🧱 What’s the Difference Between PTAC Heat Pump and Electric Heat?
Here’s the short version: both PTAC heat pump units and electric resistance heat models give you heating and cooling in one wall unit—but how they generate heat is totally different.
🔁 PTAC Heat Pump
A PTAC unit with a heat pump works by reversing the refrigerant cycle. Instead of pushing heat out of your space like it does in the summer, it pulls heat in from the outside air during winter.
✅ Pros:
-
Super energy efficient in moderate climates
-
Lower electric bills when temps aren’t freezing
-
Great for long-term use and multi-room setups
⚠️ Cons:
-
Doesn’t work well in freezing temps (below 35°F)
-
Might need a backup heat source in colder regions
🔌 PTAC with Electric Heat
These units use electric resistance coils to generate heat—like a giant toaster oven in your wall. Flip the heat on, and it gets hot immediately.
✅ Pros:
-
Reliable in any climate—works great even in subzero temps
-
Simple design, fewer moving parts
-
Instant heat with no delay
⚠️ Cons:
-
Uses more electricity
-
Not as efficient as heat pumps, especially for large buildings or long use
🧊 Cooling Performance is Identical
Whether you choose electric heat or a heat pump, the cooling side of the unit is essentially the same. So the choice really comes down to how you want to heat your space.
📍 Which Is Right for You?
Here’s my breakdown by situation:
✅ Go with a PTAC Heat Pump if:
-
You’re in a mild or warm region (like the South or coastal areas)
-
You want lower utility bills over time
-
You have multiple rooms or long heating seasons
✅ Go with PTAC + Electric Heat if:
-
You’re in a cold climate with freezing winters ❄️
-
You need instant, reliable heat no matter what
-
You’re outfitting hotel rooms or rentals with short stays
Still not sure? This guide from Energy Star on heat pump performance offers some excellent insight.
💰 Which One Saves More Money?
This one’s tricky. Heat pumps can save more money over time—but only if your climate allows them to run efficiently most of the year. If your region drops below freezing often, that efficiency disappears fast and electric backup kicks in anyway.
Want to dig into the math? Check out this detailed comparison from the U.S. Department of Energy:
🔗 DOE: Heat Pumps vs. Electric Resistance Heating
🏢 Applications for Hotels, Apartments, and Rentals
-
Hotels: Heat pumps are more efficient for large-scale use if you’re in a mild region, but electric heat gives guests fast heat in cold climates.
-
Apartments: Heat pumps are great if your property has proper insulation and stays in a temperate zone.
-
Short-Term Rentals: Guests love quick, responsive heat—electric may be more practical.
You can read more about hospitality-focused PTAC solutions in this FacilitiesNet article on PTAC efficiency in hotels.
🧰 Final Thoughts from Tony
I’ve worked on more PTACs than I can count, and here’s my honest advice: choose your heat source based on your climate and usage needs. Don’t just grab the first model you see online. ❄️🔥
“Heat pumps are champs in the South, but when you're facing wind chills in Michigan, trust me—you’ll want electric coils backing you up.” – Tony the Trusted Tech
And if your old PTAC is barely hanging on, don’t wait for it to die in the middle of January. Get a reliable replacement today from The Furnace Outlet’s PTAC Heat Pump Collection. Whether you need electric, heat pump, or combo units, they’ve got the gear to keep your space comfortable year-round. 🧯
In the next topic you will read about: How to Install a PTAC Heat Pump the Right Way — Tony Walks You Through It
