Gas vs Electric Furnaces

🔧 Intro: Two Furnaces Walk Into a Basement...

Okay, so maybe that’s not how the joke goes—but this decision’s no joke. I’ve had more customers than I can count ask me the same question: "Tony, should I go gas or electric?"

My answer? It depends. Every house is different, every homeowner has different priorities, and there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. But after 25+ years of crawling through basements and attics, installing furnaces coast to coast, I’ve got a pretty good idea of what works and what doesn’t.

This guide lays it all out: efficiency, cost, safety, environmental impact—you name it. By the time you’re done reading, you’ll know exactly which furnace fits your home, your budget, and your lifestyle.

Let’s get into it.


🔍 What’s the Real Difference Between Gas and Electric Furnaces?

🔥 Gas Furnaces

Gas furnaces burn natural gas or propane to create heat. A flame ignites in the burner, heating a metal heat exchanger, which then warms the air that’s pushed through your home via ductwork.

Best For:

  • Cold climates

  • Homes with existing gas lines

  • Folks who want lower long-term heating costs


⚡ Electric Furnaces

Electric furnaces use high-voltage electric resistance heating coils to warm up the air. No combustion, no gas, just electricity flowing through coils—like a giant toaster, but safer.

Best For:

  • Mild climates

  • Homes without gas lines

  • Simpler installations and lower upfront costs


💸 Installation Costs: The First Wallet Test

💰 Gas Furnace Installation

A standard gas furnace install will set you back $3,000 to $6,500, depending on size, efficiency, and how tricky the job is. That includes:

  • Furnace unit

  • Venting system

  • Gas line hookup

  • Condensate drain (for high-efficiency models)

If your home already has gas service and ductwork, you’re golden. But if not? Expect to pay more for running gas lines or updating your panel for electric alternatives.

⚡ Electric Furnace Installation

Electric furnaces are simpler and cheaper to install, with average prices between $2,000 to $4,000. Why? No gas hookup, no combustion venting, and fewer parts overall.

👉 HomeAdvisor has a helpful cost breakdown comparing both systems.

Winner: Electric takes the edge for installation price alone, especially in new builds or small spaces.


💵 Energy Costs: What You’ll Pay to Stay Warm

🔥 Gas Furnace Operating Costs

Natural gas is still one of the cheapest heating fuels out there. According to the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA), the average cost per therm of natural gas in the U.S. is significantly lower than the cost per kWh of electricity.

For most homes, this means:

  • Lower monthly heating bills

  • Better cost control in cold climates

  • Higher efficiency in terms of BTUs per dollar

That said, propane can be a different story. It’s often more expensive and varies heavily depending on your region.

⚡ Electric Furnace Operating Costs

Electricity is easier to install—but more expensive to run. Especially in the winter when you're pulling serious amperage.

  • Higher utility bills in cold regions

  • Stable but elevated costs in milder zones

  • 100% efficiency at point-of-use, but more expensive energy source

Check your local energy rates. This tool from EnergyBot helps you compare rates by ZIP code.

Winner: Gas, hands down, if you’re in a cold state and have access to natural gas. Over time, the savings are significant.


♻️ Efficiency and Environmental Impact

Here’s where it gets interesting.

🌱 Electric Furnaces

  • 100% AFUE (Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency)

  • No combustion = no carbon monoxide or flue gases

  • Can be powered by renewable electricity (solar, wind, hydro)

  • Lower maintenance and fewer moving parts

Electric furnaces don’t lose heat through a flue like gas models do. That’s a big win on paper. But generating electricity—especially from fossil fuels—still contributes to emissions unless you’re using renewables.

🔥 Gas Furnaces

  • Most models run at 80–96% AFUE

  • Ultra-high-efficiency models use condensing technology

  • Emits carbon monoxide and greenhouse gases

  • Must be vented properly

Newer condensing gas furnaces are incredibly efficient. According to ENERGY STAR, models with 95%+ AFUE are now standard in many areas with incentives to match.

Winner: If your electricity is green, electric takes the win. But for most homes using traditional grid power, high-efficiency gas offers a better balance of performance and environmental responsibility.


🔧 Maintenance and Longevity

Here’s something most folks overlook: the cost and hassle of maintenance.

🔥 Gas Furnace Maintenance

You’ve got more parts, more potential failure points:

  • Burners and igniters

  • Heat exchanger (can crack if neglected)

  • Gas valves and sensors

  • Exhaust venting systems

Annual service is non-negotiable, both for performance and safety.

⚡ Electric Furnace Maintenance

Electric units are simple machines. No burners, no combustion, no venting.

  • Just clean the blower and check the coil

  • Fewer parts to fail

  • Less regular servicing needed

👉 According to Bob Vila, gas furnaces typically last 15–20 years, while electric models can hit 20–30 years with proper care.

Winner: Electric, thanks to fewer breakdowns and longer lifespans.


🔒 Safety Considerations

You can’t put a price on peace of mind.

🔥 Gas Furnace Safety

  • Carbon monoxide risk if not vented properly

  • Combustion chamber cracks can leak harmful gases

  • Requires working CO detectors in the home

  • Gas leaks can be dangerous if undetected

⚡ Electric Furnace Safety

  • No combustion = no CO or exhaust

  • No risk of gas leaks

  • Lower fire risk if installed properly

  • Still requires proper electrical capacity

Bottom line? Gas is safe when installed and maintained properly—but electric is inherently safer, especially in homes with children, elderly, or those sensitive to indoor air quality.


🏠 Home Type and Regional Fit

If you live in a:

  • Southern climate (Zones 1–3)
     → Go electric. Winters are mild, and heating needs are low.

  • Northern climate (Zones 5–7)
     → Go gas. Efficiency and power matter more up north.

  • Mid-range climate (Zone 4)
     → Depends on energy costs, home size, and preferences.

Smaller homes, apartments, or off-grid homes often do better with electric—especially when paired with solar or heat pumps.

Bigger homes or older houses in cold states? Gas is the way.

👉 This climate zone map from the DOE will help you figure out where your house falls.


🧮 Which One’s Cheaper Long-Term?

Let’s do some napkin math:

Criteria Gas Furnace Electric Furnace
Upfront Cost $$$ $$
Installation Complexity High Low
Monthly Bills Low High
Maintenance Moderate Low
Lifespan 15–20 years 20–30 years
Rebates/Incentives High (in many areas) Low

In cold climates with affordable natural gas? Gas wins on lifetime value.

In warm climates or smaller homes? Electric makes more sense.


🧲 What About Dual-Fuel or Heat Pumps?

If you’re in a transitional climate or want the best of both worlds, dual-fuel systems are worth a look. These combine:

  • Electric heat pump for mild days

  • Gas furnace for cold snaps

They switch automatically depending on outdoor temps. It’s a smart way to maximize efficiency without sacrificing comfort.

Heat pump + gas furnace combos are becoming the new standard in many states—and may be required in the future as part of green building codes.


🛒 Where to Buy Your Next Furnace

You can find solid gas and electric furnaces at big box stores, but if you want real HVAC-grade equipment with proper documentation, warranty support, and product transparency, stick with a trusted supplier.

That’s where I send folks to The Furnace Outlet. You’ll find everything from high-efficiency gas models to plug-and-play electric systems, and they’ve got people who actually know HVAC—not just commission clerks reading off boxes.


🧠 Final Thoughts from Tony

Here’s the real takeaway:

  • If you live in a cold climate, have access to natural gas, and want to save on heating bills—go gas.

  • If you’re in a mild region, want a low-maintenance install, and don’t want to mess with venting or combustion—go electric.

  • If you’re somewhere in between, consider a hybrid system or run the numbers on both.

At the end of the day, comfort, budget, and utility rates will guide your choice. But now you’ve got the facts—and the experience of a guy who’s seen it all, installed it all, and fixed more than I care to admit.

Still have questions? Drop me a line. I’ll give it to you straight.

Stay warm, stay safe,
—Tony Marino

Tony’s toolbox talk

Leave a comment

All comments are moderated before being published