Share your love

Dual-Fuel Balance Point: How to Set Heat Pump & Auxiliary Heat Lockouts for Lower Bills

By Jake Lawson | HVAC Specialist | The Furnace Outlet

A dual-fuel heating system can offer homeowners an excellent combination of energy efficiency, dependable winter comfort, and flexibility when outdoor temperatures fall. By combining an electric heat pump with a gas or propane furnace, the system can use whichever heating source makes the most sense under the conditions.

But there’s a catch. Simply installing a heat pump and furnace together doesn’t guarantee lower heating bills. The controls must know when to run the heat pump, when to switch to the furnace, and when one heating source should be prevented from operating. That’s where the dual-fuel balance point and heat pump lockout settings become important. I’ve encountered dual-fuel installations where the equipment itself was excellent, but the thermostat settings caused the furnace to take over much earlier than necessary. I’ve also seen systems configured to keep the heat pump operating at temperatures where its heating output couldn’t keep up with the house, resulting in uncomfortable rooms and unnecessary operating costs.

Neither approach is ideal. The goal is to identify the temperature at which switching heating sources makes economic or operational sense, then configure the controls accordingly. For some homes, the heat pump will remain the least expensive heating option well below freezing. For others, particularly those using expensive electricity and relatively inexpensive natural gas, the furnace may become more economical at a higher outdoor temperature.

There is no universal 30°F, 35°F, or 40°F switchover setting that works for every dual-fuel installation. In this guide, I’ll explain how thermal and economic balance points differ, how heat pump and auxiliary heat lockouts work, how to compare heating costs, and how to choose settings that improve comfort without wasting money.

What Is the Dual-Fuel Balance Point?

The term balance point is often used to describe the outdoor temperature at which a heat pump should stop heating the house and another heating source should take over. However, there are actually two important balance points, and confusing them can lead to poor thermostat settings. The first is the thermal balance point. This is the outdoor temperature at which the heat pump’s available heating capacity approximately equals the home’s heating requirement.

Above this temperature, the heat pump may be capable of maintaining the indoor setpoint without assistance. Below it, the home’s heat loss may exceed the heat pump’s available output, requiring supplemental heating or a different heat source. The second is the economic balance point. This is the outdoor temperature at which the operating cost of heat supplied by the heat pump equals the operating cost of heat supplied by the furnace. These two temperatures are not necessarily the same.

A heat pump may be physically capable of heating a home at 15°F but become more expensive to operate than the gas furnace at 30°F. In another home, the heat pump may remain less expensive than the furnace at nearly every temperature where it can meet the heating load. Understanding this distinction is the foundation of effective dual-fuel control.

How a Dual-Fuel Heat Pump System Works

A conventional dual-fuel system combines an electric heat pump with a compatible fossil-fuel furnace, usually powered by natural gas or propane. During milder weather, the heat pump transfers heat from outdoor air into the home. Because it moves heat rather than generating all of it through electrical resistance, it can deliver more heat energy than the electrical energy it consumes. As outdoor temperatures fall, the heat pump’s efficiency and available heating capacity generally change. The exact behavior depends on the equipment, compressor technology, defrost requirements, and outdoor conditions.

The furnace provides another source of heat when the heat pump becomes unable to meet the load, is restricted by manufacturer operating limits, or becomes more expensive to operate. In many conventional dual-fuel systems, the heat pump and furnace are designed to operate as alternative heating sources rather than simultaneously. The thermostat or equipment control coordinates the changeover. This differs from an all-electric heat pump system with electric resistance backup, where the heat pump and supplemental electric heat may be allowed to operate together. That distinction is important because the meaning of auxiliary heat lockout depends on the system configuration.

Thermal Balance Point vs. Economic Balance Point

The thermal balance point is primarily about heating capacity and comfort. Imagine a house that needs 30,000 BTU per hour to maintain its indoor temperature during a particular winter condition. If the heat pump can deliver 32,000 BTU per hour at that outdoor temperature, it may be capable of meeting the load independently. If the temperature falls and the house now requires 38,000 BTU per hour while the heat pump can deliver only 29,000 BTU per hour, the heat pump cannot maintain the desired indoor temperature on its own.

That indicates a capacity shortfall, regardless of whether the heat pump is inexpensive to operate. The economic balance point, by contrast, compares the cost of delivering the same amount of useful heat from two different energy sources. A heat pump may have a coefficient of performance, or COP, of 3.0 under one operating condition and 2.0 under another. The higher the COP, the more useful heat it delivers per unit of electricity consumed.

The furnace’s operating cost depends on its fuel price and thermal efficiency, often represented by its AFUE rating. A 96% AFUE gas furnace converts approximately 96% of the fuel’s rated energy into useful heat under the standardized conditions represented by that rating. The best economic switchover point is where the relative cost of these two heating methods changes, provided both systems can safely and adequately heat the home.

What Is a Heat Pump Lockout Temperature?

A heat pump lockout temperature is an outdoor temperature threshold below which the controls prevent the heat pump from operating in heating mode. For example, if the heat pump lockout is set to 25°F, the control system may prevent heat pump heating below that threshold and use the alternate heating source instead. The exact switching behavior depends on the thermostat, control board, equipment configuration, sensor readings, and any programmed time delays or temperature differentials.

A heat pump lockout is not necessarily the same as the manufacturer’s minimum operating temperature. Many modern cold-climate heat pumps can operate well below freezing, while other equipment has more limited low-temperature performance. A lockout setting should therefore be based on the heat pump’s published heating capacity, efficiency, operating limits, the home’s heat loss, and the economics of the alternate fuel.

Setting the lockout unnecessarily high can waste money by forcing the furnace to run when the heat pump could have provided economical heating. Setting it too low may cause comfort problems if the heat pump cannot meet the building’s heating demand.

What Is an Auxiliary Heat Lockout Temperature?

An auxiliary heat lockout prevents the backup heating source from operating above a selected outdoor temperature, subject to the system’s control logic and safety requirements. For example, an auxiliary heat lockout set at 40°F may prevent routine supplemental heating above that outdoor temperature because the heat pump is expected to handle the load independently. This setting can help avoid unnecessary backup heating during mild weather.

However, auxiliary heat lockout terminology is not used identically across all thermostats and HVAC systems. On an all-electric heat pump with resistance backup, the auxiliary heat lockout typically restricts electric strip heating above the selected temperature. On a dual-fuel system, the control may instead use a fossil-fuel changeover threshold, compressor lockout, equipment staging logic, or another manufacturer-specific setting. Emergency heat operation and equipment-protection functions may also follow different rules. Before adjusting these controls, identify whether the system uses electric resistance auxiliary heat, a fossil-fuel furnace, or a combination of both.

Example: When Is the Heat Pump Cheaper Than Gas?

Imagine a homeowner paying $0.16 per kWh for electricity and $1.50 per therm for natural gas. The home has a 96% AFUE furnace and a heat pump whose COP changes as outdoor temperatures fall. At a COP of 3.0, the heat pump’s approximate heating cost is $15.63 per million BTU delivered. The gas furnace costs approximately $15.63 for the same useful heating output. That means the two heating sources are essentially equal in operating cost under those assumptions.

If the heat pump operates at a COP of 3.5 during milder weather, its heating cost falls to approximately $13.40 per million BTU. In that condition, the heat pump is cheaper. If colder weather reduces its COP to 2.0, the cost increases to approximately $23.45 per million BTU. The gas furnace would then be substantially less expensive. The important conclusion is that the economic switchover temperature depends on where the heat pump’s actual COP crosses the break-even value. It cannot be determined from outdoor temperature alone.

Finding Your Break-Even COP

Instead of guessing a switchover temperature, homeowners can calculate the minimum COP the heat pump must achieve to compete economically with the furnace. Using the earlier example of $0.16 per kWh, $1.50 per therm, and a 96% AFUE furnace, the break-even COP is approximately 3.0.

If the heat pump’s actual COP is higher than 3.0, it is generally the less expensive heating source. If the COP falls below 3.0, the gas furnace becomes less expensive under those energy prices. The next step is to consult the heat pump manufacturer’s extended performance data. These tables may show heating capacity and electrical input at several outdoor temperatures. A contractor can use this information to estimate COP across the operating range and identify the outdoor temperature where the economic crossover occurs.

This approach is considerably more dependable than using a generic switchover temperature recommended for an entirely different home.

What Changes When Your Backup Furnace Uses Propane?

Propane changes the economics because its energy content and price structure differ from natural gas. One gallon of propane contains approximately 91,500 BTU of energy. The useful heating output depends on furnace efficiency. Suppose propane costs $3.00 per gallon and the furnace operates at 95% AFUE. The approximate cost of useful heat is $34.51 per million BTU.

Under the earlier electricity price of $0.16 per kWh, a heat pump operating at COP 2.0 would deliver heat for approximately $23.45 per million BTU. In this example, the heat pump remains substantially less expensive than propane even at a relatively modest COP.

That doesn’t mean the heat pump can necessarily meet the home’s heating load at every temperature. Capacity and manufacturer operating limits still matter. However, propane-heated homes may have a stronger economic incentive to operate a suitable cold-climate heat pump at lower outdoor temperatures than homes served by inexpensive natural gas.

How to Choose a Practical Heat Pump Lockout Setting

Once the economic balance point has been estimated, the next step is to check whether the heat pump can actually meet the home’s heating demand at that temperature. This requires comparing the home’s heat-loss calculation with the heat pump’s published heating-capacity data. If the heat pump becomes more expensive than the furnace at 30°F and can adequately heat the home above that temperature, a changeover around that point may be economically reasonable.

However, if the heat pump remains less expensive than the furnace down to 10°F but cannot meet the home’s heating load below 25°F, the system still needs an appropriate backup-heating strategy. In a conventional dual-fuel system that cannot run both heat sources simultaneously, the furnace may need to take over when the heat pump becomes unable to maintain comfort. Modern variable-capacity systems may use more sophisticated control logic, including outdoor temperature, indoor temperature error, operating time, and equipment capacity.

A good switchover strategy respects both the economic and thermal limits rather than relying on either one in isolation.

How to Set Auxiliary Heat Lockouts Without Sacrificing Comfort

For an all-electric heat pump with resistance backup, auxiliary heat lockout can be particularly important because electric resistance heating generally delivers approximately one unit of heat for each unit of electrical energy consumed. A heat pump operating at COP 3.0 can provide roughly three times as much heat per unit of electricity as resistance heating.

Preventing unnecessary resistance-heat operation during mild weather can therefore reduce energy consumption significantly. However, setting the auxiliary heat lockout too low or too restrictively may leave the home uncomfortable when the heat pump cannot meet the load. The proper setting depends on the heat pump’s available capacity, the building’s heating requirements, the thermostat’s staging logic, and manufacturer guidance. For dual-fuel systems using a gas furnace, the terminology and behavior can differ. Some controls provide separate compressor and fossil-fuel lockout settings, while others use one balance-point setting or a combination of outdoor temperature and indoor temperature droop.

Resideo’s published thermostat documentation describes several such control arrangements, including configurations that permit furnace operation in an intermediate temperature range when indoor temperature falls sufficiently below the setpoint. This is why copying another homeowner’s thermostat settings can be a mistake, even when both homes use heat pumps and gas furnaces.

Why Thermostat Droop and Recovery Settings Matter

Some dual-fuel thermostats can switch to the furnace when the indoor temperature falls a specified amount below the desired setpoint. This difference is often called temperature droop. For example, a thermostat may be configured to request furnace heating if the indoor temperature falls 2°F below the target temperature, subject to the thermostat’s control logic. Other thermostats use runtime limits, adaptive recovery, or equipment-specific staging strategies.

These features can improve comfort when a heat pump is temporarily unable to recover quickly from a temperature setback. However, overly aggressive furnace staging can reduce the economic benefits of the heat pump. A thermostat that routinely switches to gas whenever the homeowner raises the temperature several degrees may use the furnace even when the heat pump could have completed the recovery more economically. Moderate temperature setbacks, suitable recovery settings, and correct thermostat configuration can help reduce unnecessary backup heating.

Smart Thermostats and Dual-Fuel Optimization

A compatible smart thermostat can make dual-fuel operation more convenient by using outdoor temperature information, schedules, and equipment-specific settings. However, not every smart thermostat supports every dual-fuel configuration. Some systems require an outdoor temperature sensor, while others can use internet-based weather information. Manufacturer-integrated controls may also incorporate operating data that a generic thermostat cannot access.

Certain Resideo thermostat models explicitly support dual-fuel operation and auxiliary heat lockout features, demonstrating why it is important to select a thermostat with the appropriate control capabilities. For proprietary communicating HVAC systems, the manufacturer’s matching thermostat or control may be necessary to preserve full functionality.

I recommend verifying thermostat compatibility, staging capabilities, sensor requirements, and furnace-changeover logic before purchasing any replacement. A sophisticated thermostat is useful only when it is correctly configured for the equipment it controls.

Common Dual-Fuel Lockout Mistakes That Increase Heating Bills

One common mistake is setting the furnace changeover temperature unnecessarily high. This causes the furnace to run during conditions when the heat pump may still be the more economical heating source. Another mistake is assuming that the lowest possible heat pump lockout always produces the greatest savings. If the heat pump’s COP falls below the economic break-even point, continued operation may cost more than using the furnace.

Homeowners also sometimes confuse auxiliary heat with emergency heat. Auxiliary heating is normally activated automatically by the system when needed, while emergency heat is a separate operating mode on many thermostats. Incorrectly configuring a dual-fuel system as an all-electric heat pump can create serious control problems, including inappropriate equipment staging.

Outdoor temperature sensor placement and accuracy also matter. An incorrectly located or malfunctioning sensor can cause changeovers at the wrong time. Finally, homeowners should avoid repeatedly adjusting lockout temperatures based on a single unusually cold day. A meaningful evaluation should consider equipment performance, weather patterns, comfort, and energy costs over a reasonable period.

How to Tell Whether Your Lockout Settings Are Saving Money

The best way to evaluate a dual-fuel system is to examine both comfort and energy consumption. Begin by documenting the current thermostat settings, the heat pump model, furnace efficiency, and applicable electricity and fuel rates. Review utility bills alongside outdoor temperatures, recognizing that differences in weather and occupancy can affect comparisons. If the thermostat or equipment control provides runtime information, examine how frequently the heat pump and furnace operate under different conditions.

A homeowner may discover that the furnace is operating frequently during relatively mild weather, suggesting that the changeover settings deserve professional review. Conversely, if the heat pump runs for extended periods during cold weather while indoor temperatures steadily fall, the thermal balance point or equipment performance may need investigation. For the most accurate assessment, a contractor can measure system performance and use manufacturer data to compare the delivered heating cost of both sources.

Frequently Asked Questions About Dual-Fuel Balance Points

What is the best dual-fuel balance point temperature? There is no universal best temperature. The appropriate setting depends on the heat pump’s heating capacity and COP, the home’s heating load, local electricity and fuel prices, and the thermostat’s control strategy.

Should I lock out my heat pump below 35°F? Not automatically. Many heat pumps can operate efficiently below 35°F, and some cold-climate models are designed for much lower temperatures. The correct setting should be based on actual equipment performance and heating economics.

What is the difference between compressor lockout and auxiliary heat lockout? Compressor lockout prevents heat pump operation below a selected outdoor temperature. Auxiliary heat lockout prevents backup heating above a selected threshold, although exact behavior varies with equipment and thermostat configuration.

Is it cheaper to run a heat pump or gas furnace in winter? Either may be cheaper depending on electricity prices, gas prices, furnace efficiency, and the heat pump’s COP at the current outdoor temperature.

Does a dual-fuel system run the heat pump and furnace together? Many conventional integrated dual-fuel systems alternate between the heat pump and fossil-fuel furnace. Certain specially designed systems may use other operating arrangements, so the manufacturer’s instructions should determine acceptable operation.

Can I change dual-fuel lockout settings myself? Some thermostats allow homeowners to access these settings, but incorrect changes can affect comfort, operating costs, and equipment safety. A qualified HVAC technician should verify the configuration before changes are made.

Jake Lawson’s Final Advice: Let the Numbers Determine the Switchover

When I evaluate a dual-fuel heating system, I don’t begin by asking whether the heat pump should shut off at 30°F or 35°F. I begin by looking at the home’s heating load, the heat pump’s actual low-temperature performance, the furnace’s efficiency, and the homeowner’s energy prices. Those numbers establish whether the heat pump is capable of meeting the load and whether it is economical to continue using it. The thermostat then needs to implement that strategy without unnecessary furnace staging, excessive temperature swings, or conflicts with the equipment’s operating requirements.

For homeowners with expensive propane, a suitable cold-climate heat pump may remain economical at surprisingly low temperatures. For homeowners with inexpensive natural gas and high electricity rates, the economic crossover may occur much earlier. Neither situation justifies a universal lockout recommendation.

The best dual-fuel system is one that maintains dependable comfort while selecting the most appropriate heating source for the conditions. Before changing your lockout temperatures, have your installer verify the equipment’s performance data, calculate the thermal and economic balance points, and confirm the correct thermostat configuration. That’s how you turn a dual-fuel installation into a genuinely cost-conscious heating system rather than simply owning two heating appliances.

— Jake Lawson, HVAC Specialist | The Furnace Outlet

References & Further Reading

For a useful explanation of how electric heat pumps and gas furnaces work together, Carrier’s guide to dual-fuel heating systems discusses equipment operation, temperature-based changeovers, and the factors that influence heating performance and operating costs. It also explains why the appropriate switchover temperature varies according to equipment design, climate, and local energy prices.

The U.S. Department of Energy’s Building Science Education training on heat pump and dual-fuel thermostats provides educational resources about thermostat selection, equipment controls, and the differences between heat pump and backup heating operation. These materials are particularly helpful for understanding why thermostat configuration should match the actual heating equipment.

For homeowners interested in the technical details of balance-point control, Resideo’s VisionPRO IAQ thermostat documentation explains compressor lockouts, fossil-fuel changeovers, auxiliary heat lockouts, and temperature-droop strategies. Although the exact installer settings apply to that thermostat family, the control principles help illustrate how different dual-fuel operating strategies work.

The U.S. Department of Energy’s Standard Work Specifications for Single-Family Home Energy Upgrades includes guidance on heat pump thermostat selection, outdoor temperature sensing, supplemental heating controls, and manufacturer-based lockout settings. It reinforces the importance of preventing unnecessary backup heating while maintaining proper equipment operation.

For additional background on supplemental heating, Carrier’s explanation of auxiliary heat discusses how backup heating supports heat pumps during colder conditions and why the need for additional heat depends on the home’s heating load and the heat pump’s available capacity.

Share your love
Jake Lawson
Jake Lawson
Articles: 163

Remain Updated

Enter your email address below and subscribe to our newsletter for latest on HVAC

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Stay informed and not overwhelmed, subscribe now!