Electric vs. Gas Furnaces: Why Tony Switched to Electric in 2025

🔥 Introduction: Tony’s 2025 Furnace Decision

Hey there — Tony here. I’ve spent over 30 years working around heating systems. I’ve repaired burners that sounded like jet engines, replaced cracked heat exchangers in the dead of winter, and tuned gas furnaces that had been running since the ‘80s.

For decades, gas was king — it was cheap, reliable, and powerful. But in 2025, something changed. Between rising gas prices, affordable renewable power, and new federal rebates, the economics flipped. When my own 15-year-old gas furnace finally called it quits, I made the switch to a 20 kW Goodman electric furnace — and I haven’t looked back.

This guide breaks down why I switched, what you should know before deciding, and how to figure out whether electric heating finally makes sense for your home.

---

⚡ 1. Understanding the Core Difference

At their core, both electric and gas furnaces serve the same purpose: they pull in cool air, heat it, and push it through your home’s ductwork. But how they do it couldn’t be more different.

🔧 Gas Furnace Basics

• Burns natural gas or propane in a combustion chamber.

• Produces heat, which warms a metal heat exchanger.

• A blower pushes air over the exchanger and into ducts.

• Requires a flue or vent to release combustion gases.

⚙️ Electric Furnace Basics

• Uses heating elements (like giant toasters).

• Electric current flows through metal coils, generating heat instantly.

• The blower moves warm air through ducts.

• No venting or combustion needed — just electricity.

That simplicity is the first thing that caught my attention. No burners to clean, no pilot lights to relight, no gas leaks to worry about — just clean, instant heat.

(Source: Energy.gov – Furnaces and Boilers)

---

💰 2. Cost Comparison: Installation & Operation

For most homeowners, the decision starts with money — both upfront and long-term.

When I got quotes in early 2025, local gas utilities had tacked on new infrastructure and carbon surcharges, making gas installation $1,200 more expensive than an equivalent electric unit.

On top of that, I didn’t need to vent through my basement wall — which saved labor and avoided drilling through old brick.

---

🧾 Real-World Operating Cost Example

Let’s break down operating costs with current U.S. averages:

• Electric rate: $0.13/kWh

• Gas rate: $1.25/therm

• Electric furnace efficiency: 100 %

• Gas furnace efficiency: 90 %

If you need 60,000 BTU/hour:

• Electric: 17.6 kWh × $0.13 = $2.29/hour

• Gas: 0.67 therms × $1.25 = $0.84/hour

So yes — electricity can cost more per hour, but that’s not the full story. My 2025 switch came with 2 key offsets:

1. My home’s solar array covers about 40 % of my winter use.

2. I received a $1,500 federal rebate for switching to electric (more on that later).

That balance tipped total annual costs nearly even — and I cut maintenance entirely.

(Sources: Energy.gov, HomeGuide.com)

---

🌎 3. Efficiency & Environmental Impact

When it comes to efficiency, electric wins every time — at least on paper.

• Electric Furnace: 100 % efficient at point of use. Every kilowatt-hour turns directly into heat.

• Gas Furnace: 80–96 % AFUE (Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency), losing some heat through exhaust gases.

But efficiency alone doesn’t tell the whole environmental story. It depends on where your electricity comes from.

In 2025, my state’s grid crossed 60 % renewable generation thanks to new solar and wind projects. That meant every kWh my furnace used had roughly half the emissions it would’ve had just five years earlier.

Gas combustion, on the other hand, always releases CO₂ and small amounts of nitrogen oxides (NOx) — no way around it.

Switching to electric immediately cut my household carbon footprint by about 1.8 metric tons per year, according to the EPA’s Greenhouse Gas Calculator.

---

🔋 4. Integration with Solar, Heat Pumps & Smart Homes

One of the best parts of going electric? The flexibility.

Unlike gas systems that exist in isolation, electric furnaces integrate easily with:

• Solar panels – Store daytime solar generation and heat your home for free.

• Heat pumps – Run efficient heating most of the time, using your furnace only as backup.

• Smart thermostats – Automatically manage when electric heat turns on, saving energy.

In my setup, I use a Goodman 20 kW electric furnace (MBVK20DP1X00) with a smart thermostat that prioritizes my rooftop solar. When I produce extra power, the system preheats the house slightly — effectively using “free” energy.

In 2025, electrification isn’t just a trend — it’s a system that talks to every other part of your home.

(Source: EnergyStar Smart Thermostat Guide)

---

⚙️ 5. Maintenance & Longevity

If you’ve ever maintained a gas furnace, you know it’s not “set it and forget it.”

🧰 Gas Maintenance Checklist

• Clean burners annually.

• Inspect pilot light and ignition systems.

• Check flue for cracks or corrosion.

• Test CO detectors regularly.

🔧 Electric Maintenance Checklist

• Replace filter every 1–3 months.

• Inspect heating elements annually.

• Check wiring connections.

That’s it.

No soot. No combustion chambers. No carbon monoxide detectors to replace.

Electric furnaces also tend to last longer because they don’t deal with corrosion from combustion byproducts. Mine is expected to last 25+ years.

---

💡 6. Safety & Indoor Air Quality

I’ve walked into homes where a cracked heat exchanger was leaking carbon monoxide — an invisible, deadly gas.

Electric furnaces eliminate that risk entirely. No combustion = no CO leaks, no exhaust flue, no open flame.

That means:

• Safer operation.

• Better indoor air quality.

• No backdrafting or flue condensation.

For families with kids, elderly parents, or respiratory issues, the difference is night and day.

(Source: CPSC Carbon Monoxide Safety Center)

---

🏡 7. The Electrification Push: Incentives & Rebates in 2025

Here’s where 2025 really changed the game.

Under the Inflation Reduction Act, homeowners can now access rebates and tax credits for installing high-efficiency electric heating equipment.

• Federal credit: Up to $2,000 for qualifying systems.

• Local utilities: Many offer $500–$1,500 for gas-to-electric conversions.

• Solar pairing: Add-on incentives for electric-ready homes.

In my case, I got:

• $1,500 rebate from my utility for retiring a gas furnace.

• $1,200 in state credits for upgrading my service panel to 200 amps.

That cut my total install cost by nearly 40 %.

Check your eligibility through the DSIRE Incentives Database or EnergyStar Rebate Finder.

---

⚖️ 8. When Gas Still Makes Sense

To be fair, electric heat isn’t perfect for everyone.

Gas may still make sense if:

• You live in an area with low gas prices and high electric rates.

• Your electrical panel can’t handle 20+ kW without costly upgrades.

• You face sub-zero winters where electric-only heat can struggle.

• Your home already has efficient ducted gas infrastructure.

But even then, hybrid systems — a heat pump + small electric furnace backup — are quickly taking over.

For most modern homes under 2,500 sq ft, all-electric setups are no longer an experiment — they’re the standard.

---

🔋 9. My 2025 Electric Furnace Setup

Here’s exactly what I installed in my own home:

• Model: Goodman MBVK20DP1X00 Electric Furnace + HKTAD201 Heat Kit

• Output: 68,240 BTU (20 kW)

• Airflow: 2,000 CFM

• Voltage: 240V single-phase

• Breaker: Two 60A circuits

• Duct connection: Reused from previous gas unit (no venting required)

It’s whisper-quiet, smooth, and has never once tripped a breaker — even during our coldest January nights.

Installation took less than a day. No gas line disconnection headaches, no venting permits, no combustion testing.

---

🧠 10. Lessons Learned from the Switch

1. Plan for your electrical panel early.
   If you’re on a 100A service, you’ll likely need an upgrade — but that’s future-proofing for EVs and induction cooking too.

2. Seal your ducts.
   Leaky ducts waste 20–30 % of your heating power. I sealed mine with mastic and saw instant improvements.

3. Use a smart thermostat.
   It learns your heating habits and shaves unnecessary runtime off your bill.

4. Take advantage of off-peak rates.
   Some utilities charge less at night — use preheating to lower costs further.

5. Don’t fear electric heat.
   Old stereotypes about slow, expensive electric furnaces don’t hold up in 2025. Modern systems are powerful, efficient, and quiet.

---

🧭 11. The Bottom Line: Why Tony Switched

Here’s my honest summary after a full heating season:

In my own words:

“After decades of working with gas, I finally realized electric isn’t the future — it’s the upgrade. It’s simpler, safer, and smarter for how homes are built and powered today.”

In the next topic we will know more about: Understanding kW and BTUs: How to Compare Furnace Power Ratings