PTAC vs. Electric Heat vs. Hydronic: Which Heating Option Wins?
Heating your home or property is one of those decisions that impacts your comfort and your wallet for years to come. With so many options available—ranging from PTAC heat pumps to traditional electric resistance heating and hydronic (water-based) systems—choosing the right solution can feel overwhelming.
The good news? Each option has strengths, drawbacks, and ideal applications. This article will break down the differences in plain English so you can decide which one wins for your specific situation.
The Contenders: A Quick Overview
Before we compare them, let’s set the stage with what each system actually is.
1. PTAC Heat Pumps
-
Definition: A self-contained heating and cooling unit, usually installed through a wall sleeve. Combines AC and heat pump technology.
-
How It Works: In heating mode, the refrigerant cycle reverses to pull heat from outside air and deliver it indoors. When it’s too cold, it can switch to backup electric heat.
-
Common Use Cases: Hotels, apartments, senior housing, sunrooms, small businesses.
-
Key Benefit: Year-round comfort (heating + cooling) in one system.
2. Electric Resistance Heating
-
Definition: The simplest form of electric heat—think baseboard heaters, electric furnaces, or space heaters.
-
How It Works: Electricity passes through a heating element, which glows hot and transfers that heat into the room.
-
Common Use Cases: Supplemental heating, low upfront cost homes, garages, older apartments.
-
Key Benefit: Simple, reliable, and works in any climate.
3. Hydronic Heating
-
Definition: Heating system that uses hot water (or sometimes steam) circulated through pipes and radiators/baseboards.
-
How It Works: A boiler heats water, which is then distributed through a network of pipes. The water radiates heat into rooms before returning to be reheated.
-
Common Use Cases: Multi-family housing, older homes in cold climates, commercial buildings.
-
Key Benefit: Comfortable, even heating with low noise.
👉 For a deeper dive on hydronic heating systems, see U.S. DOE Hydronic Heating Overview.
Efficiency Face-Off
Heating efficiency isn’t just about comfort—it’s about cost. Here’s how the three systems compare:
-
-
Typically 2–3 times more efficient than electric resistance heat in moderate climates, thanks to the heat pump cycle.
-
According to reports, heat pumps can provide the same heating at a fraction of the energy use compared to resistance heaters.
-
However, efficiency drops below ~25–30°F, when backup resistance heat engages.
-
-
Electric Resistance Heat:
-
Nearly 100% efficient at converting electricity into heat—but that’s the problem. Every kilowatt of energy becomes heat, with no multiplier effect.
-
In regions with high electricity rates, costs can skyrocket.
-
-
Hydronic Heating:
-
Efficiency depends on the boiler type. Modern condensing boilers can reach 90–95% efficiency.
-
Systems retain heat well and distribute it evenly, but installation costs are high.
-
👉 According to the U.S. Energy Information Administration, space heating is the single largest end-use of energy in homes, making efficiency a critical decision factor.
Comfort Levels Compared
Heating isn’t just numbers—it’s how the warmth feels.
-
PTAC Heat Pumps: Deliver quick, direct airflow. Some find the fan-driven heat less “cozy” than radiant systems. However, modern units have quieter fans and better airflow control.
-
Electric Resistance: Provides dry, intense heat. Good for spot heating but can create uneven comfort.
-
Hydronic: Offers the most even, comfortable heat. Radiant warmth feels natural and avoids drafts.
If comfort is your top priority, hydronic usually wins. But if flexibility matters, PTACs are hard to beat.
Installation & Upfront Costs
-
PTAC Heat Pumps: Moderate upfront cost. Units are self-contained, so installation is simpler—cut a wall opening, install a sleeve, and wire it. No ductwork needed. Replacement is easy (slide out, slide in).
-
Electric Resistance: Lowest upfront cost. Baseboard heaters or plug-in units are inexpensive. But if you need whole-house coverage, costs add up and so do utility bills.
-
Hydronic: Highest upfront cost. Requires a boiler, piping network, and radiators. Retrofitting into a home without existing hydronic infrastructure can be prohibitively expensive.
Maintenance & Lifespan
-
PTAC Heat Pumps: Require regular filter cleaning, coil maintenance, and occasional servicing of the compressor or fans. Lifespan: 7–12 years.
-
Electric Resistance: Minimal maintenance. Just keep units dust-free. Lifespan: 20+ years.
-
Hydronic: Boilers and piping need annual maintenance. Leaks, corrosion, and pump failures can occur. Lifespan: 15–30 years, depending on the system.
👉 For PTAC care tips, see ACHR News: Maintenance of PTAC Units.
Climate Considerations
Your local weather plays a huge role in the best choice:
-
Cold Climates:
-
Hydronic shines here—steady warmth even below zero.
-
PTAC heat pumps may need frequent backup resistance heating, raising costs.
-
-
Mild/Moderate Climates:
-
PTAC heat pumps are extremely efficient.
-
Electric resistance is fine for supplemental heating.
-
-
Hot Summers + Mild Winters:
-
PTAC wins again—provides both cooling and heating in one package.
-
Noise & Aesthetics
-
PTAC Heat Pumps: Louder than hydronic or baseboard systems, since they rely on fans and compressors. Modern models are quieter but still audible.
-
Electric Resistance: Silent (except fan-forced heaters).
-
Hydronic: Nearly silent—one of its biggest appeals.
If noise is a dealbreaker, hydronic leads, followed by baseboard resistance heaters.
Environmental Impact
-
PTAC Heat Pumps: Can significantly cut emissions if powered by clean electricity. The new ENERGY STAR PTHP specification highlights the environmental benefits of efficient units.
-
Electric Resistance: Worst option for emissions if electricity is fossil-fuel heavy, since it consumes more energy.
-
Hydronic: Depends on the boiler fuel. Natural gas boilers are cleaner than oil but still emit CO₂. Renewable hydronic systems (like solar thermal or biomass boilers) are greener.
Cost Over Time: Total Cost of Ownership
When you factor in upfront, operating, and maintenance costs, here’s how the contenders shake out:
-
PTAC Heat Pumps: Moderate upfront cost, lower operating cost in mild climates, moderate maintenance. Great balance overall.
-
Electric Resistance: Low upfront, very high operating costs in the long run. Good for supplemental or rare use, not whole-home heating.
-
Hydronic: High upfront, moderate to low operating cost depending on fuel. Excellent comfort but expensive to install.
Who Wins?
It depends on your situation:
-
Choose PTAC Heat Pumps if…
-
You need both cooling and heating in one unit.
-
You manage hotels, apartments, or senior living.
-
You live in a mild to moderate climate.
-
-
Choose Electric Resistance if…
-
You want the lowest upfront cost.
-
You need supplemental or emergency heat.
-
You live in a very small space or use heat infrequently.
-
-
Choose Hydronic if…
-
You live in a very cold climate.
-
You prioritize comfort and quiet.
-
You’re willing to invest in higher upfront costs for long-term payoff.
-
Final Thoughts
There’s no one-size-fits-all winner. PTAC heat pumps are versatile and efficient for year-round comfort in moderate climates. Electric resistance is simple and cheap up front but costly to run. Hydronic heating offers unmatched comfort but requires significant upfront investment.
The right choice depends on your climate, budget, and whether you value efficiency, comfort, or simplicity most.
