📘 Table of Contents
🏠 Deciding Between Goodman & Amana
Choosing a heat pump brand isn't easy. Homeowners often find themselves comparing two well-known names: Goodman and Amana. Both owned by Daikin, each brand has distinct strengths, warranties, efficiency ratings, and price points.
This guide covers everything you need to know to make the right choice between these two respected HVAC brands.
🔍 Brand Overview: Goodman
Founded in 1982, Goodman quickly became popular for affordable, reliable heating and cooling solutions. Their heat pumps, like the Goodman 3 Ton 17.2 SEER2 2-Stage Heat Pump, are known for:
-
Budget-friendly pricing
-
Easy serviceability
-
Extensive parts availability
-
Solid performance and reliability
Goodman’s parent company, Daikin, ensures solid manufacturing quality and technological advancements, with manufacturing plants located in the U.S..
🔍 Brand Overview: Amana
Amana, established in 1934, has a reputation built around premium quality and durability. Known for its distinct PTAC heat pumps like the Amana Distinctions 9,000 BTU PTAC Heat Pump, the brand is popular for:
-
Higher-end product positioning
-
Exceptional warranties (lifetime options)
-
Quiet, energy-efficient operation
-
Reliable performance in extreme conditions
Like Goodman, Amana also benefits from Daikin’s global technology and manufacturing expertise.
📈 Efficiency and Performance
Efficiency ratings (SEER2, HSPF2) directly impact your monthly energy bills:
|
Brand & Model |
SEER2 Rating |
HSPF2 Rating |
Ideal for |
|
Goodman GSZC703610 |
17.2 |
9.6 |
Balanced value/efficiency |
|
Amana PTAC DHP093J25BA |
11.2 |
3.4 |
Hotels, apartments, smaller spaces |
For residential homes, Goodman often provides better overall efficiency ratings at lower prices. Amana PTAC units excel for individual rooms, condos, hotels, and specialized setups requiring zone control.
The Department of Energy notes that higher SEER ratings significantly cut cooling bills, a strong point for Goodman’s central systems.
🛡️ Warranty Comparison
Warranty coverage varies significantly:
-
Goodman: Typically 10-year limited parts warranty (requires timely registration). Select units offer lifetime compressor coverage (Goodman Warranty Info).
-
Amana: Offers similar standard 10-year parts warranties, but often goes further with lifetime compressor replacement on premium models, particularly on select units (Amana Warranty Details).
Amana's comprehensive warranty is appealing for homeowners prioritizing long-term peace of mind.
💸 Cost and Value
Goodman typically offers:
-
Lower upfront cost
-
Good value for mid-range buyers
-
Ideal for cost-conscious homeowners
Amana typically offers:
-
Higher initial investment
-
Enhanced features, quieter operation
-
Superior long-term value due to extended warranty and durable build quality
For budget-friendly efficiency, Goodman usually wins. For premium features and longevity, Amana may justify its higher initial costs.
🛠️ Installation & Maintenance Considerations
Installation complexity and maintenance needs differ slightly:
-
Goodman heat pumps are installer-friendly, with readily available replacement parts nationwide.
-
Amana PTAC units are straightforward to install in hotel rooms or apartments, requiring less complex ductwork setup. However, specialized replacements may sometimes be necessary.
Both brands recommend annual professional tune-ups to maintain efficiency and comply with warranty conditions. The North American Technician Excellence (NATE) directory helps homeowners find qualified HVAC contractors.
🏁 Which Brand Should You Choose?
Goodman delivers affordable, reliable whole-home heating and cooling with decent efficiency and broad serviceability.
Amana brings premium features, lifetime warranties, and tailored solutions for smaller zones or retrofit installations.
Which should you pick? If you're budget-savvy and want a solid whole-home system, go Goodman. If you're designing for apartments, condos, or want the quietest, most reliable option with long-term coverage, Amana is worth the investment.
Explore our heat pump offerings to compare models:
This article is the main guide in our Goodman vs. Amana Heat Pump Series. To get the full picture, explore the following focused articles:
❓ FAQ
Q: What is the difference between Goodman and Amana heat pump warranties?
A: Both offer a standard 10‑year parts warranty, but Amana adds a lifetime compressor and unit‑replace clause. So Amana’s coverage is more comprehensive if registered promptly.
Q: Are Goodman heat pumps reliable?
A: Yes, Goodman heat pumps are known to provide reliable performance over 15–18 years, especially when installed by certified professionals and maintained routinely.
Q: Which brand is more energy-efficient?
A: Goodman typically provides higher SEER ratings for residential central systems, whereas Amana excels in specific zone-controlled setups.
Q: How much do Goodman and Amana heat pumps cost to install?
A: Typical installed cost ranges from $4,500–$7,000 for Goodman, and $5,500–$9,000 for Amana, varying with efficiency level and labor rates in your region.
Q: Do Amana heat pumps hold their value better?
A: Yes, Amana heat pumps tend to retain resale value more effectively due to their premium build quality and warranty coverage.
