Troubleshooting Guide — Common Furnace Issues and Fixes

🔍 How to Know When Something’s Wrong

Furnace issues rarely start as emergencies. Most begin with small signs — changes in sound, air temperature, or performance — that get worse over time if ignored.

120,000 BTU 80% AFUE Upflow/Horizontal Two Stage Goodman Gas Furnace

Savvy learned this the hard way one January when her system began cycling on and off more frequently. The house stayed warm, but her utility bill jumped 20%. What seemed minor turned out to be a dirty flame sensor — a five-minute professional fix that saved her hours of frustration later.

Here’s what she learned: pay attention early.

🔧 Common Warning Signs

• Unusual noises — rattling, whistling, or booming

• Uneven heating (cold upstairs, hot downstairs)

• Short cycling (turning on/off frequently)

• Weak airflow

• Cool air blowing instead of heat

• Higher gas or electric bills

• A faint burning smell or unusual odor

As Energy Star explains, “a well-maintained furnace should operate quietly and evenly.” If something changes, it’s a sign to look closer.

This guide breaks down the most common furnace problems Savvy has faced — what causes them, what homeowners can safely check, and when to call in the pros.

---

🔥 Furnace Won’t Turn On

When your furnace doesn’t start at all, the cause could be as simple as a flipped switch or a tripped circuit.

Possible Causes

• Tripped circuit breaker or blown fuse

• Thermostat not set to “Heat”

• Power switch accidentally off (often looks like a light switch near the furnace)

• Dirty flame sensor or faulty igniter

Savvy’s Checklist:

1. Check the thermostat — Is it on Heat? Is the temperature higher than the current room temp?

2. Inspect the power — Make sure the furnace switch is in the ON position.

3. Check the breaker panel — Flip the HVAC breaker fully off, then back on.

4. Look for indicator lights — Many Goodman models have LED codes visible through a small window. A flashing red light often indicates an ignition issue.

If the furnace still doesn’t start after these checks, the issue is likely internal (igniter, control board, or gas valve).

📘 Learn more: Installation 101 — What to Expect When Setting Up a Two-Stage Gas Furnace.

---

💨 Furnace Blows Cold Air

You expect warm, steady air — not a blast of cold from your vents.

Common Causes

• Dirty air filter restricting airflow

• Clogged flame sensor preventing ignition

• Blower running without heat (fan set to On)

• Overheating safety shutdown due to poor ventilation

Savvy’s Quick Fix:

1. Replace the air filter. If it’s clogged, airflow drops and the heat exchanger overheats.

2. Check the thermostat fan mode. It should be set to Auto, not On.

3. Confirm your gas valve is open. Look for the handle parallel to the pipe.

4. Listen for the ignition sequence. If you don’t hear a click or see the igniter glow, it may need professional replacement.

💡 Pro Tip: If your furnace runs briefly and then shuts down, it could be a dirty flame sensor — an easy fix for a technician.

📚 Resource: HVAC.com – Furnace Troubleshooting Basics.

---

🧭 Weak Airflow or Uneven Heating

If one room feels like the tropics and another like an icebox, airflow imbalance is usually the culprit.

Possible Causes

• Dirty filter or blower wheel

• Blocked or closed vents

• Leaky or poorly sealed ducts

• Improper blower speed setting

Savvy’s Fix:

• Replace or clean the filter.

• Walk through the home and ensure every vent is open (even in unused rooms).

• Vacuum return grilles to remove dust.

• Check for furniture blocking vents.

If the issue persists, ducts might be leaking. Savvy discovered dust streaks near duct seams — a telltale sign of leaks. After sealing them with foil-backed mastic, her airflow improved instantly.

💡 Pro Tip: Balancing airflow keeps your Goodman’s 9-speed blower running at optimal efficiency, minimizing wear.

📘 Related: Maintenance Made Simple — How Savvy Keeps Her Furnace Running Efficiently.

---

🔊 Furnace Is Making Strange Noises

A healthy furnace hums quietly. Unusual noises are its way of saying something’s off.

Noise Decoder:

Savvy once noticed a high-pitched whistling sound that turned out to be a clogged filter. “I replaced it, and the sound disappeared within minutes.”

The Goodman HVAC Learning Center emphasizes that unusual sounds often relate to airflow or ignition timing — both simple to address when caught early.

---

⚠️ Furnace Keeps Turning On and Off (Short-Cycling)

Short-cycling — frequent on-off cycles — is hard on your furnace and wallet.

Common Causes

• Thermostat too close to a vent (temperature readings skewed)

• Dirty filter causing overheating

• Flame sensor fouled

• Blocked exhaust vent

• Oversized furnace cycling rapidly to avoid overheating

Savvy’s Fix:

• Move any obstructions near the thermostat.

• Replace the filter.

• Check that exterior vents are clear of snow or debris.

• Call a pro if short-cycling persists — it could indicate sizing or gas pressure issues.

💡 Pro Tip: Two-stage systems like Goodman’s are designed to prevent short-cycling by running longer at low fire. If yours is cycling frequently, something’s interfering with that balance.

---

🧪 Furnace Smells Funny (Dust, Gas, or Musty Odor)

Not all furnace smells are bad — some are perfectly normal when heating season starts.

Smell Decoder:

The EPA Indoor Air Quality Guide stresses that any gas-like smell warrants immediate action — never try to relight or restart your system until a professional clears it.

Savvy once smelled something “off” after replacing a filter — it turned out she had accidentally installed it backward, restricting airflow. A quick fix, but an important reminder: always follow the arrow direction on filters.

---

🔥 Pilot Light or Igniter Won’t Stay Lit

Older furnaces used pilot lights, but modern Goodman units rely on electronic ignition.

Possible Causes:

• Dirty flame sensor or igniter

• Faulty thermocouple (older models)

• Weak gas supply

• Control board malfunction

Savvy’s Fix:

• Inspect through the furnace window for a steady blue flame.

• If the igniter doesn’t glow, shut off power — it may need replacement.

• Never attempt to bypass safety sensors or manually light an electronic igniter.

💡 Pro Tip: Igniters are delicate — oils from your fingers can damage them. Always let a licensed technician handle replacements.

---

🧯 Furnace Is Overheating or Shutting Down Unexpectedly

If your furnace runs briefly, then shuts off, it may be overheating.

Possible Causes

• Dirty filter restricting airflow

• Clogged blower wheel

• Faulty limit switch (a safety device)

• Blocked supply vents

Savvy’s Fix:

1. Turn off the furnace.

2. Replace the air filter.

3. Wait 10–15 minutes, then restart.

4. If the issue repeats, schedule a service appointment.

As Energy.gov notes, overheating can crack the heat exchanger — a costly and dangerous repair. Regular maintenance prevents this completely.

---

📉 Higher Utility Bills Without Increased Use

A sudden jump in your energy bill usually signals hidden inefficiency.

Possible Causes

• Dirty filter or blower

• Leaky ducts

• Malfunctioning thermostat

• Two-stage system stuck on “high fire” mode

Savvy’s Fix:

• Check your filter first — it’s the most common cause.

• Inspect duct connections in your attic or basement.

• Run your thermostat’s test cycle to confirm both heating stages activate.

Savvy noticed her bills rising despite mild weather — her technician found the thermostat wire controlling low-fire mode had come loose. One screw tightened, and her system was back to normal efficiency.

💡 Pro Tip: Monitor your utility bill each month. A steady increase without lifestyle changes is the furnace’s way of telling you it needs attention.

---

🛠️ Error Codes and LED Light Indicators

Goodman furnaces come with built-in LED diagnostic lights that “blink” to indicate issues.

Common Code Meanings:

💡 Savvy Tip: Turn off furnace power before opening the front panel to view codes. Keep a printed copy of your Goodman owner’s manual nearby — or bookmark the Goodman Manuals Page.

Understanding codes helps technicians diagnose faster, saving you labor costs.

---

📞 When to Call a Professional

Some problems have easy homeowner fixes — others are strictly professional territory.

Call an HVAC Technician If:

• You smell gas or burning plastic

• Your furnace repeatedly shuts off

• Your CO detector goes off

• The blower motor hums but doesn’t spin

• LED codes repeat even after filter replacement

• The flame looks orange or yellow (indicates poor combustion)

Goodman’s warranty requires professional service to maintain coverage, so it’s always better to err on the side of caution.

📘 Goodman Warranty Registration

💬 Savvy Says: “I handle the easy stuff — filters, vents, thermostat checks — but when it comes to gas or wiring, I leave it to the pros. That’s peace of mind.”

---

🧠 Savvy’s Real-World Troubleshooting Story

One winter, Savvy’s furnace started short-cycling — running for two minutes, then shutting down.

She replaced the filter, reset the thermostat, and checked the breaker — no luck. When her HVAC technician arrived, he cleaned the flame sensor, which had built up a thin layer of dust.

“It took him 10 minutes,” she laughs. “Now I schedule cleaning every fall before it gets cold. That tiny part was the difference between comfort and chaos.”

Understanding the basics helped her explain the symptoms clearly, saving her diagnostic time and cost.

---

🧾 Homeowner’s Quick Troubleshooting Flow

💡 Savvy Tip: Use this checklist seasonally to spot patterns before they become emergencies.

---

🌟 The Bottom Line — Smart Diagnosis, Safe Fixes

A well-maintained furnace doesn’t just heat your home — it gives you control, confidence, and peace of mind.

Savvy’s approach is simple:

• Observe early — pay attention to changes in sound or airflow.

• Check what’s safe — filters, vents, breakers, and thermostat.

• Call professionals for gas, wiring, or ignition issues.

Your Goodman furnace is built to last decades, but only if it’s cared for properly. With a little attention, you can solve 80% of small issues yourself and prevent costly repairs down the line.

“Understanding what’s normal — and what’s not — gives me confidence,” Savvy says. “Now I catch problems early instead of waiting for something to break.”

That’s smart troubleshooting — and that’s the Savvy way.

In the next topic we will know more about: How Much Does a Goodman 80% AFUE Furnace Cost in 2025? Real Budgeting Tips