heat instead of producing it, heat pumps use much less electricity than electric resistance heaters, saving you money on energy bills.
-
Dual Function: Heat pumps provide both heating and cooling in one unit, making them incredibly versatile.
-
Lower Carbon Footprint: Heat pumps are generally more environmentally friendly, especially when paired with clean electricity sources.
Cons
-
Initial Cost: Heat pumps tend to have a higher upfront price tag than electric heat units.
-
Cold Climate Performance: Traditional heat pumps may struggle in very cold climates, although newer models with advanced technology perform better.
-
Maintenance: Slightly more complex than electric heat, requiring periodic servicing to maintain efficiency.
Best For
-
Moderate to warmer climates where heating loads are less extreme.
-
Energy-conscious homeowners looking to reduce their carbon footprint and utility costs.
-
Spaces needing year-round climate control in one system.
Option 3: Hydronic Coils – The Warm, Quiet, Water-Based Heat
How It Works
Hydronic coils use hot water (or steam) supplied by a central boiler or water heater. The hot water flows through a coil inside the PTAC, and a fan blows air over the coil, warming the room.
Pros
-
Comfort: Hydronic heat is known for providing gentle, even warmth without the dry air or noise sometimes associated with electric heat.
-
Quiet Operation: Since the heat source is water, these units tend to run quieter than electric or heat pump units.
-
Efficiency: When paired with an efficient boiler, hydronic systems can be very cost-effective, especially in buildings that already use boiler systems.
Cons
-
Installation Complexity: Requires plumbing for hot water supply, which can increase installation costs and complexity.
-
Limited Cooling Options: Hydronic coils only provide heat, so a separate cooling system or combined PTAC cooling function is needed.
-
Maintenance: The system depends on the central boiler’s maintenance and water quality.
Best For
-
Buildings with existing hydronic boiler systems.
-
Areas where quiet, comfortable heat is preferred over quick blasts of warmth.
-
Commercial or multi-unit residential buildings with centralized heating infrastructure.
How to Choose the Best Heating Option for Your PTAC
Consider Your Climate
-
Cold climates: Heat pumps with cold-climate technology or hydronic coils paired with a boiler can offer efficient warmth.
-
Mild climates: Electric heat may be sufficient and simpler.
Think About Energy Costs and Environmental Impact
-
If you want to save on utility bills and reduce your carbon footprint, heat pumps are a strong choice.
-
Electric heat is simple but can be costly over time.
Factor in Installation and Maintenance
-
Electric heat is the easiest and cheapest to install but may cost more long-term.
-
Hydronic coils require plumbing and a boiler system but offer quiet, comfortable heating.
-
Heat pumps need periodic servicing but combine heating and cooling in one.
Match to Your Building Type
-
Single-family homes and small offices often do well with heat pumps or electric heat.
-
Larger buildings with boilers benefit from hydronic coils.
Final Thoughts from Samantha
Choosing the right heating option for your PTAC unit is a balance of comfort, cost, and convenience. While electric heat offers simplicity, heat pumps provide efficiency and year-round climate control, and hydronic coils deliver quiet, cozy warmth in buildings with existing boiler systems.
Remember, no matter which option you pick, using an R-32 refrigerant PTAC ensures you’re also making an environmentally smart choice. If you want to learn more about R-32 and why it’s gaining popularity, check out our detailed guide here: Is R-32 the Right Refrigerant for Your PTAC Unit?
Got questions or ready to find your perfect PTAC? I’m here to help every step of the way!
