The Truth About Furnace Filters: When to Change, Which MERV Rating, & Why It Matters

If your furnace had a “most underrated part,” the air filter would win every time.

I’ve talked to countless homeowners who spent good money on a high-efficiency furnace—only to unknowingly sabotage it with the wrong filter or a filter that hadn’t been changed in months. The furnace wasn’t broken. It was choking.

80,000 BTU 96% AFUE Upflow/Horizontal Two Stage Goodman Gas Furnace - GR9T960804CN

Let’s clear the air (literally).

This guide breaks down what furnace filters actually do, how often to change them, how to choose the right MERV rating, and why your filter choice directly affects comfort, efficiency, and furnace lifespan.

---

🔥 Why Furnace Filters Matter More Than You Think

Your furnace filter doesn’t just “clean air.” It plays three critical roles:

• 🌬️ Protects airflow through the system

• 🛠️ Guards internal components (blower motor, heat exchanger)

• 🏠 Improves indoor air quality

In high-efficiency furnaces like a 96% AFUE Goodman, airflow precision matters. Even small restrictions can cause:

• Longer run times

• Reduced comfort

• Higher energy bills

• Premature wear on expensive parts

👉 According to Energy.gov, dirty filters are one of the most common causes of HVAC inefficiency:
https://www.energy.gov/energysaver/home-heating-systems

---

🧪 What Furnace Filters Actually Do (And What They Don’t)

Let’s bust a common myth:

❌ “The higher the MERV rating, the better for every furnace.”

Not true.

✔️ What Filters Do Well

• Capture dust, pollen, pet dander

• Protect the blower motor from debris

• Keep coils and heat exchangers cleaner

❌ What Filters Don’t Do

• Replace proper duct sealing

• Fix humidity problems

• Remove all viruses or odors (without special systems)

Your filter is a gatekeeper, not a cure-all.

---

⏱️ When Should You Change Your Furnace Filter?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer—but there is a smart range.

🗓️ General Rule of Thumb

• Every 1–3 months for most homes

🔄 Change Filters More Often If You Have:

• Pets

• Allergies or asthma

• Construction dust nearby

• A constantly running system

• Thicker pleated filters

🏡 Homes That Can Go Longer

• No pets

• Minimal occupancy

• Cleaner outdoor air

• Shorter heating seasons

Samantha tip:
If you can’t remember the last time you changed it, it’s time.

👉 Filter replacement guidance from This Old House

---

🧠 Understanding MERV Ratings (Without the Confusion)

MERV stands for Minimum Efficiency Reporting Value. It measures how well a filter captures particles.

Here’s the part most homeowners miss:
Higher MERV = higher resistance to airflow.

---

📊 MERV Ratings Explained Simply

---

✅ Best MERV Rating for a Goodman 96% Furnace

MERV 8–11 is the sweet spot for most homeowners.

Why?

• Strong particle capture

• Minimal airflow restriction

• Protects efficiency and staging

👉 EPA guidance on indoor air filtration:
https://www.epa.gov/indoor-air-quality-iaq

---

🚫 The Hidden Risks of Using Too High a MERV Filter

I see this mistake all the time—especially with allergy-conscious homeowners.

⚠️ Problems Caused by Over-Restrictive Filters

• Reduced airflow

• Furnace overheating

• Limit switch shutdowns

• Blower motor strain

• Shorter system lifespan

High-efficiency furnaces are smart, but they can’t overcome bad airflow forever.

👉 Airflow restriction explained by HVAC.com:
https://www.hvac.com/expert-advice/common-hvac-problems/

---

📐 Filter Thickness: Does It Matter?

Yes—and more than people realize.

📏 Common Filter Sizes

• 1-inch (most common)

• 2–4 inches (media filters)

🔍 Thicker Filters = Better If Designed For Them

A 4-inch filter:

• Has more surface area

• Restricts airflow less when properly sized

• Lasts longer (up to 6 months)

But forcing a thick filter into a system not designed for it? That’s a no-go.

---

🔄 How to Change Your Furnace Filter the Right Way

This takes 5 minutes—and can save you hundreds.

✅ Step-by-Step

1. Turn the furnace off

2. Remove the old filter

3. Check airflow arrow (points toward furnace)

4. Insert new filter snugly

5. Restore power

Samantha tip:
Write the install date on the filter frame with a marker.

---

🧾 Filter Costs vs. Long-Term Savings

Let’s talk money.

💵 Cheap Filter vs. Smart Filter

• Cheap filter: saves $5 today

• Restricted airflow: costs $200 later

A quality MERV 8–11 filter:

• Protects efficiency

• Reduces service calls

• Extends furnace life

👉 According to Family Handyman, filter neglect is a leading cause of HVAC service calls:

https://www.familyhandyman.com/project/how-to-change-a-dirty-furnace-filter/

---

⚖️ Furnace Filters vs. Whole-Home Air Quality Systems

If allergies are a concern, filters aren’t your only option.

🌀 Better Pairings

• Standard MERV 8–11 filter

• • UV light

• • Whole-home air purifier

This keeps airflow healthy and air clean.

---

🏁 Final Thoughts: Small Filter, Big Impact

Your furnace filter is a quiet hero—or a silent saboteur.

Change it regularly.
Choose the right MERV rating.
Respect airflow.

Do that, and your Goodman 96% furnace will reward you with:

• Better comfort

• Lower bills

• Fewer repairs

• Longer lifespan