0 comments

Common Heat Pump Problems — and Why They’re Almost Always Avoidable

Introduction — Tony Here: Let’s Talk About Why Heat Pumps Break (And How to Stop It)

I’ve been working with heat pumps for over two decades. And if there’s one thing I can tell you with 100% confidence, it’s this:

Most heat pump problems are preventable.

Not random.
Not mysterious.
Not “just what happens with HVAC.”

No — most failures are caused by simple maintenance issues, airflow problems, installation shortcuts, or homeowners not knowing what’s normal vs. what’s trouble.

And here’s the good news:

Your Goodman 2-ton heat pump can run smooth for 15–20 years if you avoid the big mistakes.

In this guide, we’ll cover:

The most common issues I see in homes
Why they happen
What’s normal vs. not
What you can prevent yourself
What a tech needs to handle
How to keep tiny problems from becoming big bills

Let’s break this down Tony-style — blunt, practical, and proven.

1. Understanding the Root Cause: 90% of Heat Pump Problems Start With Airflow

If air can’t flow, nothing works.

Poor airflow causes:

Icing
Overheating
Weak heating/cooling
High energy bills
Compressor strain
Early failure

This is the #1 cause of heat pump problems — and it’s almost always due to:

Dirty filters
Dirty coils
Blocked vents
Closed registers
Leaky ducts

👉 DOE – Why Airflow Matters for Heat Pump Performance

Before you blame the heat pump, blame the airflow.
It’s usually the real culprit.

2. Frozen Outdoor Coils — The Most Common Winter Complaint

Every winter, I get the same call:

“My heat pump is covered in ice — is it broken?”

Short answer:
Probably not.

Frost is normal. Ice is normal.
A thin layer is part of normal winter operation.

The problem is when ice becomes:

Thick
Solid
Wrapped around the coil
Covering the whole unit
Blocking the fan

This usually means:

Poor defrost cycle
Blocked airflow
Drainage issues
A failing sensor
Low refrigerant

👉 Heat Pump Winter Frost & Defrost Guide

Almost always avoidable with proper maintenance.

3. Weak Heating or Cooling — Usually an Easy Fix

If your Goodman isn’t heating or cooling well, the cause is usually simple:

❌ Dirty filter

Kills airflow instantly.

❌ Dirty indoor coil

Reduces heat absorption.

❌ Dirty outdoor coil

Reduces heat release.

❌ Low refrigerant

Causes weak performance and icing.

❌ Leaky ducts

You’re losing 20–40% of air.

❌ Wrong thermostat settings

Especially in winter.

👉 ENERGY STAR – HVAC Performance Troubleshooting Basics

Good news?
Most of these are fixable in 10 minutes.

4. Short Cycling — When the System Turns On and Off Rapidly

Short cycling is the silent killer of heat pumps.
It:

Destroys compressors
Wrecks efficiency
Raises electric bills
Makes your home uncomfortable

Common causes:

Oversized system
Dirty coil
Thermostat placement issues
Low refrigerant
Bad airflow

👉 HVAC Short Cycling Causes & Fix Guide

If you catch this early, you can save your compressor.
Ignore it, and you’re buying a new outdoor unit.

5. Loud or Strange Noises — When to Worry (And When Not To)

Some sounds are normal.
Some mean it’s time to call a tech NOW.

Normal Noises

Defrost cycle “whoosh”
Low compressor hum
Fan ramping up or down

Problem Noises

Grinding → motor or bearing issue
Screeching → blower or fan failure
Rattling → loose panels or failing fan blade
Buzzing → electrical issue
Whistling → duct leaks

👉 Homeowner Heat Pump Noise Diagnosis Guide

Goodman systems are known for reliable operation, so unusual noises are always worth checking.

6. Rising Energy Bills — Often a Warning Sign of Early Failure

If your electric bill jumps suddenly, your heat pump is telling you something.

Common causes:

Dirty coil
Wrong thermostat settings
Low refrigerant
Bad sensor
Sticking reversing valve
Faulty or constant backup heat

Backup heat running all the time?
That’s a red flag.

👉 Energy Efficiency Troubleshooting for Heat Pumps

The sooner you investigate, the cheaper the fix.

7. Thermostat Problems — A Tiny Device That Causes Huge Issues

Your thermostat controls the entire system — and small issues can cause big headaches.

Common thermostat problems:

Wrong heat mode (heat vs. EM heat)
Incorrect wiring
Poor location (sunlight, vents, appliances)
Low batteries
Wrong settings for heat pumps

In winter, ALWAYS run in heat, never emergency heat, unless a tech instructs you.

A thermostat misconfiguration can double your energy bill.

8. Refrigerant Leaks — The Most Common Professional Repair

Refrigerant doesn’t “run out.”
If it’s low, it’s leaking.

Symptoms:

Weak heating/cooling
Icing on the indoor coil
Icing on the outdoor unit
Higher energy usage
Long run times

A tech will:

Pressure test
Locate leak
Repair or replace the line/coil
Recharge to spec

Catching leaks early saves compressors from overheating and failing.

9. Drainage & Moisture Problems — Silent and Often Noticed Too Late

Your air handler produces water while cooling — lots of it.

If drainage fails, you can get:

Water damage
Mold growth
Float switch shutdowns
Indoor humidity issues
Rust inside the unit

Prevent it by:

Cleaning the drain line
Checking the trap
Ensuring proper slope
Adding a float switch
Avoiding algae buildup

Most drain issues cost $0 to prevent and $400–$1,200 to repair after the damage.

10. Tony’s Final Take (Bottom Line)

Here’s the truth nobody tells homeowners:

Heat pumps almost never fail because of the equipment.
They fail because of neglect.

Goodman builds reliable, long-lasting systems. But even the best unit needs:

✔ Clean airflow
✔ Clean coils
✔ Proper refrigerant levels
✔ Clear outdoor space
✔ A working thermostat
✔ Regular maintenance
✔ A good installer
✔ Early detection of small issues

Do these right, and your 2-ton Goodman will: