What’s the Difference Between Electric Heat and Heat Pump PTACs?

If you’re looking to add a room-by-room heating and cooling solution — maybe a guest room, basement suite, rental space or small business zone — then understanding the differences between electric-heat and heat-pump versions of the familiar hotel-style unit, often referred to as “hotel heat & air PTAC units,” is key. I’m Samantha, and I’ve helped dozens of homeowners and small business owners compare their options. Today let’s break down how these two types stack up — in performance, cost, climate suitability, and long-term comfort.

---

1. Setting the Stage: Why This Matters

When you pull up specs for a PTAC (packaged terminal air conditioner) you’ll often see that some models use electric resistance heating, and others are “heat pump” models. On the surface the difference might seem small — they both heat and cool a space — but behind the scenes the technology, efficiency, and suitability differ quite a bit.

Choosing the wrong type could mean higher energy bills, less comfort, or a system that struggles in your climate. So my goal here is to walk you through:

• How electric-heat PTACs work vs. heat-pump PTACs

• What each does best (and where they fall short)

• How to pick the right one for your climate and budget

• Real-world trade-offs you won’t usually see in product blurbs

Let’s get into it.

---

2. How Each Technology Works

2.1 Electric-Heat PTACs

In an electric-heat PTAC model, the heating function uses electric resistance elements — think of them like high-powered electrical heaters. Electricity flows through resistor coils, which generate heat; that heat is then blown into the room. The cooling side operates like a standard PTAC (compressor, evaporator, condenser, etc).

Because it’s resistance heating, the conversion of electricity to heat is nearly 100% efficient in that conversion sense — every unit of electric input becomes heat output. However the key issue is that it generates heat rather than moves it, which limits how efficient it can be when you’re comparing total energy use. (For background reading on how resistance vs. heat pump compare, see this breakdown.) Energy.gov

2.2 Heat-Pump PTACs

A heat-pump PTAC works a little differently. Instead of generating heat from electrical resistance, it “moves” heat from one place to another — extracting warmth from outdoor air (even when it’s cool) and delivering it indoors. In cooling mode it reverses the cycle (just like an air-conditioner). Because it moves heat instead of creating it, it can deliver more heat for each unit of electrical input — often achieving a coefficient of performance (COP) greater than 1 (often 2-3 or more). NREL.gov

In short:

• Electric-heat = straightforward, simpler mechanics, but higher operating cost.

• Heat-pump = more complex (compressor, reversing valve, etc) but significantly more efficient when conditions allow.

---

3. Performance & Efficiency Comparison

3.1 Energy Efficiency

One of the biggest differentiators is how much heat you get per unit of electricity consumed.

• Electric-heat models: Because they convert electricity directly into heat, their effective “output” is about 1 unit heat per unit electricity (COP ≈ 1).

• Heat-pump models: Because they move heat, many can achieve COPs of 2, 3 or greater under favorable outdoor conditions. For example, some sources note PTAC heat-pump systems “move” heat rather than generate it, making them much more efficient. federalregister.gov

3.2 Operating Cost

Because of the difference in efficiency, operating cost tends to favour heat-pump models (in the right climate).

For example: if you’re in a moderate climate where outdoor temperatures don’t plunge too low, a heat-pump PTAC will likely cost you less to run for the same output than an electric-heat model.

However: in very cold outdoor conditions, a heat-pump’s efficiency can drop (because there’s less “heat” outside to extract) — and at some point it can approach the performance of electric resistance. northnjhvac.com

3.3 Performance in Different Climates

• Mild to moderate climates: Heat-pump models shine here. They deliver efficient heating and cooling and good comfort year-round.

• Cold climates (very low outdoor temps): Electric-heat models are more predictable because they don’t rely on extracting heat from the outside; they simply generate it. If you have long stretches of very cold weather, the built-in efficiency advantage of heat pumps might shrink. 

3.4 Installation & Maintenance

• Electric-heat models are often simpler (less mechanical parts) which can mean lower upfront cost and potentially lower maintenance overhead.

• Heat-pump models have more moving parts (compressor, reversing valve, refrigerant circuit) and more sensitivity to installation quality (sizing, refrigerant charge, outdoor air path) — which means you want a competent installer to maximize performance.

---

4. Side-by-Side Comparison Table

Here’s a quick table summarizing key differences:

---

5. How to Choose Which One for Your Space

Here’s a practical decision path — I walk this through with the folks I advise.

Step A: Consider your climate

• If you live in a region where winters get very cold (well below freezing for extended periods), you might lean toward a model with electric resistance heat (either standalone or as backup) because the outdoor air source may not supply enough heat for efficient operation of a heat pump.

• If your winters are milder (freezing nights maybe, but not long sustained deep cold), a heat-pump PTAC is likely your better bet for long-term cost savings.

Step B: Consider usage & zone size

• If you’re using the PTAC in a guest room, basement office, or rental unit that isn’t used continuously, the simplicity of electric-heat might make sense — especially if you only need heat occasionally.

• If you’re using it as a main heating/cooling source for a space you’ll occupy often (say a studio rental, or a finished basement you’ll use year-round), then the efficiency gains of a heat-pump model become more meaningful over time.

Step C: Evaluate your budget & installation constraints

• If upfront budget is tight and you need something basic, an electric-heat model might get you started.

• But remember: the long-term operating cost difference could offset the upfront savings. It’s worth estimating your electricity cost over time.

• Also check your installation: do you have adequate wall sleeve, outdoor air path, sufficient insulation, and correct electrical supply? For heat-pump units, correct installation is more critical.

Step D: Future-proofing & resale value

• If you ever plan to rent the space, increase usage, or perhaps convert it into a more frequently used room, a heat-pump PTAC is more future-proof.

• Electric resistance models might be fine for now, but may cost more to operate or may limit comfort if usage changes.

---

6. Real-World Scenarios: Which Option Fits Which Situation

Here are some sample settings to illustrate how I help homeowners pick.

Scenario 1: Cold-climate guest room

Imagine you have a basement guest suite in a region where winters go well below freezing for weeks. Usage is occasional (guests on weekends). Here the electric-heat PTAC could be a good fit: simple install, heating when needed, less concern about outdoor heat extraction. The trade-off: possibly higher electricity bills, but that's acceptable given limited use.

Scenario 2: Year-round rental unit in moderate climate

You have a small studio apartment you rent out year-round in a region with mild winters. Here the heat-pump PTAC likely wins: lower operating costs, full heating & cooling coverage, guests will appreciate comfort, and the pay-back on efficiency can add up.

Scenario 3: Large space, high use, mixed climate

You convert a garage into a home office with frequent use, in a region with hot summers and cold winters. Here you may lean strongly toward a heat-pump model but also ensure you choose a “cold-climate” rated one (if you’re in very cold winter conditions) or have a supplemental resistance heat backup. It may cost more upfront, but the comfort and long-term savings could be significant.

---

7. Key Questions to Ask Before You Choose

When you’re comparing models and talking to installers, here are questions you’ll want answers to:

1. What’s the rated heating capacity (BTU) for this model at my location’s cold temperature?
   (Because outdoor temperature impacts heat-pump performance.)

2. What is the efficiency rating (EER, HSPF or equivalent) of the heating/cooling mode?
   (Higher numbers = better efficiency.)

3. Does this model use electric resistance heating as backup or as main heat?
   If yes, what is the cost impact?

4. What’s the minimum outdoor temperature at which this heat-pump still performs effectively?
   (For many units, performance drops below a certain outdoor temp.) 

5. What’s the upfront cost difference between the electric-heat option and the heat-pump option (including installation)?
   Compare that to estimated operating cost difference over 5–10 years.

6. What are the maintenance requirements and expected lifetime of each model?
   Heat-pump models might require more regular inspections of refrigerant, outdoor coils, etc.

7. Which model fits in the existing wall sleeve or do I need to modify wall/venting?
   If you’re retrofitting, installation cost differences may override efficiency gains.

---

8. My Best Advice for Homeowners and Small Business Owners

Since I’ve helped many people through this, here are some of the “Samantha-tips” I share in casual conversation:

• Don’t pick just on upfront cost. That cheaper electric-heat model might cost you more in electricity in the long run if you use it heavily.

• Think about how often the space will be used. If it’s occasional, simplicity may be fine. If daily, efficiency matters more.

• Check insulation and windows. Even the most efficient heat-pump PTAC will struggle if the room is leaky or poorly insulated.

• Consider total cost of ownership. Operation + maintenance + installation matters more than the purchase price alone.

• Look ahead: what if you rent the room later? Or convert it? Choosing the more efficient model might pay off if usage increases.

• Get a reputable installer. Especially for heat-pump models, proper installation affects performance dramatically.

• Ask about “cold climate” ratings if your winters are harsh. Not all heat pumps are created equal.

• Check control features. Thermostat, fan modes, remote control, smart integration — these affect comfort and convenience.

• Budget for maintenance. Even though PTAC units are simpler than full systems, make sure you plan for filter changes, coil cleaning, seasonal check-ups.

---

9. Final Takeaways

• If your priority is simple, reliable heat for a space that’s used occasionally or in a very cold climate, an electric-heat PTAC model can be a fine, straightforward choice.

• If you’re installing comfort in a space that’s used frequently — especially if you also need cooling — and you’re in a moderate climate (or can get a “cold-climate” rated unit), then a heat-pump PTAC is likely the better long-term option.

• The difference in efficiency can translate into meaningful cost savings and comfort improvements — but it only pays off if the installation is done right, the room is well suited, and you choose the model that matches your climate and usage.

• Ultimately, the “best” choice is the one that fits your specific space, budget, climate, and usage pattern. There’s no one-size-fits-all — but with this comparison, you’re much better equipped to make a confident decision.

In the next blog, you will dive deep into "Can You Install a PTAC Unit Yourself? What to Know Before You Cut the Wall".