When I started researching a new HVAC system for my 2,400 sq. ft. Colonial in New Jersey, I kept hearing the same debate:
Should you stick with a traditional gas furnace + central AC combo—or switch to a modern heat pump system?
In the Northeast, where we face humid summers and bitterly cold winters, the choice isn’t simple. Both systems have strong points, but the right one for you depends on your home, your budget, and your priorities.
After going through this decision myself, here’s what I learned.
🏠 Why This Decision Matters in the Northeast
Unlike homeowners in Florida or Texas, we Northeasterners don’t just care about summer cooling. We need serious heating power for 5–6 months out of the year.
-
Climate Zones 5 & 6 (covering most of the Northeast) require higher heating loads than milder regions
-
Our winters often dip below 20°F—and sometimes below zero.
-
Summers are hot and humid enough that we still need dependable air conditioning.
So when we’re comparing gas furnace + AC combos vs. heat pumps, the real question is:
👉 Which system keeps us comfortable year-round, at the best long-term cost?
🔥 Gas Furnace + AC Combo: Pros & Cons
This is the traditional setup most Northeast homes already have:
-
A gas furnace for heating.
-
A central AC unit (like a Goodman 4 Ton 13.5 SEER2) for cooling.
✅ Pros
-
Reliable heating in any weather → Furnaces don’t lose efficiency in freezing temps.
-
Strong, fast heat → Unlike heat pumps, gas furnaces deliver hot air quickly.
-
Lower upfront cost → A Goodman furnace + AC combo often costs $8,500–$13,500 installed
-
Long lifespan → Furnaces last 15–20 years, AC units around 12–15 years.
❌ Cons
-
Fossil fuel dependency → Requires natural gas, propane, or oil.
-
Efficiency limits → Even high-efficiency furnaces top out at 98% AFUE.
-
Fewer rebates → Federal credits rarely apply unless the AC is ≥15.2 SEER2.
-
Two separate systems → More components to install, maintain, and eventually replace.
❄️ Heat Pump Systems: Pros & Cons
Heat pumps have been gaining popularity, especially with the federal Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) offering strong incentives.
They work like an AC in summer, but in winter they reverse cycle to pull heat from outside air and bring it inside.
✅ Pros
-
One system for heating + cooling → Simpler setup, less equipment.
-
High efficiency → Many models offer 15.2–20+ SEER2 cooling and 8–10 HSPF2 heating.
-
Rebate eligible → Most qualify for federal tax credits + state rebates
-
Lower carbon footprint → Especially if paired with renewable electricity.
❌ Cons
-
Cold weather performance → Efficiency drops below 20°F. Some models need backup resistance heat or dual-fuel setups.
-
Higher upfront cost → Cold-climate heat pumps run $12,000–$18,000 installed
-
May require electrical upgrades → Panels may need higher amperage.
-
Shorter lifespan → Typically 12–15 years, since they run year-round.
⚡ Cost Comparison (2025 Estimates)
Here’s how the two stack up financially:
| System | Upfront Cost (Installed) | Annual Maintenance | Avg. Lifespan |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gas Furnace + AC | $8,500–$13,500 | $200–$400 | 15–20 yrs (furnace) / 12–15 yrs (AC) |
| Heat Pump (Cold-Climate) | $12,000–$18,000 | $200–$400 | 12–15 yrs |
👉 Furnaces + AC are cheaper upfront, but heat pumps can qualify for $1,000–$3,000 in rebates and save more on energy bills over time.
🌎 Rebates & Incentives
This is where the decision often tips.
Federal Tax Credits (IRA, 25C)
-
Central ACs: Must be ≥15.2 SEER2 to qualify (Goodman 13.5 SEER2 does NOT qualify)
-
Heat Pumps: Must be Energy Star certified (most cold-climate models are). Credit: 30% up to $2,000
State & Utility Programs
-
Massachusetts (Mass Save) → Rebates up to $10,000 for heat pumps
-
New Jersey Clean Energy → $500–$1,000 rebates for heat pumps; limited rebates for AC-only systems
-
Con Edison (NY) → Heat pump rebates up to $5,000; AC rebates require ≥15.2 SEER2.
👉 Bottom line: Heat pumps almost always qualify for more rebates than gas + AC systems.
🏠 Comfort & Performance in the Northeast
This was the deciding factor for me.
-
Gas Furnace + AC: Always delivers steady, powerful heat—even on the coldest January night.
-
Heat Pump: Modern cold-climate models (like Mitsubishi Hyper-Heat or Carrier Infinity) now work well down to -5°F. But in practice, most homeowners still use a backup heat source.
👉 Many homeowners choose a dual-fuel setup: a heat pump for most days, with a gas furnace kicking in below ~30°F. This balances rebates + comfort.
⚖️ Which Homeowners Should Choose What?
Here’s how I’d break it down for friends and neighbors:
🔥 Stick with Gas Furnace + AC if:
-
Your home already has natural gas.
-
You want the lowest upfront cost.
-
You prioritize reliable heat above all else.
-
You plan to stay put for less than 10 years.
❄️ Choose a Heat Pump if:
-
You want to maximize rebates and tax credits.
-
Your home doesn’t have natural gas service.
-
You value eco-friendly, all-electric heating.
-
You’re upgrading electrical service anyway.
📝 Samantha’s Advice
For my own home, I decided to stick with a Goodman 4 Ton 13.5 SEER2 + 100k BTU furnace combo.
Why?
-
I already had natural gas service.
-
I needed reliable heat in freezing temps.
-
Rebates on heat pumps wouldn’t have offset the much higher upfront cost for me.
But if I were building new—or planning to stay in my home for 20+ years—I’d seriously consider a cold-climate heat pump or dual-fuel hybrid system.
👉 The right choice isn’t the same for everyone. It depends on your climate, your budget, and how long you’ll be in your home.
✅ Samantha’s Takeaway
-
If you want affordable, reliable heat in the Northeast → A gas furnace + AC combo is still the best bet.
-
If you want rebates, efficiency, and eco-friendly heating → Go with a cold-climate heat pump (or hybrid).
For my family, gas + AC was the right call. But for yours? It might be time to embrace heat pump technology.
In the next topic we will know more about: Seasonal Maintenance for Your Goodman AC + Gas Furnace System
