What Is the Difference Between Electric Heat and Heat Pump PTACs?

Smart Heating Choices for Your Guest Space, Home Office, or Rental Suite

---

🛏️ Introduction: Why Heating Type Matters in a PTAC Unit

If you're considering a PTAC (Packaged Terminal Air Conditioner) for your home, guest suite, or Airbnb, you've probably already noticed they come in two heating options: electric resistance heat and heat pump. At first glance, they may seem interchangeable—but they’re not. Your comfort, energy bills, and winter performance all hinge on which one you choose.

For homeowners like Samantha, a small business owner with a guest space in Northern California, energy efficiency is top priority. But she also wants warmth on chilly nights and low maintenance all year. The question is: heat pump or electric heat?

Let’s break down the key differences—so you can confidently choose the right PTAC system for your climate, budget, and space.

---

⚡ What Is Electric Heat in a PTAC Unit?

Electric resistance heat works just like a space heater: it passes current through metal coils to generate heat, which a fan then blows into the room. It’s simple, direct, and effective.

✅ Pros of Electric Heat PTACs:

• Works in all temperatures — even when it’s below freezing

• Fewer moving parts = less that can break

• Lower upfront cost

• Immediate heat output

❌ Cons:

• Higher electricity use than a heat pump

• Costly to run in cold climates

• No cooling benefit from the heating process

💡 Best for:

• Cold climates with frequent freezing temps

• Guest rooms used only occasionally

• Supplemental heat in basements or attics

---

🔁 What Is a Heat Pump PTAC?

A heat pump PTAC doesn’t create heat—it moves it. In winter, it reverses the refrigeration cycle to pull warmth from the outside air (even if it’s chilly) and transfers it inside. In summer, it works like a regular air conditioner.

✅ Pros of Heat Pump PTACs:

• Uses far less electricity than electric heat

• Lower energy bills

• Great for moderate climates

• All-in-one heating and cooling

❌ Cons:

• Less effective in freezing temperatures

• Slightly higher upfront cost

• More components = more maintenance potential

💡 Best for:

• Year-round rentals or apartments

• Regions with mild to moderate winters

• Energy-conscious homeowners

---

💰 Cost Comparison: Upfront and Operating Costs

Energy Savings Example

According to the U.S. Department of Energy, heat pumps can reduce electricity use for heating by approximately 50% compared to electric resistance heating.

---

🌎 Which Heating Type Is Better for Your Climate?

Climate makes a huge difference. Let’s compare:

🔥 Cold Climate (below 25°F often):

• Electric heat wins

• Heat pumps lose efficiency rapidly

• May require a backup heating strip

🌤️ Mild to Moderate Winters (30–60°F):

• Heat pump is ideal

• Uses less energy

• More eco-friendly

📍 Use this Climate Zone Map to check where your region lands:
🔗 U.S. DOE Climate Zones

---

📏 Space Type Matters, Too

---

🔌 Electrical Considerations: Do You Have the Right Circuit?

Before you decide, make sure your space has the right electrical support:

⚠️ Always consult an electrician before installation. Improper wiring can trip breakers or cause fire hazards.
🔗 Learn more at NFPA

---

🧰 Maintenance & Longevity

🛠️ Electric Heat PTAC

• Pros: Fewer components, low maintenance

• Cons: May run hotter and wear coils faster

🔁 Heat Pump PTAC

• Pros: Efficient operation extends component life

• Cons: Needs occasional compressor service

Both systems benefit from:

• Cleaning air filters monthly

• Flushing condensate drains

• Vacuuming coils 1–2 times a year

---

🧾 Real Models to Compare

Here are two excellent options from The Furnace Outlet:

💨 GE Zoneline 12,000 BTU PTAC with Heat Pump (Model AJEQ12DC)

• 208/230V, 20 amp

• Heat pump and backup electric

• Energy-efficient EER 10.6
  

🔥 Amana 9,000 BTU Electric Heat PTAC (Model PTC093K35AXXX)

• 208/230V, 15 amp

• 3.5 kW heat kit

• Simple install, quiet operation
  

---

✅ How Samantha Made Her Choice

Samantha lives in a coastal California town where winter lows rarely dip below 40°F. After comparing power bills and comfort needs, she chose a heat pump PTAC for her Airbnb guest unit. It keeps the space cool in summer, warm in winter, and her monthly utility costs dropped by nearly 30%.

If she were setting up a ski cabin in Tahoe, though? She’d go electric all the way.

---

📋 Final Checklist: Which PTAC Should You Choose?

Choose a Heat Pump PTAC if you…

• Live in a moderate climate

• Want lower utility bills

• Run the unit daily

• Don’t expect deep winter cold

Choose an Electric Heat PTAC if you…

• Live in a cold climate

• Only use the room occasionally

• Prefer simplicity

• Want reliable backup heat

---

🏁 Conclusion: Smart Heating for Smart Spaces

Both heat pump and electric PTACs have their place—it’s all about matching the unit to your climate, usage patterns, and long-term goals.

If you're like Samantha—trying to find that sweet spot between savings and comfort—a heat pump PTAC may be the upgrade your guest space deserves. But for freezing climates, electric heat remains the tried-and-true workhorse.

In the next topic we will know more about: Best PTAC Brands Compared: GE Zoneline vs. Amana vs. Hotpoint