Electric Heat vs. Heat Pump PTACs: Which Is Better for Your Space?

🌟 Introduction

When you’re shopping for a PTAC (Packaged Terminal Air Conditioner)—like the Amana Distinctions 9,200 BTU with 5 kW electric heat—one of the biggest decisions you’ll face is:

👉 Do I want electric resistance heat or a heat pump PTAC?

Both provide heating and cooling in one self-contained unit, but they work differently, have different costs, and perform better in different climates.

This guide will break down the pros, cons, and real-world costs of electric heat PTACs vs. heat pump PTACs so you can make the best choice for your home, apartment, or hotel.

---

⚡ Section 1: Why the Heating Option Matters

Many buyers focus on cooling capacity (BTUs) first. But here’s the reality:

• If you live somewhere with chilly winters, heating may cost you more than cooling.

• PTACs are unique because you can choose between electric resistance heat and heat pump heating.

• The wrong choice could mean higher utility bills or ineffective comfort.

👉 Savvy’s Note: Always match your PTAC’s heating type to your climate and usage pattern.

---

🔌 Section 2: How Electric Heat PTACs Work

⚙️ The Basics

Electric PTACs use resistance heating: electricity passes through coils, which heat up and warm the air (just like a toaster).

✅ Pros

• Works in all climates (no efficiency loss in cold).

• Simple and reliable—fewer parts that can fail.

• Quick heat output—warms up the room fast.

• Lower upfront cost—often $100–$200 cheaper than heat pump PTACs.

❌ Cons

• Energy-intensive: Uses 100% electricity to make heat.

• Higher utility bills—especially in cold regions.

• Not eco-friendly if electricity is coal-based.

💵 Real-World Costs

A 5 kW electric heater uses 5,000 watts (5 kW).

• Run 3 hrs/day × 30 days = 450 kWh/month.

• At $0.15/kWh (U.S. average), that’s $67.50/month (Energy.gov).

👉 Bottom line: Electric heat PTACs are reliable and strong but costly to run long-term.

---

♻️ Section 3: How Heat Pump PTACs Work

⚙️ The Basics

A heat pump PTAC works like an air conditioner in reverse:

• Instead of removing heat from your room, it pulls heat from the outside air and brings it indoors.

✅ Pros

• Much more energy-efficient (uses ~⅓ the electricity of resistance heat).

• Lower monthly bills—often saves 30–50% vs. electric PTACs.

• Eco-friendlier—uses less power overall.

❌ Cons

• Less effective in very cold climates (below ~35°F, efficiency drops).

• Higher upfront cost ($100–$200 more than electric-only models).

• More complex components—slightly higher repair risk.

💵 Real-World Costs

A heat pump delivering 5 kW of heat may only use ~1,500–2,000 watts.

• Run 3 hrs/day × 30 days = ~180 kWh/month.

• At $0.15/kWh, that’s $27/month.

👉 Bottom line: Heat pump PTACs are ideal for mild climates where winters don’t get bitter cold.

---

⚖️ Section 4: Cost Comparison

👉 Example: Over 10 years, a heat pump PTAC could save you $4,000+ in heating costs compared to electric resistance—if you live in a mild climate.

---

🌎 Section 5: Climate Considerations

❄️ Cold Climate (Northeast, Midwest)

• Heat pumps lose efficiency below ~35°F.

• Electric PTACs are more reliable for consistent heat.

☀️ Mild Climate (South, Coastal)

• Heat pumps thrive—efficient and cost-saving.

• Electric heat rarely needed, so resistance heating becomes a backup.

🌦️ Mixed Climate (Mid-Atlantic, Pacific Northwest)

• A dual system PTAC (heat pump + electric backup) is the best of both worlds.

👉 Savvy’s Note: Don’t choose based on price alone. Climate matters more than anything.

---

🏨 Section 6: Best Use Cases

🟠 Electric Heat PTACs

• Hotels in northern states – guests expect strong, reliable heat.

• Backup heat in offices – simple, no fuss.

• Regions with cheap electricity – cost impact is minimal.

🟢 Heat Pump PTACs

• Apartments in the South – where cooling dominates and mild winters save on heating costs.

• Coastal vacation rentals – efficient year-round operation.

• Eco-conscious homeowners – looking to cut carbon footprint.

🔵 Dual Heat PTACs (Hybrid)

• Great for mixed climates—uses heat pump first, switches to electric only when needed.

---

🛠️ Section 7: Maintenance & Longevity

• Electric PTACs: Easier to maintain (simple heating coil).

• Heat Pump PTACs: Require coil cleaning and refrigerant checks to maintain efficiency.

• Both: Need monthly filter cleaning and seasonal coil care 

👉 Savvy’s Tip: Heat pump PTACs are a little fussier, but the energy savings make it worth it in the right climate.

---

📝 Section 8: Savvy’s Final Word

So, which is better—electric heat or heat pump PTACs?

• Choose Electric Heat if:

  • You live in a cold climate with freezing winters.

  • You want simplicity and reliability.

  • Your electricity costs are low.

• Choose Heat Pump if:

  • You live in a mild climate where winters are short and not severe.

  • You want to save money long-term.

  • You’re eco-conscious and want to reduce electricity use.

👉 Best of Both: If available, a dual heat PTAC (heat pump + electric backup) gives you flexibility no matter where you live.

Savvy’s advice: Match your PTAC to your climate. It’s the smartest way to stay comfortable without wasting money.

---

🎨 Infographic Concept

Side-by-Side Comparison: Electric vs. Heat Pump PTACs

• Electric Heat (⚡)

  • Works in all climates

  • Simple, reliable

  • Higher bills (~$67/month)

• Heat Pump (♻️)

  • Energy-efficient

  • Saves 30–50% on bills (~$27/month)

  • Weaker in cold weather

👉 Bottom caption: “Best Choice Depends on Your Climate & Budget”

---

In the next topic we will know more about: Is 9,200 BTUs Enough? Sizing Tips for Your PTAC Unit