0 comments

Cost Breakdown (2025): Equipment, Install, Fuel Bills & Long-Term ROI

If you're trying to understand the real 2025 cost of replacing, installing, operating, and maintaining a high-efficiency furnace—especially a 96% Goodman—you don’t need fluff, charts with no meaning, or a salesman’s version of the truth. You need Money-Smart Jake to hand you the exact cost structure: equipment pricing, labor, venting, duct upgrades, fuel bills, 10-year operating cost projections, the ROI vs an old 80% furnace, Real performance, and the hidden costs most homeowners never see coming until they’re signing the invoice.

This is the full no-nonsense 2025 cost guide, built on realistic national averages, thousands of installs, and the real math behind heating fuel economics. If you want to know whether a 96% furnace actually saves money—or just “sounds nice”—this is the guide.

1. 2025 Furnace Equipment Costs (Realistic Ranges, Not Marketing Fiction)

These are real-world street prices, not wholesale contractor pricing and not MSRP fantasy numbers. These reflect what homeowners typically pay for equipment only, not installation.

Goodman / Amana / Daikin 96% Furnaces (2025 retail equipment pricing)

BTU Size	Typical Price (Equipment Only)	Notes
40k BTU	$1,250–$1,750	Small homes, condos
60k BTU	$1,350–$1,900	Most common size
80k BTU	$1,500–$2,150	Larger homes
100k+ BTU	$1,700–$2,500	Large homes / cold climates
Variable-speed premium models	$1,900–$3,000	GMVC/GCVM models

Goodman remains the most cost-efficient major brand in 2025, which is why it's the industry workhorse.

2. Full Cost Table: Equipment + Labor + Materials (2025)

This is the all-in price most homeowners care about—the total they pay out of pocket.

2025 Complete Installation Cost Breakdown (Real Averages)

Component	Cost Range	Notes
96% Furnace (equipment)	$1,350–$2,200	Depending on BTU & model
Labor (standard install)	$1,800–$3,000	Varies by region
PVC venting (materials)	$150–$500	Based on run length
Drain, trap, pump (if needed)	$60–$450	Pumps add cost
New thermostat (optional)	$80–$500	Basic → smart
Gas line modifications	$120–$650	Pressure test, resizing
Electrical modifications	$80–$500	Dedicated circuits, wiring
Duct repairs	$150–$2,500	Depends on condition
Permits	$50–$300	City/county dependent
Total installed cost	$3,700–$7,800	Most homeowners fall in this range

If your quote is over $8k, something unusual is going on: attic install, bad ductwork, long vent runs, or contractor markup.

If your quote is below $3,800, check for missing components—cheap installs often skip air testing, proper vent design, or code compliance.

3. Installation Scenario Comparisons: Attic vs Basement vs Closet (2025 Pricing)

Some homes are cheap to install in. Others make contractors swear under their breath.

Basement Install (Cheapest & Easiest)

Cost: $3,700–$6,000
Why cheaper:
- Easy access
- Short vent runs
- Adequate workspace
- No need for support platforms
Best-case scenario for affordability

Garage Install (Middle)

Cost: $4,200–$6,500
Might require:
- Elevated platform (per code)
- Sealed combustion requirements
- Earthquake straps in certain regions
- Upgraded vent terminations

Closet Install (Medium/High)

Cost: $4,500–$7,000
Needs:
- Compact models
- Upflow/downflow considerations
- Fresh air intake routing
- Condensate routing in cramped space
- Added fire safety clearances

Attic Install (Most Expensive)

Cost: $5,000–$8,800
Why expensive:
- Platform construction
- Large drip pan + float switch (mandatory)
- Insulated lines, venting long distances
- Extreme temperatures affect work time
- Hard to maneuver the equipment up there

Attics are the #1 cost inflator in 2025 HVAC installs.

Great general cost references:
HomeAdvisor_Furnace_Costs
Forbes_HVAC_Cost_Guide

4. Venting Material Cost Differences (96% Goodman Furnaces)

96% furnaces use PVC venting, typically Schedule 40. Prices vary.

2025 PVC Material Costs

Item	Price Range
2" Schedule 40 PVC	$9–$14 per 10 ft
3" Schedule 40 PVC	$14–$25 per 10 ft
Elbows, couplings, fittings	$2–$14 each
Termination kits	$25–$120
Furnace PVC adapters	$10–$40
Condensate neutralizer (optional)	$80–$250

Long vent runs (attics, multi-story homes) can add $200–$600 quickly.

PVC pricing trends:
PVC_Pipe_Pricing_2025

5. Duct Repair / Replacement Pricing (2025)

Bad ductwork is the silent cost inflator. Many homeowners think the furnace is dying when it's actually the ducts choking the system.

2025 Duct Pricing Snapshot

Repair Type	Cost Range	Notes
Minor sealing (mastic/tape)	$150–$500	Quick, high value
Return boot replacement	$120–$350	Common fix
Flex duct replacement (per run)	$180–$450	Depends on length
Sheet metal duct rebuild (per run)	$300–$800	Long-term solution
Entire system duct replacement	$3,500–$12,000	Big homes get expensive
Manual D redesign	$350–$1,200	Needed for poor systems

If your ducts can’t deliver 900–1200 CFM for a 60k furnace + AC combo, expect furnace short-cycling, noise, and poor efficiency.

Good ductwork education:
Ductwork_Guide

6. Gas vs Propane vs Electric Heating Costs (2025)

Heating costs in 2025 vary dramatically based on fuel type. Here are real averages across the U.S. for 2025.

Natural Gas Heating (Most Affordable)

Average U.S. price: $1.55 per therm
Efficiency with 96% furnace: ~$1.61 per 100,000 BTUs delivered
Annual cost for 2,000 sq ft home: $700–$1,500

Propane Heating

Average U.S. price: $2.60–$3.80 per gallon
Cost per 100,000 BTUs delivered (96% AFUE): ~$2.90–$4.30
Annual cost: $1,600–$3,200

Electric Resistance Heat

Average U.S. price: $0.16–$0.21 per kWh
Cost per 100,000 BTU: ~$4.60–$6.00
Annual cost: $2,400–$4,500

Heat Pumps (for comparison)

COP-based efficiency makes them cheaper unless temps drop below 25°F
Annual cost: $800–$1,900, depending on climate

Energy price references:
EIA_Fuel_Costs_2025

7. 10-Year Operating Cost Chart (Gas, Propane, Electric)

Assuming average climate and a typical 2,000 sq ft home.

10-Year Projected Cost

Heating Type	Avg Annual Cost	10-Year Cost	Notes
Natural Gas (96%)	$1,100	$11,000	Lowest cost
Natural Gas (80%)	$1,320	$13,200	$2,200 MORE than 96%
Propane (96%)	$2,300	$23,000	Expensive fuel
Electric Resistance	$3,400	$34,000	Worst cost
Heat Pump	$1,350	$13,500	Moderate
Oil (for comparison)	$2,600	$26,000	Volatile cost

This is why 96% furnaces dominate in gas-heated regions—they're the cheapest and most predictable over time.

Good comparison reference:
Heat_Cost_Comparison

8. ROI: Replacing an Old 80% Furnace with a 96% Gas Furnace

Here is where Money-Smart Jake gets blunt:
Switching from 80% to 96% almost always pays for itself.

Let’s look at actual ROI math.

Example Home

Heating load: 800 therms of delivered heat
Gas price: $1.55/therm

Annual Fuel Use

80% furnace: 800 ÷ 0.80 = 1,000 therms
96% furnace: 800 ÷ 0.96 = 833 therms

Annual Savings

167 therms × $1.55 ≈ $258/year

Add ECM blower electricity savings (~$40/year):
Total ≈ $300/year

Upgrade Cost Difference

80% install: ~$3,500
96% install: ~$4,500
Upgrade premium: $1,000

Payback

$1,000 ÷ $300/year = 3.3 years

10-Year Return

10 × $300 = $3,000 gained
Minus $1,000 premium = $2,000 net positive

20-Year Return

20 × $300 = $6,000 gained

ROI FAQs:
AFUE_Savings_Calculator

9. Hidden Costs Most Homeowners Don't See Coming (2025)

Here’s where most budgets explode.

✔ Permits

$50–$300
Required in almost every jurisdiction
Inspections are mandatory for venting, gas lines, and electrical systems

✔ Electrical Upgrades

The furnace may require a new dedicated 15A/20A circuit
Panel work ranges from $80 (simple) to $900 (panel changes)

✔ Gas Line Upgrades

New flex connector: $40–$80
Gas resizing: $150–$450
Pressure testing: $80–$200

✔ Venting Redesign

If your old 80% furnace vented into a chimney, you now need PVC sidewall venting
Cost: $150–$600
Chimney liner required for water heater: $400–$1,200 (big surprise cost)