Through-the-Wall vs. Window AC: Why Samantha Chose a Wall Unit for Her Living Room

🏡 1. My Cooling Dilemma: A Real-Life Decision

I’ve lived in my home for over a decade, and for the first few summers I relied on a trusty window air conditioner in the living room. It was simple, affordable, and it got the job done—until it didn’t.

Over time, I noticed a few things:

• My electricity bills were climbing every summer.

• The noise was starting to drive me nuts.

• My living room felt darker with a big box blocking half the window.

• On stormy days, I could feel little drafts around the unit.

Last year, I decided it was time to upgrade. My choices boiled down to: stick with a window unit or invest in a through-the-wall AC. Here’s everything I learned while making my decision—and why the wall unit ultimately won my heart.

Best 12,000 BTU Through The Wall AC

---

🏠 2. The Basics: Window AC vs. Through-the-Wall AC

Before we get into my decision, let’s make sure we’re on the same page about how these units differ.

Window Air Conditioner

• Where it sits: In a window opening, secured with brackets or side panels.

• Cooling style: Vents warm air outside while cooling inside air.

• Pros: Lower upfront cost, no wall modifications, easy to install or remove seasonally.

• Cons: Blocks natural light, may not seal perfectly, can be noisier, and can make a home less secure.

Through-the-Wall Air Conditioner

• Where it sits: Permanently installed in a hole cut into an exterior wall, inside a metal or plastic wall sleeve.

• Cooling style: Works like a window unit but is sealed into the wall for better insulation and noise control.

• Pros: Keeps windows clear, often more efficient, quieter, and more secure.

• Cons: Higher installation cost, requires cutting a wall (DIY or pro).

📖 More details on the differences from the U.S. Department of Energy’s room AC guide.

---

📏 3. Cooling Performance & Room Size Matters

When deciding between the two, the size of your space plays a huge role.

Window ACs

These are excellent for small to medium rooms (150–350 sq ft) and are available in a wide range of BTUs, from tiny 5,000 BTU models up to around 25,000 BTU.

Through-the-Wall ACs

They shine in larger rooms—like my 500 sq ft living room—because they can handle higher BTU ratings without overwhelming the space visually or structurally.

Why it mattered for me:
My living room is open to the dining area, which means I needed at least 12,000 BTUs to keep things comfortable in summer. That’s a sweet spot for through-the-wall models.

You can use the ENERGY STAR Room AC Sizing Guide to find your own ideal BTU rating.

---

⚡ 4. Energy Efficiency: EER, CEER & Insulation

Energy efficiency was a huge deciding factor for me. I wanted to keep cool without feeling guilty every time the electric bill arrived.

EER (Energy Efficiency Ratio)

• Formula: BTU cooling capacity ÷ power input (watts)

• Higher EER = better efficiency

CEER (Combined Energy Efficiency Ratio)

• Includes EER plus standby power usage.

• More realistic for actual day-to-day performance.

Window vs. Wall

• Window units: Can be efficient, but often lose points due to air leaks around the frame.

• Through-the-wall units: Generally have tighter seals and better insulation, which means less cooled air escapes.

I chose an ENERGY STAR–certified wall unit with a CEER of 10.5. It’s not just a sticker—ENERGY STAR products meet strict EPA efficiency standards (full criteria here).

---

🔇 5. Noise Levels: The Sound of Comfort

My old window AC had one setting: loud. Whether I was watching TV, on a call, or just trying to relax with a book, the constant hum and occasional rattle were always there.

Through-the-wall units tend to be quieter for two reasons:

1. They’re mounted in a fixed sleeve that absorbs vibration.

2. The wall itself acts as a noise barrier.

Now, I can watch a movie without turning the volume up to 25.

---

🔒 6. Security & Weather Protection

This was another big factor for me.

Window ACs:

• Can be pushed in or removed from outside if not secured with special brackets or locks.

• Let in more drafts and moisture during storms.

Through-the-Wall ACs:

• Installed permanently inside a sleeve and surrounded by insulation.

• Much harder for anyone to tamper with from outside.

• Better protection from wind, rain, and snow.

Consumer Reports has a good safety guide for window ACs—worth reading if you go that route.

---

🪟 7. Aesthetics: Keeping My View & My Light

I love natural light. With a window AC, half my living room window was blocked by a bulky appliance, making the room feel smaller and darker.

A through-the-wall unit:

• Keeps every bit of window space open.

• Looks more like a built-in appliance than a temporary fixture.

• Allows for year-round installation without seasonal shuffling.

And yes, I can finally open the blinds and enjoy my garden view.

---

💵 8. Installation & Cost Breakdown

Window AC

• Unit: $200–$700 (12,000 BTU range)

• Installation: DIY-friendly, no wall work

• Seasonal removal & storage required

Through-the-Wall AC

• Unit: $500–$1,200 (12,000 BTU range)

• Wall sleeve: $50–$150

• Installation: $300–$700 (pro), less if DIY

• One-time install, stays put year-round

While the wall unit cost me more upfront, the long-term savings in energy and convenience make it worthwhile.
AC installation cost guide can give you location-specific pricing.

---

📊 9. Side-by-Side Comparison Table

---

📝 10. Why I Ultimately Chose the Wall Unit

Here’s my personal checklist of why I went with a through-the-wall AC:

• BTU match for my open-plan living room

• Year-round readiness—no hauling in and out every season

• Lower noise levels for daily comfort

• Improved security over a window unit

• Unobstructed light and view from my favorite window

• Better sealing and insulation for efficiency

Now, every time I walk into my living room on a hot July afternoon, I get that crisp, cool air without the hum, draft, or blocked sunlight. Worth every penny.

---

Final Thought:
If your living room is the heart of your home and you’re tired of seasonal installs, blocked views, and higher bills, a through-the-wall AC could be a game-changer—just like it was for me.

In the next topic we will read about: DIY vs. Professional Installation for a 12,000 BTU Through-the-Wall AC